frenzy: pies can thank us for playing under the roof
frenzy: go easy on us Wellsy
pcaman2003: Just stay quiet WHE
mardyb: i wonder if theboos from all 6 norf supporters will put wells off…
th3rio: great call @pcaman
Torz: Will Larkey get a touch this week?
DrSeuss: Thank God I traded in Grundy and not Gawn….
Sixty656: Get stuffed Scharenburger
lukat: Good choice DrSeuss, Grundy will score more than 160 tonight 🙂
Sixty656: Gawn is dead thanks to mumford, so thats a win…
DrSeuss: Yeah just a slow start I am sure – traded in Grundy and Beams this week. Not looking good so far
th3rio: honest question…why would you guys go grundy over gawn? lol
th3rio: gawn has been on fire last 3 weeks
Texwalker: Wat r the pies paying mayne per year??
original: Grundy ffs cmon
Kermit: Kermit the Frog here with a Muppet News Flash: Lynden Dunn looks like Guy Smiley, but he’s not smiling.
Thedude24: Need 100+ from Grundy or I’m screwed. Come on dude
StuL: Come on higgins, pls try not to suck.
Pokerface: ‘on fire’ is a bit of an exaggeration
Pokerface: except for this week obviously
DrSeuss: If you compare the last 2 weeks they had both scored pretty equally
Pokerface: gawns also been under injury clouds the last couple of weeks
th3rio: Poker, apart from today, he got 108 and 111, the 108 he was off for 15 mins of the third with an ankle.
th3rio: Grundy the same, but feels like I see him under a ton more than i do over, probably why im bias lol
DrSeuss: So he had an injury? Th3rio?
Pokerface: that’s hardly on fire
th3rio: rolled his ankle, played the next week and still tonned up, you tell me Suess?
th3rio: Still tonned up the game he rolled it, I know who I’d trade in 🙂
Pokerface: over the last 3 weeks.. you are leaving out the 57 in that too th3rio
th3rio: Yeah, he was rubbish the first 3 weeks on his return, I can appreciate that. But the trade was done prior.
9inch: Go pies smash em.
DrSeuss: He is injury prone – thats why I chose Grundy – looks like a terrible choice this week – but as you said you are bias
JButcher: Bye bye Grundy hello Gawn
th3rio: Relax guys, I wasn’t attacking. I was just wondering your rationale based on the past 3 weeks between the 2.
Pinkman: i have both Gawn and Grundy so mixed feelings about this whole conversation 😉
th3rio: Grundy can go from 50 to 100+ real fast so don’t stress too much
DrSeuss: We werent attacking either – looking at the last couple of weeks they are pretty even. This week not so much.
original: Grundy points for smother? Plz say yes
th3rio: im just happy WHE is playing shit
9inch: I like Grundy think I’ll get him again next year. Only 23 yrs old
DrSeuss: Grundy normally scores from a lot of marks in play as well but pies kicking has been terrible so far
Pinkman: enjoying the way scharenberg going about things. covering JJ nicely thx
PowerBug: Bye Bye Brodie
StuL: Grundy has to go or the AFL is a joke. Identical to dangers.
Beast_Mode: gawn in, grundy out. that
AngryRyno: free kick for Grundy, and they’ll suspend him… bizarre system!
MattyZ: Brodie suspended and one of my fabourite players hurt :'(
biggerz: that ends grundy v gawn debate…
pcaman2003: Not identical at all. Danger held on well after ball release.
Breezey: Totally different to Dangers. Have a proper look
thommoae: Goodbye Norf too. Main big man gorn.
sfmmp23: It’s not identical to Dangers, Kruezer didn’t have the ball, Brown did. i think Grundy should be ok for that tackle
Pinkman: haha Grundy Gawn
StuL: Blow it out your hawk hole pacman.
original: Grundy will get off
thommoae: Interesting point – it can win you a game, that. Take a week or two for eliminating a team’s key man.
pcaman2003: Facts are facts Stuhl. The eyes see what they see.
Pinkman: didn’t see it, but hope so @original
StuL: The motion of the tackle itself was pretty much identical.
DrSeuss: Grundy should be ok – Brown got into trouble because he was more trying to handball rather than protect his fall
thommoae: You can’t slam a guy’s head just ‘cos he has the ball sfmmp
LMartos: considerable driven force, both arms pinned, 1 week
pcaman2003: Except Brown still had the ball.
sfmmp23: He didn’t slam his head, there was no sling motion
thommoae: How can you protect yer fall with arms pinned? With yer nose?
StuL: Kreuzer had the ball at first, i dont see how you pull out of a tackle in mid air.
sfmmp23: Brown was going down in the tackle and because Grundy was behind him, Grundy went down aswell, very unfortunate
sfmmp23: I understand I don’t think Danger should have been suspended either but Grundy’s tackle was pretty different to Dangers.
thommoae: You kidding? No slam of head? Is Brown fakin’ it?
original: Will be looked at, will get off
Yelse: did treloar come back on after the tackle?
thommoae: You don’t pull out, you just have a duty of care if his arms are pinned
Beast_Mode: i was the only one lst week who said danger is gone, the rest of the muppets here didnt agree
sfmmp23: I never said he didn’t slam his head. But I’m saying that Grundy didn’t have a slinging motion, wasn’t intentional
DrSeuss: Just because he hit his head doesnt mean it was slammed
Breezey: He hit his head on the ground. He didn’t slam his head.
sfmmp23: Grundy didn’t slam his head
Beast_Mode: pinned arms and a KTFO is the only thing that matters, he’ll get a week 100%
sfmmp23: There was no second motion, no slinging motion, clearly wasn’t intentional. Should be ok.
ajconodie: It’s interesting that Grundy received a free kick but is now looking at weeks yet Ziebell slung Treloar and was penalise
ajconodie: And nobody bats an eyelid. The rule is flawed.
original: Grundy was trying to hold him upright, the energy from fighting the tackle resulted in him lunging forward
frenzy: you guys didnt learn anything from danger last week
Beast_Mode: lol that doesn’t matter
Number 8: Muppet commentators trying to excuse the inexcusable. Grundy gone.
original: Wouldn’t be surprised if ziebell got a week and grundy got off
3rdstriker: Grundy perfect tackle but will definitely get a week. Players will now have to avoid taking players to ground in tackles
Number 8: Had his arms pinned 3rd. Why did he take him to ground? Stoopid Grundy
Sloan4Pres: Grundy must get 2 weeks minium
AngryRyno: why would Grundy get two weeks if Danger got 1? Brown actually had the ball
Sloan4Pres: Grundy’s was worse than Danger’s. By far
BestCoast: Grundy Grundy Grundy Grundy
AngryRyno: why? because it looked worse? or you actually have some useful information to back up your biased claims?
Breezey: Lot of shower getting spoken about now. 2 weeks please. Danger only got one
AngryRyno: Cunnington should be suspended for 3 weeks on your logic
Sloan4Pres: maybe because Brown was actually concussed. Kruezer wasn’t, landed on his shoulder
Bulky: Worst commentary team ever! It’s Tyson Goldsack not Todd Goldstein you stupid flog Darcy.
Heizenberg: Idiot Darby said Goldstein!!!!
original: Na kreuz didn’t have the ball tho and it was a slinging motion with head first.
Heizenberg: Hahaha I just put same bulky
AngryRyno: Kreuzer was concussed, how could you mistake that? been in the press all week, wakey wakey
kano: Sloan4pres for the burger
Number 8: For those who didn’t get the memo, Danger got 2, down to 1 for early plea
9inch: If I win this week and Grundy gets one week that will be good yes. 🙂
Sloan4Pres: Carlton will say he was, but it’s BS. Why’d he play this week then?
pcaman2003: @AngryRyno. LOL!Exactly!
Apachecats: Busy week at the MRP
Bulky: Luke Darcy and Basil Zempilas, the cream of the commentary crop. Said no-one ever!
AngryRyno: some people are more easily concussed than others, maybe if you put Grundy in Brown’s place there would be no concussion
AngryRyno: concussion affects people differently, some can shake it off, others miss the rest of the season eg. Kade Kolo
blashtroko: astronaut for phillips
Apachecats: Channel 7 kept calling it as Goldstein down instead of goldsack.
J.Worrall: 2 sides on the ground tonight – on is wearing white!
JButcher: Crisp has been a brilliant draft free agent pick up
CamT: 2 weeks for Grundy. Grundy didn’t try to keep on his feet.
StuL: Wells for 3 years looking a good call.
Beast_Mode: give the red cross to greenwood, he’s not coming back
Apachecats: funny thing about the ch 7 team ,none of them was game enough to correct the wrong call so it was repeated.
BestCoast: Rooboy must be coaching the Kangas today
StuL: If you havw a “duty of care” to
StuL: If you havw a “duty of care” to tackle “gently”,
StuL: Damn auto refresh. Forget it.
Beast_Mode: looks like goldsack is coming back on
The39Steps: Good bottle of red StuL?
runt: There is no need to smash someone into the turf when you have them well wrapped up in a tackle.
Apachecats: @stul if you have a mess
Apachecats: age chopped you don
StuL: Red? Thats elite bogan juice.
Apachecats: ‘t need to repeat it.just continue with it.
pcaman2003: Worst game of the year under perfect conditions.
StuL: North suck so bad.
pcaman2003: Both sides should be rubbed out for a week for this garbage.
runt: The usual flatulance from the Pies fans causing weird conditions under the roof
Number 8: Hands down worst game of the year
blashtroko: Give phillips the astronaut… 17 pos, 0 contested
m0nty: Q2 of the Dons game today was worse than this game
Number 8: Yeah, but was the commentary this bad too?
Number 8: Nothing to recommend this match whatsoever
DrSeuss: Come on Grundy – finish strong in your 1 game for my team this year
The39Steps: Only redeeming feature of this game is JZ. All heart, guts and grit.
Breezey: Heart for Grundy. Having to play most of this game knowing what rubbish has been written on FF
thommoae: Which camp is spouting the rubbish, Breezey?
BestCoast: @Breezey they cant have the Roos heart because they dont have one
Apachecats: Who told him @Breezy?
Breezey: I rang his mum at halftime Apache
LMartos: Not sure how Taylor Adams isn’t top 10 for clangers in the comp, seems to get at least 5 each week
Apachecats: ha ha ha breeze
Pokerface: that was me that answered breezey
Breezey: Very ladylike speaking voice Poker
Pokerface: haha touche 🙂
Gotigres: Get to 100 please Thomas.
JButcher: Cmon Crisp don’t stop
original: Thomas doesn’t deserve 100
Gotigres: Not after he stubbed his toe running into an open goal @original
Chat log from R20 of 2017: North Melbourne vs Collingwood
Chat log for North Melbourne vs Collingwood, R20 of 2017
frenzy: pies can thank us for playing under the roof
More in Chat log
Chat log for Collingwood vs Brisbane, GF of 2023
Chat log for Brisbane vs Carlton, PF of 2023
Chat log for Collingwood vs Western Sydney, PF of 2023
Chat log for Port Adelaide vs Western Sydney, SF of 2023