ReggieOz: Go Dees!
Baldfrog: Hope Jackson can ton up bit worried about max getting all the points
bc__: Go Blowey
zadolinnyj: let?s go green
pcaman2003: Hoping Kelly will have a better week after a poor effort round 4.
frenzy: Flynn could be in for a rough nite
zadolinnyj: Cameron said Whitfield has knee and foot issues. Why would they not get him right and rest him
kascadev8: go cogs, youre all i have
Baldfrog: oh god Eleni is umpiring
beerent11: Leon please get deboer onto clarry. Let?s get that be up even higher.
pcaman2003: Have 4 in this but Kelly my only POD.
hinsch: Oliver just put a little bit of effort in this week pls
kascadev8: ill tag you clarry
pcaman2003: Why does a backman like Bowey get benched after 4 minutes?
beerent11: Ranga on ranga action
zadolinnyj: Would love to see clarkson coaching gws. too much talent for what they give
Yelse: whitfield3 SC ? wtf
Migz: i saw whitfield get multiple ground balls and his CP has stayed at one and he went backwards. doesnt make sense to me
Migz: oh well
BRAZZERS: so many clangers form whitfield this season, so unlike him
DrSeuss: Agree Zado – Cameron needs to go
frenzy: people said don’t play the Perryman
Raspel31: Clayton, yes, you were a very naughty boy last week but prepared to forgive everything.
pcaman2003: See if you can find a team mate Kelly. Get your MOJO back please
beerent11: I don?t think I?ve ever seen a Melbourne supporter in the chat.
Hazza09: First Grundy now Gawn FFS
MrWalrus: Just want to say seeya later all, im done with this shit, see you in my next life
Baldfrog: Deesaresad Beer
zadolinnyj: I got Taranto so sorry everyone
Baldfrog: You say that every week Walrus
beerent11: Ahhh yes
pcaman2003: Shut the door on your way out.
beerent11: Green started well zad
Migz: oh walrus. i was the eagles game last night and im still here. quit ya bitching haha
frenzy: salty walrus
zadolinnyj: I know umps are ruuining the game MrWalrus but don?t go. Keep the faith
Baldfrog: Walrus should have been an actor very dramatic
beerent11: Toys out the cot
Catatafish: Hayes is my premo ruckman..
Baldfrog: They are zad thats why im back going to sturt games
zadolinnyj: GWS enrries disgusting
Yelse: geez this year premiums aren’t consistent mid as well have had all mid pricers
Migz: whitfield has been shafted more than what walrus thinks the tiggers were shafted
Catatafish: Whitfield has been consistently frustrating so far
BRAZZERS: walrus a sook
zadolinnyj: If I was back in Adelaide would go with you Ballfrog. Central?s fan but love the Sturt jumper
Migz: also my amazing either to back up gawns C last week with a C this week instead of macca … bad idea so far
BigChief: Lets go C Preuss. I want 150 from you.
Baldfrog: Just find the umps are fair in the sanfl zad
Yelse: whitfield score def wrong but CD won’t correct it
zadolinnyj: Need the double blues in afl
DrSeuss: Maxy not getting any marks or possessions so far – was marking everything last week
BigChief: Zado you like the baby blue jumper?
zadolinnyj: See what you did there BigChief
pcaman2003: Thought Kelly was my only POD this game,but have Bowey too. Come on you two.
Baldfrog: Nearly folded 10 years ago doubt that would happen
exatekk: walrus still crying?
zadolinnyj: And atmosphere makes you feel like ur in the game Ballfrog
Catatafish: Whitfield score was right, now a bit silly
kascadev8: time to start tagging Ash boy
zadolinnyj: The jumper not the team Ballfrog
Baldfrog: oh soz zado
Raspel31: Being new to this game why does the tall, expensive man Gorn do nuffink?
zadolinnyj: like the 80s and 90s doudle blues jumper
pcaman2003: Kelly was a sublime user of the ball once. What happened?
Baldfrog: signed a million a year deal pcaman doesn’t have to try anymore
Baldfrog: Look at grundy pcaman
BigChief: Raspel I think he is there for his beard.
beerent11: Jackson and Gawn total 13 points
pcaman2003: Baldfrog. Quite possibly. He’s just not with this year.
Raspel31: Ah, danke BigChief- ist gut ja?
BigChief: Almost as good as Grizzly Adams Raspel 🙂
Baldfrog: Is rasp impersonating a Jamaican tonight?
Yelse: all 3 rucks his game struggling
Baldfrog: Jackson to pruess soon
zadolinnyj: Grizzly Adam?s did have a beard. Happy gilmore
Hazza09: Obviously no tags tonight on Oliver, but 2 weeks ago Cameron the flog double tagged Touk
beerent11: Is pruess a keeper baldfrog?
BigChief: Lol Zado.
Baldfrog: Probably not Beer but where do we make money from?
Baldfrog: decent roookies very hard to find
cmperrfect: Its Pruenglish all the way for me this year.
beerent11: Tough one. I?m keeping Jackson til I can get to a premo. And chucking him into the fwd line.
kascadev8: stop clarry
beerent11: With him or xerri
BigChief: Whitfield looks cooked already. Can’t even run.
pcaman2003: Is Whitty cooked already. He’s a delicate creature.
colin wood: Whitfield done a rib?
Baldfrog: you can do that to beer havent used many trades and need to make more money
Baldfrog: Missed xerri got brodie
BRAZZERS: max flicked the switch
Hazza09: So nobody tagging Oliver?
cmperrfect: Hey m0nty, landscape on a mob device hides the team scores. FYI.
pcaman2003: Off the bench Bowey and get that ball.
Baldfrog: Melb getting lots of time to dispose of the ball
dabombers: Who are we bringing in next week. Time to cull Rowell and JHF i reckon.
kascadev8: rowell to green
Badgerbadg: langdon kinda looks like jesus
zadolinnyj: Horne still cash to come.
Baldfrog: Keeping JHF but dunno Rowell to
Dredd: Time to cull Grundy too
zadolinnyj: Okeefe was bad at Collingwood. How is he still playing
Catatafish: Depends on rookie scenario, but Rowell likely upgrade to a Touk or Steele for me
Ninty: Time to cull Whitfield. How?s the DT > SC conversion dead set yuck
dabombers: JHF is my M10 over last 3 weeks. BE will be borderline from now on.
zadolinnyj: Rowell to smith
pcaman2003: Rowell to Steele or Boak for me.
pjw1234: rowell to prestia might get it for free
TheLegend6: Prestia will be good for 3 weeks then get an injury
BigChief: Might be Rowell to Bailey Smith.
zadolinnyj: Sparrow thought he was one
dabombers: Gonna be a tough 3-4 weeks. Boosts in maybe 1 or two of them. Rosas and Pruest are def ins for me next week.
Yelse: rowell to green for me
pcaman2003: Thata boy Bowey. Keep going
colin wood: Get stuffed Ellani
zadolinnyj: rubbish free.great goal
Social: Evning legends, what happened in adlaide?
Baldfrog: Problem with dogs mids Chief is they take turns at scoring
Baldfrog: Ask Walrus Social
kascadev8: go crom, social
wadaramus: What’s wrong with Jacko’s SC, is DE is good?
Social: not the umps again
Hazza09: So Rowell and Grundy getting traded next week?
Baldfrog: What made u think that Social?
kascadev8: should just be rowell hazza
BigChief: Wada looks okay to me. 44 DT and 43 SC
Dredd: Without a doubt Hazza
Baldfrog: max came good why cant Grundy?
Dredd: Praying Oliver and Green can over Rioli and Short?s rubbish scores
BigChief: Baldfrog because Coll play 5 200cm players.
Baldfrog: Green is the one can he keep going all season?
NewFreoFan: Eleni having a mare
Baldfrog: True Chief but the yank should be gone this week
Hazza09: I?m liking Rowell to Green
Baldfrog: Eleni always has a mare
Social: the yank only got a fine
pcaman2003: Nice qtr Kelly and Bowey.
Baldfrog: Yeah social didn’t mean that he’s just a liability all round
Social: agree baldfrog, but looks super cool doing it
Baldfrog: lol Social those sunnies are appalling
Social: Corey Hart wants them back
Baldfrog: He should oinly play at marvel suits his superhero style
Yelse: grundy will be back drop cox and maybe cameron and he will get more than 65 TOG
thesilentl: Cameron has a broken rib so he’s gone. Cox out for mihocek
Pokerface: it wasnt grundys TOG that was the issue. It was his ability when he was on the ground
thesilentl: Grundy will come good, elite players don’t just forget how to play forever
Pokerface: yes but their attitude can
the dud: Ed Langdon missing a tackle
frenzy: Grunds price starting with a 4, yes please
BigChief: Sloane injury looks serious. Poor bastard if that’s the case.
Pokerface: grundy actually ahsnt been good for a couple of years. he blamed it on the bubbles etc, but would be good this year.
Pokerface: seems no different at all. i think he’s done as an uber
Baldfrog: None of the players on mega contracts Dusty Kelly or Grundy have been as good compared to pre contract.
Pokerface: and buddy. but i guess he’s 10 years older now 🙂
BRAZZERS: lol dusty was injured last season and hasnt played this year, still won a prem after contract year.
NewFreoFan: Heeney has started his mega contract pretty well
zadolinnyj: That?s why contracts in nfl still mean you have to play well to get the big bucks
Baldfrog: Buddy;s the luckiest 3 games a year for a million
zadolinnyj: Dusty not about the money
Baldfrog: Brazzers you cant say that dusty has been as good really?
Pokerface: aaaah.. you forget dusty shopping himself around several years ago?
Pokerface: and noone wanted his asking price?
BRAZZERS: he’s already cemented himself as the greatest player to play the sport, not much left to prove nackers
zadolinnyj: Agents asking price
Pokerface: lmao, the greats play good consistently. not just when they can be bothered
mattmac24: Dusty the greatest player to play the sport..? Sorry what? He is a brilliant player but not the greatest
BRAZZERS: like danger? lol. dusty gets it done when it matters
BigChief: Dusty not even top 10 ever.
Pokerface: where did i claim danger was the greatest player to play?
beerent11: Hahaha brazzers you troll. Works every time.
Baldfrog: Brazzers must be under 20 seen many brillianbt players in my lifetime
NewFreoFan: Best ever is an impossible task, too hard to compare players across different eras
zadolinnyj: Leigh Matthew?s and gary Ablett jr went alright
Ash777: yeah no greatest is not in this decade
Baldfrog: Barry Robran and Poly Farmer
BRAZZERS: 3 norms 3 flags, jordan level. case closed, lol matthews already said Dusty is the best player he’s ever seen
Baldfrog: Russell Ebert was bloody good
Pokerface: flag doesnt make u great. flag is a team thing. many many greats dont get a chance at norm
zadolinnyj: Correct NewFreoFan. The Jordan Lebrun debate. Jordan bye the way
beerent11: Got em all biting. Waters boiling.
Pokerface: midfielders medal in any case
NewFreoFan: Besides we all know the goat was Pav
Ash777: lmao mathews
pjw1234: Dusty was top 10 in games that matter
zadolinnyj: Andrew McLeod got two in a row in to gfs and not even close
BRAZZERS: it does when you dominate them
Pokerface: dermot brereton won 5 flags. guess that makes him greater brazzers?
Baldfrog: Thought Wayne Carey was the greatest seems to change every couple of years these days
Pokerface: he took houli’s medal in one and picketts medal in another
BRAZZERS: you can make the agrument his isn’t, i can make one he is. so no one will win the discussion. its all subjective
zadolinnyj: Zac Dawson was amazing from first game but no medals or gfs
pcaman2003: Why did Kelly have an effective disposal and drop from 69 to 66? Very confusing!
Yelse: back to the game whitfield going backwards
Ash777: If you look at norms smith winners you know it’s a pot luck
NewFreoFan: No I won the discussion, it’s Pavlich, the Superpav
mattmac24: Trolling or not, he down right is not the greatest to ever play the game.
BigChief: Relton 100x better than Dusty
zadolinnyj: Surely Shane woewodin.
Pokerface: i will admit, he does have the most chopstick threats of all the greats
NewFreoFan: Damn, how did Relton take this long to get mentioned
kascadev8: dusty not as good
zadolinnyj: BigChief for the win
Pokerface: zad, brazzers is too young to know who that is
NewFreoFan: Relton narrowly ahead of Tambling
hinsch: Finish the argument Reece Jones has been suspended more that Toby Greene
Pokerface: relton is still rotting away on my bench as we speak
thesilentl: Arms out 50 @bigchief, time to stop sooking about it
NewFreoFan: Kosi wowee
Baldfrog: lol thanks freofan was googling trying to find his name
zadolinnyj: If I was the herald sun sc team I would hire Felton for special comments
NewFreoFan: Demons just doing party tricks now
zadolinnyj: Gee Melbourne are in beast mode
Badgerbadg: dees flicked the switch after than ump respect 50m
mattmac24: One of my opponents has May, Ward and Flynn.. what a week to go up against a weird team
NewFreoFan: Can’t disrespect the umpires so they’re disrespecting the giants
Oddsy5: gawn = beast
pcaman2003: Get back out there Kelly. I need more points from you.
Baldfrog: Not looking good Matt
beerent11: They should keep Flynn instead of pruess
Pokerface: that would set the sc pundits alight 🙂
m0nty: they should play Flynn and Preuss tbh
zadolinnyj: Wonder who fell for brayshaw
NewFreoFan: they need to try something, underperforming with their list so far this year
Badgerbadg: Dees are still such a feel good story- they were terrible for so long! I remember when they coped 200 against the cats
Hazza09: Will they play both Flynn and Pruess?
Ash777: other than the tanking you mean badger?
zadolinnyj: Will be hard to drop flynn
NewFreoFan: Who’s fired first, Cameron or Hinkley
Hazza09: Flynn and Pruess together is not ideal
Badgerbadg: Tanking to get scully and trengove? lol
Ninty: Please tell me there?s a 1 missing in front of Whits SC score
Baldfrog: They wont feel as good if you stop feeling it
Baldfrog: Hinkley needs an extension
beerent11: This is the first week my Jackson r2 risk has hurt me.
pcaman2003: Get the ball Bowey. You’ve gone to sleep.
Stu7: Gawny to go massive
NewFreoFan: bit of bias there Baldfrog?
Baldfrog: Never Freofan just enjoy seeing his coke cans week after week
zadolinnyj: Bobby hill awful
NewFreoFan: Bring Choco back
dabombers: Im liking the SC update trade. As scores change so does trade plans. Updated 3x since round started.
kascadev8: why have you not used Ash to tag at all mr cameron
Catatafish: Whitfield out asap. Even getting the ball he’s clearly fucked someone’s wife at CD.
NewFreoFan: tag who? Oliver? Trac? Viney? the others can cover
pcaman2003: You’re allowed to tackle Kelly and kick the ball instead of constant HB.
mattmac24: Whitfield has had 2 contested possessions. Too much easy ball so scoring minimal points
wadaramus: Jackson spending a long time on the pine?
pcaman2003: Onya Bowey! Take a bow.
Baldfrog: Epl time then replay Crom v sooky sooky lalas
Ash777: lol every time bowey gets the ball the commentators have to talk about him not losing a game.
kascadev8: Ash777 did you know that Bowey is gonna have 12 wins from 12 games? incredible
beerent11: Was limping at the top of the screen earlier in the game wadaramus
NewFreoFan: Bowey not losing is the new Pendles basketball background
Catatafish: I agree with that, but almost 30 points leas and DE 71% can’t be that bad
pcaman2003: Bowey only 7 pts for intercept mark and goal.. Surely the goes up to well over 70
Ash777: Odds on Cameron to coach the next game?
dabombers: Take Cogs score or take a ping with Caldwell?
marls: Supermaning the whole team is so lame
pcaman2003: Hang your head Kelly for a terrible 11pt qtr.
zadolinnyj: Is that a serious question dabombers
Malaka: If Melbourne play their cards right, they could win this.
dabombers: Yeah. Traded back in Cripps to use as loophole. Not sure.
zadolinnyj: Cogs on track for 100
beerent11: You trade Cripps out and then back in to use a loophole?
dabombers: Caldwell due for a 120 at Marvel soon.
bc__: Whitfield get a heart for?
pcaman2003: Bowey owners won’t be happy with the low score he got for the intercept mark and goal. From 62 to 68. Go figure!
dabombers: Changed plans @beer. Decided Butters was better out over Cripps or Ridley to get in Gawn this week. Changed mind 4 times
zadolinnyj: He asked the wizard for it bc
DropCox: @zado he should have asked for courage
zadolinnyj: Bedford unlucky monty
Stu7: Off the pine Bowey
pcaman2003: Bowey finally on.
Social: Good to see Bruhn getting a decent run
banta: Why Jackson such low tog? Game is all tied up. Surely rest gawn and play the kid. So weird.
pcaman2003: C’mon Bowey and Kelly. Don’t stop now.
wadaramus: Jacko getting massive arse splinters.
m0nty: nominations for star please
loc1477: Green has been huge! Not sure what game the scorers are watching this second half he should be on 120-130
rupertmarn: Will Flynn keep Preuss out?
exatekk: rest the captain?? HAHA
exatekk: Gawn monty
frenzy: looks likely rupertman
pcaman2003: GWS are a rabble and the coach will be looking for a new job soon.
beerent11: They?re playing the best team in the comp by a mile.
thommoae: Dees will do this to other teams this year; they are a class above the League at this point.
zadolinnyj: GWS to use two rucks
Social: off the pine conigs
zadolinnyj: Look at that calf spasm
colin wood: Gawn surely to scale up well here
Oddsy5: dees are that good its good to watch. one of the 3 teams i like lol
Hazza09: How is Gawn only 125
zadolinnyj: Not many points left
kascadev8: have the last 3 mins off Green, youve deserved it
zadolinnyj: Not often the crows himmelberg does better then gws one
colin wood: Zado they?ll just take them off the no namers happens all the time
zadolinnyj: Anyone getting Toby greene
J.Worrall: Star for May – when else does a defender get it?
thommoae: Pcaman – Giants ain’t a rabble. outclassed tonight but they’ll be back.
dabombers: Cameron might have had enough of coaching.
J.Worrall: no scaling needed
NewFreoFan: they’re 1-4 at 73%, rabble like
Social: Hes achieved nothing with a squad of top picks
m0nty: new icon
BurtCocain: shitfield is gone after this week, why did i hold onto him
Chat log from R5 of 2022: Melbourne vs Western Sydney
Chat log for Melbourne vs Western Sydney, R5 of 2022
ReggieOz: Go Dees!
More in Chat log
Chat log for Collingwood vs Brisbane, GF of 2023
Chat log for Brisbane vs Carlton, PF of 2023
Chat log for Collingwood vs Western Sydney, PF of 2023
Chat log for Port Adelaide vs Western Sydney, SF of 2023