Connect with us

2009 cheat cheet

2008’s mature age AFL draftees

Mature age AFL draftees

One of the things fantasy coaches always look for in national AFL drafts is the mature age player: a player who for whatever reason comes into the league significantly older than the 17 to 18 years of age that is the norm among AFL draftees. Think Darren Pfeiffer from last year’s draft, or Alwyn Davey of a couple of seasons ago. There are a handful of young men who fit the bill this year who should factor into your decisions.

Hayden Ballantyne – Fremantle small forward (FWD), 175cm, unknown weight, 16 July 1987
Everyone should know Ballantyne’s story by now: set to replace Jeff Farmer as the Dockers’ primary goalscoring small forward, he has been tearing up the WAFL to the tune of 75 goals this year and the Sandover Medal playing for Peel Thunder. It is no surprise that Ballantyne has now surpassed Chris Yarran as by far the most popular bench forward in the Fanplanner – albeit that half of the reason for that is Yarran is now the most popular starting forward, with Ballantyne shooting up the charts in starting 22s as well. I gave the Dockers a lot of stick for picking Hill over Rich, but choosing Ballantyne is a pleasing sign that the club want to start winning games now, not just warehousing talented kids for the long term. Perhaps surprisingly, Docker fans are not enthused with this pick. Ballantyne’s lack of upside is offset by the fact that, like Rich, he has honed his game in one of the two best feeder comps in the country to be of ready made AFL standard. I’m sure they’ll come around with a few Purple Jesus poses and, most importantly, some bags of goals early in the season.

Liam Anthony – North Melbourne medium outside midfielder (CTR), 189cm, 87kg, 9 September 1987
Another boy who played with the men in the WAFL this year, in this case for most of East Fremantle’s season. Quick and with good skills, Anthony is nonetheless coming under the baleful eye of Dean Laidley, Fantasy Antichrist, which means NO GAMES FOR YOU! Okay, maybe a couple to tease you, then it’s straight to the VFL seconds for the duration. Seriously, I can not make this clear enough. Do not buy North draftees. You know it to be true.

Rohan Bail – Melbourne medium forward (FWD/CTR), 183cm, 78kg, 26 June 1988
Not much is known about this kid. Apparently he was rookie of the year in the QAFL (starting to see a pattern, are we?) playing for Mount Gravatt on a wing, including four goals in the grand final, with major assets including endurance running and goal sense. In case you’re wondering why he wasn’t picked up in previous drafts, injuries are the excuse, though exactly what those injuries were isn’t disclosed. As far as his fantasy potential, you’d have to look at similarly gifted junior sportsmen like Tim Clarke, who made to the AFL based almost solely on their aerobic and athletic abilities, but couldn’t cut it because they weren’t good enough footballers. Bail will have to overcome the problem that Clarke couldn’t before you can consider him for fantasy, I suspect.

Mitch Robinson – Carlton medium outside midfielder (CTR), 192cm, 78kg, 7 July 1989
Robinson barely qualifies on this list as he will still be 19 once the season starts, but he does have six months on every draftee other than the aforementioned. His cachet is built mostly on an outstanding under 18 championships, where he was not only the best for Tasmania but for the whole of division 2, culminating in All-Australian selection. Some junior reports talk up his high possession rate, his long kicking and his defensive work, while others express concerns about his selfish attitude and his clanger count. Robinson will be ready to play fairly early. Will the coach give him free rein, or keep him at the Bullants to work on his negatives? He sounds like a natural-born braggadocio Blue, so maybe this is the perfect club for him. Follow him on and off the field in the preseason for his mental progress more than the physical.

Other players at the top end of draftee ages included Jaydyn Post, Jamie Bennell, Dayne Beams, Neville Jetta and David Zaharakis. Undrafted players who are in this range include Steven Gaertner and Luke Stanton, both of whom should be rookied in due course.

Have you already twigged on Ballantyne? Does Anthony tempt you despite Dean’s devilry? Do you know any more about Bail than the rest of us? How about Robinson, are you as arrogant as he is, arrogant enough to buy him? Let me know in the comments.



  1. Dazza

    December 1, 2008 at 8:49 pm

    You could probably throw Davenport on that list as well. Even though he is recycled he is still at basement price (as opposed to someone like Hislop).

  2. m0nty

    December 1, 2008 at 8:52 pm

    Davenport will be on a separate list I’ll blog about soon, of older players who have been on lists for a while who are still at draftee prices.

  3. Nick

    December 2, 2008 at 2:47 am

    Speaking of Davenport, I couldn’t find him in Planteam

  4. Captain Fantasy

    December 2, 2008 at 6:46 am

    I’m very keen on Mitch Robinson, but I’m not sure how where he fits at a club who probably doesn’t need nor deserve him.

  5. Chad

    December 2, 2008 at 7:22 am

    Davenport isn’t in the planner. Based on last year ( he would be a MID, 91900

  6. m0nty

    December 2, 2008 at 8:34 am

    I’ve now added Davenport.

  7. Chad

    December 2, 2008 at 8:58 am

    When the picked up Davenport they said he was hopefully a “rodan-like” pickup. But i dont know how he will get into the midfield.

    Cornes,Kornes,Shaun Burgoyne,Cassisi,Salopek,Rodan,Pearce and will Hartlett get games?

    Maybe Salopek will be in the backline a bit more this year.

  8. Warnie

    December 2, 2008 at 9:04 am

    Yeah – Mitch Robinson… argh!! Just about anywhere else you’d pretty much guarentee him in your DT side at some stage this year. Could be play in Carlton’s backline?

  9. Nick

    December 2, 2008 at 9:36 am

    Chad, Hartlett probably needs more time to develop yet. Obviously with a strong core midfield, a side can afford to carry a young player with plenty of potential, but in Port’s case I think it’s hardly necessary (especially when you include Boak aswell!)

    The comment about a Rodan type role came from their recruiter. To me that indicates they fully intend to play him. It is hard to see where, but Salopek is often injured and Pearce has done very little since his Rising Star win. Spots will open up.

  10. XztatiK

    December 2, 2008 at 11:59 pm

    Add James Boyd to the list if he gets rookied.

  11. XztatiK

    December 3, 2008 at 12:03 am

    “but choosing Ballantyne is a pleasing sign that the club want to start winning games now, not just warehousing talented kids for the long term. Perhaps surprisingly, Docker fans are not enthused with this pick.”

    The only bad thing about this pick is they could’ve left him till 24, and got Jackson Trengrove at 21. (come on, it’s Freo! They had to stuff it up somehow.) They probably would’ve even been able to get him at 37.

  12. harry

    December 4, 2008 at 10:38 am

    Davenport could play as a HFF, Port don’t have great depth there.

  13. Dolbz

    February 17, 2009 at 9:52 am

    Salopek drifted back in the Intra-club match, I’d say that’s where he’ll stay this year.

    Burgoyne and C. Cornes play all over the shop, depending on their opponent and Williams likes to put Pearce and Rodan forward. Kornes can tag, as can Cassisi, so all their players apart from perhaps Boak can go anywhere, meaning there is room for Hartleet once he’s ready and depends on how the other guys go.
    Rich and Dangerfield are much better options though.

  14. EvilOverlord

    March 18, 2009 at 7:27 pm


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in 2009 cheat cheet