Connect with us

Talking Points

Contenders or pretenders?: Round 12A wrap (Sunday)

Round 12A wrap (Sunday)

A determined Brisbane Lions embarrassed Hawthorn in Tassie with a 42 point thrashing.

AFL Rd 12 - Brisbane Lions v Western BulldogsThe Lions set up their win in the third quarter, kicking 4.4 to 1.1 against the wind. The Lions had more tackles (83 to 53) and won more contested ball (129 to 95), and out coached the Hawks in the second half. Hawthorn fans who were expecting a fight back in the last quarter would have been bitterly disappointed with the insipid capitulation. Brisbane had as many, if not more, critical players missing through injury as Hawthorn. The Hawks coaching panel have a lot to think about over the break, including the tactic of going into a game with three rucks.

The Lions, already missing three important defenders, lost Troy Selwood to injury in the first quarter. Luke Power (DT154/SC162) started in the back line then moved to the centre, and accumulated a game high 36 disposals. Jonathon Brown (99/130) stepped up when it mattered most to kick four second half goals in a low scoring game. Most Lions players wanted the ball more than their Hawthorn opponents did. Brisbane scored 1766 to 1536 in SC, with an amazing nine players scoring tons.

For the Hawks, Sam Mitchell (132/142) and Brad Sewell (95/120) tried hard, but too many Hawks were missing in action. Lance Franklin (32/23) suffered from bad delivery and an overly negative game plan that dragged Hawthorn’s forwards up the ground, leaving him outnumbered. Just when you thought his price had bottomed out, it seems there will be at least two more price drops. When he finally turns it around, he will be at unbelievably low price.

The match up of Beau Muston (52/27) and Daniel Rich (74/102) would have left many fantasy coaches in a no win situation. Those coaches that have kept Rich will probably decide he’s too good to trade out now. In the last three weeks he has averaged 88 in DT and 108 in SC.

In Adelaide, the Crows won a rain-affected gain against the Kangaroos by 44 points. The wet conditions disguised what was really an extremely dominant performance by Adelaide. It was 65 inside 50s to 34 and 23 scoring shots to nine. The win means Adelaide have jumped at least three spots on the ladder, passing Port, Hawthorn and Carlton.

Michael Doughty (132/139) continued his impressive form and will be a tempting upgrade for fantasy coaches. Andy Otten (92/122) returned to form and should be retained by those coaches who still have him.

For the Kangaroos, Hamish McIntosh (106/116) did amazingly well in the conditions, with 20 disposals and 23 hit outs. For those brave coaches who chose him, Nathan Grima (90/113) is proving to be an excellent rookie defender. Sadly, Jack Ziebell (23/10) went down with what may be a serious leg injury. For the 80,000 fantasy coaches who still have him, his price will drop by about $26k in DT.

So with Part A of round 12 finished, how is your team going? What type of score are you heading for?



  1. Disco DB

    June 15, 2009 at 6:20 am

    3 rucks? 2 rucks and a CHB. Desperate times, desperate measures. Gilly might be back next match, so a ruck will go anyway.

  2. Toolavich

    June 15, 2009 at 1:29 pm

    In SC only m0nty. Have 1225 points from 14 players with GAJ Capt, Swan, Tarks, Grimes, Pav, Sidebottom, Didak, and Chappy to come.

    Plan now is to trade Petrenko or Suban for some random kid for $$$ and upgrade Ziebell to ROK with the cash as I have $170K in the bank already. Fingers crossed for Goodwin for the rest of the year also.

    Had Otten on the ground from the start, should win Rising Star award…had Rich from the start too but had him on the bench all year as backup for injury. Haven’t needed him yet.

    Keep up the great work m0nty.

  3. mmile09

    June 15, 2009 at 2:14 pm

    Keep up the good work Monty – Love the daily blogs over the weekend!

  4. tom_rox2

    June 15, 2009 at 5:31 pm

    in sc im 1334 from 14 players with Davis, Pav, Chapman, Ablett (c), Bartel, Enright, grimes and cheney if he plays if not then broughton will come into play =). Hopefully will get around the 2200-2300 mark.
    My plans for next week are to Upgrade Ziebell to Brown.

  5. hairydog84

    June 15, 2009 at 7:10 pm

    need c cornes and drummo back in my backs 🙁

  6. Oxym0ron

    June 15, 2009 at 10:59 pm

    a fair suck of the sauce bottle m0nty – Adelaide are behind on percentages yet they don’t have the same premium list as Brisbane

    Brisbane has:
    Melb, Port, Geelong, Freo, North Melb, Pies, Ess, Doggies, Port and Sydney

    Adelaide has:
    Syd, Richmond, Freo, Saints, Port, Geelong, Pies, Hawks, Eagles & Carlton

    The run home is even stevens


  7. SimonOz

    June 16, 2009 at 8:39 am

    Will JayZ to JBrown be the big trade next week like Must-Have was two weeks ago?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Talking Points