WXV Trade Talk

[Ricochet]

Yarran played more VFL games and Oxley this year...

true but he isnt a VFL player called up to the AFL, he is a clear AFL talent who has had a tough year. I reckon its because they knew he was leaving and he was unhappy and had just given up. Put him at the tiges were they push for a flag and watch out.

and yet word this morning is Carlton can't get rid of him so they may keep him

[Holz]

Yarran played more VFL games and Oxley this year...

true but he isnt a VFL player called up to the AFL, he is a clear AFL talent who has had a tough year. I reckon its because they knew he was leaving and he was unhappy and had just given up. Put him at the tiges were they push for a flag and watch out.

and yet word this morning is Carlton can't get rid of him so they may keep him

not how i read the article. It said he was a small chance of staying. He is a contracted so they need a trade they like, so they are just playing hardball. they also said they wont try to talk players who dont want to play for them into staying.

They are just going for the best deal for him. The talk is they want Ben Lennon for him, thats not being able to give him away. The tigers love Lennon and rightly so the kid is really good.

[Jroo]

Haha I don't need to say anything,  I know that trade is fair.

But since Holz is selling my guys short, I'll just add this. MJ averages closer to 90, than he does to 80. You can't say MJ is injury prone, haven't looked at the numbers but I'd say Yaz is just as bad.

Ox showed he can score well. Rumours going around he could be on the move to Brisbane, so don't think JS is a huge issue.

[meow meow]

He played 17 games this year, and was rested for 2 games.

Players don't get rested 2 weeks in a row. He lost his spot and couldn't get it back straight away since he's not a lock in the 22. He got opportunities because Shaz and Sinclair were injured, and by the end of the season Marsh and Maynard had overtaken Ox.

Brown, Frost and Reid makes 2-3
Toovey, Langdon and Williams makes it 5-6
Scharenberg picks himself.
Marsh held Ox out of the team and looks a better prospect if you focus on AFL not SC
Sinclair plays every week if he's fit since Bucks loves him.
Maynard showed plenty in his first AFL season.
Varcoe plays a little off half back, and with Treloar coming in Pendles and Sidey are tipped to play a little more down back too.

Can't see how Oxley is best 22 at the Pies. Brad Hill is worth more. 39 for Jamar evens it up a little but MC are still winning so far IMO

So Yaz vs MJ. Should score about the same over the next two years so that's all good. Then MJ retires and Mexico City still have a 26 year old potential (averaged 87 before and 90 unsubbed last year) premo defender on their hands for 5 more seasons.

[meow meow]

Mexico City wouldn't do the trade if they didn't think they were winning.
Holz says MC are winning.
I say MC are winning.

Coincidence that the teams that finished 1-3 this year all think that MC are winning?

[Holz]

The trade talk has occurred Meow.

will leave it up to the voting system and see how that plays out.

it does feel strange us agreeing on something though.

[meow meow]

Rocky is overrated.

[Ricochet]

He played 17 games this year, and was rested for 2 games.

Players don't get rested 2 weeks in a row. He lost his spot and couldn't get it back straight away since he's not a lock in the 22. He got opportunities because Shaz and Sinclair were injured, and by the end of the season Marsh and Maynard had overtaken Ox.

He didn't play for 3 weeks, at any level. That's not being pushed out, losing your spot or dropped.

Not sure why you boys don't rate him, he's had a pretty decent year. Wouldn't mind him down at NDT :P

[Holz]

He played 17 games this year, and was rested for 2 games.

Players don't get rested 2 weeks in a row. He lost his spot and couldn't get it back straight away since he's not a lock in the 22. He got opportunities because Shaz and Sinclair were injured, and by the end of the season Marsh and Maynard had overtaken Ox.

He didn't play for 3 weeks, at any level. That's not being pushed out, losing your spot or dropped.

Not sure why you boys don't rate him, he's had a pretty decent year. Wouldn't mind him down at NDT :P

he is ok

Meow states a pretty good case.

Brown, Frost and Reid makes 2-3
Toovey, Langdon and Williams makes it 5-6
Scharenberg picks himself.

Marsh and Maynard i rate and i think will get the nod of Oxley. Varcoe can play in a few different spots.

there are only 3-4 spots open in the team for a player like him and i have him like 6-8 in the cue for it. Thats why I dont rate him.

Pies actually have a decent young list

I wouldnt want to see him at NDT i would love for you to have Yarran though.

[Purple 77]

5 coaches still to vote.

Only two trades have attracted one vote each.

[RaisyDaisy]

haven't spoken about trades with anyone for about a week now and feels weird lol

If anyone is interested in any of our players then contact me! I want to get back into the loop of talking trades  ;D

[Vinny]

Been very busy lately, but keen to talk trades now as I won't be able to through Friday and the weekend.

Looking for forwards mainly, willing to lose one of I.Smith, A.Swallow, R.Douglas, B.Cunnington for one.

Also looking for depth in all lines. All NAT picks including 3 can be moved, packaged etc.

Hit me up!

[Levi434]

Vince going to be traded shortly. Have a good offer lined up so if you are to beat it'll need to be good.

[RaisyDaisy]

If any of the following players interest you then hit me up with an offer

Sam Fisher
Matt Rosa
Heath Hocking
Andrew Boston
James Harmes
Claye Beams
Alex Sexton
Mike Pyke
Travis Cloke
Jarrad Waite
Jesse White
Brodie Murdoch
Orazio Fantasia
Logan Austin
Jordan Cunico
Teia Miles
Todd Elton

We will be de-listing these players so you can have them for next to nothing

Jamie Bennell
Pat McGinnity
Dylan Addison
Padraig Lucey
Daniel Pearce
Nathan Brown

Other players not mentioned on this list are obviously in our best XV or close to it. They may be tradeable but would require a very good offer

[Holz]

u should we talk about trades relying on trades relying on trades.

unless they are 3 way or 4 way deals I dont think you should be able to trade players that you already dont have. Also I thought we didnt approach people about players they dont have. I was going to make plays for players when the official trades went through.