2014 Review and Rule discussions for 2015.

[kilbluff1985]

Happy with the priority pick idea for 4 wins or less.

Do we need to increase/change rules for not posting, and then subsequent not posting?

you mean regarding posting teams?

yeah i think premiership should points should be lost like WXV

[SydneyRox]

Happy with the priority pick idea for 4 wins or less.

Do we need to increase/change rules for not posting, and then subsequent not posting?

you mean regarding posting teams?

yeah i think premiership should points should be lost like WXV

yeah premiership points or something like that.

[ossie85]

RIGHT!

A bit late to the party, but my opinions below....

5.6 Trades must be conducted in a 1 for 1 manner.  This includes the trade of draft picks.

I think, for the first trade period at least, that trades should not be restricted by this. Numbers will even themselves out.

5.8 A player movement is defined as when a player on your list from the previous season (initial draft for initial season) is traded to another team. Draft picks or players you have received as part of a trade can be on traded without being considered a player movement.

I think this complicates things, would rather just say 10 player movements full stop.

To start discussion I reckon we do away with extra player movements and look at this proposal:
Teams finishing 18th and 17th get an additional draft pick at conclusion of first round.
Teams finishing 15th and 16th get an additional draft pick at conclusion of second Round.
In all cases you must have vacancies on your 40 player senior list to draft players,

Fine with me

and i want to bring something in like WXV regarding subs

if a player gets the green vest or is subbed off before half time

you either get that players average
or
the emerg player you have covering that pos you get there score instead if it's higher then original players score

the 2nd option i think also encourages teams to have decent depth

Agree with WXV style sub rule, surprised how well it works this year

I don't like the emergency rule, when you need to name 4 emergencies with one for each position. Think you should just have to name 4 emergencies regardless of the position.

Agree, we should get free reign on emergencies.

[kilbluff1985]

Ringo have you got a date set for when trading starts?

just curious

[Ringo]

Trading may be delayed for a week whilst we finalise the coaching status of Hurricanes and Falcons. Remember both coaches took on as an interim basis till seasons end.

Another matter for discussion is last year we had a knock out plate competition for teams not making the 8.  Are you happy for this to continue against this year.  Runs in parallel with the finals competition

[Nige]

Don't see why the coaching jobs can't be sorted out now.  ???

[Purple 77]

Don't see why the coaching jobs can't be sorted out now.  ???

Because myself and/or Stew may decide we want to stick around and re-apply EOS  8)

[Nige]

Don't see why the coaching jobs can't be sorted out now.  ???

Because myself and/or Stew may decide we want to stick around and re-apply EOS  8)

Oh yeah.  :o

[LF]

Don't see why the coaching jobs can't be sorted out now.  ???

Because myself and/or Stew may decide we want to stick around and re-apply EOS  8)

Nah we don`t want either of you to stay things have gone downhill since you join BXV :P  ;)

[kilbluff1985]

Ringo during trade period would you like me to make a thread to lodge all the trades then you don't have to read all the debates

[Ringo]

Will be same as last year a thread will be created listing all trades. Remember I locked a thread that only I could edit listing trades and fate.

[Purple 77]

Don't see why the coaching jobs can't be sorted out now.  ???

Because myself and/or Stew may decide we want to stick around and re-apply EOS  8)

Nah we don`t want either of you to stay things have gone downhill since you join BXV :P  ;)

It has nothing to do with my Hurricanes beating your hoods now does it  ;)

[LF]

Don't see why the coaching jobs can't be sorted out now.  ???

Because myself and/or Stew may decide we want to stick around and re-apply EOS  8)

Nah we don`t want either of you to stay things have gone downhill since you join BXV :P  ;)

It has nothing to do with my Hurricanes beating your hoods now does it  ;)

Haha actually no just needed to be said :P

But seriously hope you decide to stick around I`m enjoying the comp in my first season here and hopefully I can stick around for a while.

[Ringo]

OK with only a few weeks to end of season need to finalise rule changes for trade period.

So in summary these are changes that look like being made and then going to vote:

Trade Period 1 - Trades can be made in any configurations and can include National Draft and Rookie Draft picks.

Trade Period 2 - Trades will be on a one for one basis.

There will be additional movements for lower placed teams as Priority picks will be introduced if agreed by vote.

Are you happy with current approval process?
5.3 Trades will either Passed or Rejected by the league administrator.  The administrator will take into consideration the short and long term impacts to both teams, to ensure the trade does not damage a team's future chances of being competitive.
5.4 Where any coach feels that the decision of the administrator is incorrect or unfair, they may appeal the decision to the Trades Committee.  The Committee will review the decision, and have the power to confirm or over-rule the decision made by the administrator.  They will then provide feedback to the coaches involved.
5.5 The committee will consist of 3 members, not currently affiliated with the competition, who are deemed to be impartial.  The administrator will be charged with appointing the committee and ensuring they remain active.

and secondly we are currently limited to 12 player movements is this sufficient or do we need to increase to 15.

Please feel free to comment and I will collate and then put to vote prior to end of season.

[ossie85]

Have some issues with player movements

think it should be simplified to a certain number, no matter if you on trade them