Player X vs. Player Y

[ubeaut]

Sicily@D3, Coniglio@M6 & Lobb@F4. No Bundy.
Vs
Simpson@D3, Coniglio@M6 & Bundy@F4.
Vs
Hurley@D3, Rookie@M6 & Lobb@F4.

Struggling with where to spend the remaaiming cash, D3? M6? F4?

Not sold on Bundy or Lobb, but either option with Coniglio at M6 for me. Probably lean towards option 1.

[enzedder]

Sauce or Goldy?

Sauce for boring but safe 95.
Goldy for potential 110 but with Pruess risk.
I prefer Ryder and Kreuz but bye and cost/injury history respectively.

Sauce for minimum 95 and possible 105 and likely 22 games.
Who knows what you're going to get with Goldy. Potential 12 games and 105 average.
It's all speculation but Jacobs is not only a safe pick, he's a good pickina season where people are considering other risks on every line.
Goldy is yet another risky pick.
I see no reason why Sauce can't be one of the top two rucks in 2018. Hitouts and hit outs to advantage are something he does well. He has a good midfield to work with and he's in a team that should win a lot more than they'll lose.

[Mahogany]

Toby Greene, Josh Dunkley  Naughton in defense vs
Petracca, Toby McLean and 123k rookie in defense??

[tommy10]

Toby Greene, Josh Dunkley  Naughton in defense vs
Petracca, Toby McLean and 123k rookie in defense??

Just curious is it Naughton vs the rookie? Dunkley and Petrecca fighting for F3/4? And same with greene vs McLean for F2? If so then option 2 for me. McLean a POD and Petrecca should improve.

[tommy10]

Neale vs Bont vs Jelwood

[Blues Blues Blues]

Neale vs Bont vs Jelwood

Tough one.

Bont looks ready to explode IMO. Neale gets s lot of the pill, and we all know Jelwood and what he is capable of.

Could go either way, but personally I’d go Bont > Neale > Jelwood

[Blues Blues Blues]

Dahl v Mundy v McLean

[Mahogany]

Toby Greene, Josh Dunkley  Naughton in defense vs
Petracca, Toby McLean and 123k rookie in defense??

Just curious is it Naughton vs the rookie? Dunkley and Petrecca fighting for F3/4? And same with greene vs McLean for F2? If so then option 2 for me. McLean a POD and Petrecca should improve.

It would mean McLean going down from F2 to Dunkley at F4 and the cash being used to upgrade Petracca from F3 to Greene at F1 and  upgrading the 123k rookie to Naughton. Currently have Smith and Billings locked in. 2 premos and Sicily at F3 at the moment.

[ubeaut]

Dahl v Mundy v McLean

If their mid time is similar to last season then McLean>Dahl>Mundy

[jfitty]

Dahl v Mundy v McLean

Tough to split these - they really could average anywhere from 80 - 100!

I'd rank them > Dahl - Mundy - McLean

I'm not starting with Dahl, but confident he can go at least 90-95 even with his half forward role. Mundy should get enough midfield time to keep his average from last season. I'm personally not all keen on McLean, so have to put him behind the 2 guys with runs on the board.

Pretty tight though.

[MC]

Yeah I agree, they're hard to split!

I'd go: Dahl>McLean>Mundy

Though McLean clearly has the most upside, Dahl with a 4-year average of 21/95.47 is hard to ignore!
Mundy on the other hand is trending downwards, not ideal.

[ubeaut]

Sauce or Goldy?

Sauce for boring but safe 95.
Goldy for potential 110 but with Pruess risk.
I prefer Ryder and Kreuz but bye and cost/injury history respectively.

Sauce for minimum 95 and possible 105 and likely 22 games.
Who knows what you're going to get with Goldy. Potential 12 games and 105 average.
It's all speculation but Jacobs is not only a safe pick, he's a good pickina season where people are considering other risks on every line.
Goldy is yet another risky pick.
I see no reason why Sauce can't be one of the top two rucks in 2018. Hitouts and hit outs to advantage are something he does well. He has a good midfield to work with and he's in a team that should win a lot more than they'll lose.

He had a good midfield la year and Crows made top 4 so why didn't he score more than Ryder,Kreuz,Martin or Grundy? What makes him top 2 this year? 95 seems to be his limit.

[tommy10]

Toby Greene, Josh Dunkley  Naughton in defense vs
Petracca, Toby McLean and 123k rookie in defense??

Just curious is it Naughton vs the rookie? Dunkley and Petrecca fighting for F3/4? And same with greene vs McLean for F2? If so then option 2 for me. McLean a POD and Petrecca should improve.

It would mean McLean going down from F2 to Dunkley at F4 and the cash being used to upgrade Petracca from F3 to Greene at F1 and  upgrading the 123k rookie to Naughton. Currently have Smith and Billings locked in. 2 premos and Sicily at F3 at the moment.

In that case your fwds would be Billings, McLean, Petrecca and Sicily. Looks pretty strong to me. Not many good fwd rookies so you probably need Bundy/Dunkley at F5 and Fritsch at F6.

[Money Shot]

Crouch, Lobb and Sicily v Danger, Greene and 123k rookie.

[Money Shot]

Assuming all are named and play round 1...

Danger, Greene and 123k forward rookie other than Fritsch on field v Crouch, Lobb and Sicily

My guns and rookies instict is leaning towards option one but would love other peoples thoughts.