Fyfe vs. JPK

[alex1234]

looking at bringing one of these blokes in, byes no issue
just whos the better player/option in the long run

[H1bb3i2d]

If byes are no problem then I like Goddard tbh. Food for thought.

If money is no problem then thay'll both cost around as much as Stevey Johnson. And he's had his bye which will allow for a one weeker somewhere along the way ;)

If it has to be one of these 2... Fyfe.

[Woppa15]

I find it hard to split these two in terms of potential season average scores to be honest.

I voted Fyfe simply because the swans seem to share the SC points around quite a bit, at least this midfield group always have anyway.

[alex1234]

dont like goddard, mainly as he will not be top 10 mid at end of year, not enough trades in the world to consider upgrading from goddard once i get him in

had stevie from about round 4,
im looking at an upgrade for polec, need to reduce donuts

$420k in bank and dont have acres yet, lots of coin to play

yes woppa15, the fact that hannabury and co also play for swans crossed my mind, but i just like the way JPK plays so im split

[Jackross10]

Can't go wrong with either. But maybe look at a rd 8 byer. So you don't have anything like that to think about. Selwood and swan are good choices and both ripe to pick.

[alex1234]

Can't go wrong with either. But maybe look at a rd 8 byer. So you don't have anything like that to think about. Selwood and swan are good choices and both ripe to pick.

not comfortable with pendles, beams AND swan

selwood would have three 50s in his name if it wasnt for his last quarter efforts, needs to lift in my books

[H1bb3i2d]

Fair enough. In that case, looking at JPK's first and second half of seasons for the last 3 years is concerning, would have definitely made my team if I could remake it from round 1, but from here on in I would go with Fyfe.

However, despite his breakeven I think Jelwood will outscore the 2, and he's cheaper anyway.

Did you really have all of Ablett, Pendles, Johnson and Beams to begin with? (just checking, cus any of those you might not have started with would be ideal)

[Bully]

Can't go wrong with either. But maybe look at a rd 8 byer. So you don't have anything like that to think about. Selwood and swan are good choices and both ripe to pick.

Very true, I think it's more important to have a premo playing both weeks. Cotchin & Selwood for me.

[H1bb3i2d]

Can't go wrong with either. But maybe look at a rd 8 byer. So you don't have anything like that to think about. Selwood and swan are good choices and both ripe to pick.

Very true, I think it's more important to have a premo playing both weeks. Cotchin & Selwood for me.

I think Cotchin is priced so cheaply for a reason. I know I know, no Deledio, but even so... Ablett, Pendlebury, Rockliff etc. don't suffer so severely with just one other player missing.

[alex1234]

yeah already have the 4, im sure if i didnt id be jumping straight on them

im leaning towards fyfe i think, but i can see him having a low score more often than JPK, but yet a higher roof

[H1bb3i2d]

yeah already have the 4, im sure if i didnt id be jumping straight on them

im leaning towards fyfe i think, but i can see him having a low score more often than JPK, but yet a higher roof

Probably a good summary.

JPK tends to have just 'good' games that score 80s and 90s, whereas Fyfe is either on or he isn't. (Mind you, JPK pumps out some monsters too)



My main reason for Fyfe:

Fyfe's DE% was the general consensus last year (and this preseason) to be the reason holding him back from super-premo status. He has a great SC:DT ratio this year though, 119:99!!!! Considering he averaged 97 DT last year, there's no reason he won't maintain a 115-120 SC average if he keeps this up. He's simply scoring more points per touch this year, which is SC gold.

[quinny88]

Tough choice! I like both of these guys this year. Cant split them myself

[Bully]

Can't go wrong with either. But maybe look at a rd 8 byer. So you don't have anything like that to think about. Selwood and swan are good choices and both ripe to pick.

Very true, I think it's more important to have a premo playing both weeks. Cotchin & Selwood for me.

I think Cotchin is priced so cheaply for a reason. I know I know, no Deledio, but even so... Ablett, Pendlebury, Rockliff etc. don't suffer so severely with just one other player missing.

There's a few things going for Cotch. Firstly, Deledio is back as you mentioned, he will almost certainly get the number 1 tag. Secondly, Richmond have a nice draw from here, I expect Cotch to lift a notch as a result. Finally, he's a strong finsher, with Richmond's season on the line I think he'll come home with a wet sail. I'm tipping 110+ from this point on.

[H1bb3i2d]

Can't go wrong with either. But maybe look at a rd 8 byer. So you don't have anything like that to think about. Selwood and swan are good choices and both ripe to pick.

Very true, I think it's more important to have a premo playing both weeks. Cotchin & Selwood for me.

I think Cotchin is priced so cheaply for a reason. I know I know, no Deledio, but even so... Ablett, Pendlebury, Rockliff etc. don't suffer so severely with just one other player missing.

There's a few things going for Cotch. Firstly, Deledio is back as you mentioned, he will almost certainly get the number 1 tag. Secondly, Richmond have a nice draw from here, I expect Cotch to lift a notch as a result. Finally, he's a strong finsher, with Richmond's season on the line I think he'll come home with a wet sail. I'm tipping 110+ from this point on.

I'm tipping BJ to beat Cotchin.

My guess is no better than yours though :)

But as OP said he wants a top 10 mid, I think he'll need a 115 average, of which neither will achieve.

Ablett, Pendlebury, Beams, Selwood, Waston, Johnson, Rockliff and Fyfe are my bets for this.

How have I not mentioned Jobe yet??

[alex1234]

Can't go wrong with either. But maybe look at a rd 8 byer. So you don't have anything like that to think about. Selwood and swan are good choices and both ripe to pick.

Very true, I think it's more important to have a premo playing both weeks. Cotchin & Selwood for me.

I think Cotchin is priced so cheaply for a reason. I know I know, no Deledio, but even so... Ablett, Pendlebury, Rockliff etc. don't suffer so severely with just one other player missing.

There's a few things going for Cotch. Firstly, Deledio is back as you mentioned, he will almost certainly get the number 1 tag. Secondly, Richmond have a nice draw from here, I expect Cotch to lift a notch as a result. Finally, he's a strong finsher, with Richmond's season on the line I think he'll come home with a wet sail. I'm tipping 110+ from this point on.

I'm tipping BJ to beat Cotchin.

My guess is no better than yours though :)

But as OP said he wants a top 10 mid, I think he'll need a 115 average, of which neither will achieve.

Ablett, Pendlebury, Beams, Selwood, Waston, Johnson, Rockliff and Fyfe are my bets for this.

How have I not mentioned Jobe yet??

i also have jobe already  :D
trust me
its literally fyfe or JPK for me atm,