Player X vs. Player Y

[Keeper27]

Laird (D1), Finlayson (D7), JOM (M7), Sicily (F4) - Gives me 3-0-5/6-1-4/2-0-1/2-3-3

or

Sicily (D4), Savage (D2), Caddy (F4), (Finlayson) (M9) - Gives me 3-1-4/6-0-5/2-0-1/2-3-3

[ubeaut]

Laird (D1), Finlayson (D7), JOM (M7), Sicily (F4) - Gives me 3-0-5/6-1-4/2-0-1/2-3-3

or

Sicily (D4), Savage (D2), Caddy (F4), (Finlayson) (M9) - Gives me 3-1-4/6-0-5/2-0-1/2-3-3

Option 1. It has Laird. Don't like Caddy. Teases every year and doesn't deliver. Prestia to come back in. Caddy played a good role fwd last year and I expect he'll stay fwd mostly. Part of the successful small fwd game plan with Rioli,Castagna and Butler. Rather give JOM another go for cheaper.

[Colley Dogs]

F1 + F2 +F3:

Franklin or Heeney + Walters or McLean + D. Smith or Caddy or Petracca or Curnow?

[tommy10]

F1 + F2 +F3:

Franklin or Heeney + Walters or McLean + D. Smith or Caddy or Petracca or Curnow?

Heeney, McLean, Smith. It’s a flip of a coin between Walthers and McLean but I’d go with McLean because of his bye

[Ringo]

Heeney, Walters and Smith for me. Franklin can be targeted when he has the inevitable stinker hopefully just before his bye and price falls. Walters and McLean equal so choose whichever suits your bye structure, Smith well abaove the others.

Greene v Heeney

Stef Martin v Gawn

[rodneycc]

Both Greene and Heeney for me. Both will get better as season progresses. Not a Walters fan with Fyfe and Neale and an undeperforming Freo outfit.

And Gawn for the ruck spot.


Any thoughts on:

Hurley and102k Def rookie if named
Vs
Sicily and Coffield

I'm about 25-30k short of turning Sicily to Hurley,  and I think I'm willing to go without Coffield and a few mods on other lines to do it if enough def rooks are named.

[Colley Dogs]

Heeney, Walters and Smith for me. Franklin can be targeted when he has the inevitable stinker hopefully just before his bye and price falls. Walters and McLean equal so choose whichever suits your bye structure, Smith well abaove the others.

Greene v Heeney

Stef Martin v Gawn

Thanks Ringo & tommy10.

You’ve clarified Heeney and D. Smith for me. I mustn’t allow myself to be seduced by JLT scores. I prefer Walters (just), but think it might need to be McLean for the bye.

Ringo:

Definitely Heeney & Gawn for me.

As you can tell from my own dilemma, the only person I’d take over Heeney would be Franklin. However, if I had the cash I’d love to turn Walters/McLean into Greene, and roll with Heeney & Greene at F1 & F2.

With Martin, I just don’t trust that it won’t go pear shaped at some point during the season. Curious to know who your other Ruck is? If it’s Goldstein, could you not find 19k to run with Martin & Gawn?

[Bubbles]

Heeney v Hibbered (via Sicily)

[rodneycc]

Heeney v Hibbered (via Sicily)

Id go both, but if I had to pick Id go Hibbered I think. If you went Heeney instead I think you would want Hurley and Laird at least in your Def.

[Ringo]

Heeney, Walters and Smith for me. Franklin can be targeted when he has the inevitable stinker hopefully just before his bye and price falls. Walters and McLean equal so choose whichever suits your bye structure, Smith well abaove the others.

Greene v Heeney

Stef Martin v Gawn

Thanks Ringo & tommy10.

You’ve clarified Heeney and D. Smith for me. I mustn’t allow myself to be seduced by JLT scores. I prefer Walters (just), but think it might need to be McLean for the bye.

Ringo:

Definitely Heeney & Gawn for me.

As you can tell from my own dilemma, the only person I’d take over Heeney would be Franklin. However, if I had the cash I’d love to turn Walters/McLean into Greene, and roll with Heeney & Greene at F1 & F2.

With Martin, I just don’t trust that it won’t go pear shaped at some point during the season. Curious to know who your other Ruck is? If it’s Goldstein, could you not find 19k to run with Martin & Gawn?

My other ruck is Sauce Jacobs.  Martin and Gawn share the same bye so that is the purpose of question.

[Ringo]

Heeney v Hibbered (via Sicily)

Id go both, but if I had to pick Id go Hibbered I think. If you went Heeney instead I think you would want Hurley and Laird at least in your Def.

I'd go both if you can afford as in my opinion both will be top 5/10. Toss of the coin really but if pressed for one would go Heeney.  Looked a lot better last night than the previous week.

[Jalapeno]

Hey guys,

Lycett (R2) and Parker (D4) vs Kreuzer (R1) and Armitage (D6)

Thoughts?

[Gandalf123]

Hey guys,

Lycett (R2) and Parker (D4) vs Kreuzer (R1) and Armitage (D6)

Thoughts?

It would be dope if I could pick parks at d4

[ubeaut]

Hey guys,

Lycett (R2) and Parker (D4) vs Kreuzer (R1) and Armitage (D6)

Thoughts?

Think u should factor cost and money left over.
Parker 545 + Lycett 277 = 822
Armo 310 + Kreuzer 603 = 910

What will they score? Parker 110 Lycett 70-85
Armo 80 - 90 Kreuzer 95 - 105
Pretty even but there's about 90 k difference which could be handy elsewhere.
Lycett carries more risk tho as if he flops downgrading a premo/midpricer elsewhere is the only option, which is what I'm tossing up with Lycett atm.

[Jalapeno]

Hey guys,

Lycett (R2) and Parker (D4) vs Kreuzer (R1) and Armitage (D6)

Thoughts?

Think u should factor cost and money left over.
Parker 545 + Lycett 277 = 822
Armo 310 + Kreuzer 603 = 910

What will they score? Parker 110 Lycett 70-85
Armo 80 - 90 Kreuzer 95 - 105
Pretty even but there's about 90 k difference which could be handy elsewhere.
Lycett carries more risk tho as if he flops downgrading a premo/midpricer elsewhere is the only option, which is what I'm tossing up with Lycett atm.

Thanks mate, much appreciated! I think Kreuzer is the better option, but the cost is a fair chunk more as you said.

Ahh decisions  :-[