Player X v Player Y

[IntegralX]

Franklin vs Greene vs Hall

Greene >= Hall >>> Buddy I think. Top 2 are close and theres daylight between them and buddy imo.

[GoLions]

Franklin vs Greene vs Hall

Greene >= Hall >>> Buddy I think. Top 2 are close and theres daylight between them and buddy imo.

Are you saying for the worst pick or the best? Would take Buddy over those guys any day of the week.

[Big Mac]

Franklin vs Greene vs Hall

Greene >= Hall >>> Buddy I think. Top 2 are close and theres daylight between them and buddy imo.

Are you saying for the worst pick or the best? Would take Buddy over those guys any day of the week.

Yeh agreed

Would need to be doing something special with the extra $ if not going Buddy

[IntegralX]

Franklin vs Greene vs Hall

Greene >= Hall >>> Buddy I think. Top 2 are close and theres daylight between them and buddy imo.

Are you saying for the worst pick or the best? Would take Buddy over those guys any day of the week.

Yeh agreed

Would need to be doing something special with the extra $ if not going Buddy

Honestly not interested in Buddy at all this year. One good NAB game (vs Carlton no less) and everyones all over him. High ceiling but that floor is putrid.

[almonds]

S.Gray v T.Greene?

[RaisyDaisy]

S.Gray v T.Greene?

I'd go with Gray, but it's a coin flip

I have one more decision to make, and my team is finally done and I am 100% happy to take it into rd1!

Shaw / Mills / 123k fwd

VS

Simpson or Birchall / 123k mid / De Goey

In both scenario's the 123k rookie is most likely Petracca who I will use to loophole early on

Really want to start Shaw, but option 2 looks better as I believe De Goey will be good enough for D6 come seasons end, so it's 2 keepers and a rookie vs 1 super keeper and 2 rookies

(Can't afford anyone above Simpson)

[hawkboy80]

Priddis vs hannebery

hanners

[hawkboy80]

S.Gray v T.Greene?

I'd go with Gray, but it's a coin flip

I have one more decision to make, and my team is finally done and I am 100% happy to take it into rd1!

Shaw / Mills / 123k fwd

VS

Simpson or Birchall / 123k mid / De Goey

In both scenario's the 123k rookie is most likely Petracca who I will use to loophole early on

Really want to start Shaw, but option 2 looks better as I believe De Goey will be good enough for D6 come seasons end, so it's 2 keepers and a rookie vs 1 super keeper and 2 rookies

(Can't afford anyone above Simpson)

for what it's worth I had shaw & mills last week, but have since gone back to simmo & degoey again, my team is locked away now pending rookies listed R1

[Southstorm]

S.Gray v T.Greene?

I'd go with Gray, but it's a coin flip

I have one more decision to make, and my team is finally done and I am 100% happy to take it into rd1!

Shaw / Mills / 123k fwd

VS

Simpson or Birchall / 123k mid / De Goey

In both scenario's the 123k rookie is most likely Petracca who I will use to loophole early on

Really want to start Shaw, but option 2 looks better as I believe De Goey will be good enough for D6 come seasons end, so it's 2 keepers and a rookie vs 1 super keeper and 2 rookies

(Can't afford anyone above Simpson)

Option 2. De Goey looks good

[backpocket]

Shiel v Parker
Simpson v Docherty
Westhoff v Franklin v Robinson

[Keeper27]

Shiel v Parker
Simpson v Docherty
Westhoff v Franklin v Robinson

Parker. Simmo . robbo

[MC]

Shiel v Parker
Simpson v Docherty
Westhoff v Franklin v Robinson

Shiel/Doch/Hoff

Hoff in particular has gone 90+ for three straight seasons, will lift in the absence of Ryder by taking som ruck minutes imo. Docherty is far younger and might take Simmo's mantle this year, and gut says Shiel who is just an absolute jet (plus GWS will move up the ladder this year).

[backpocket]

Shiel v Parker
Simpson v Docherty
Westhoff v Franklin v Robinson

Shiel/Doch/Hoff

Hoff in particular has gone 90+ for three straight seasons, will lift in the absence of Ryder by taking som ruck minutes imo. Docherty is far younger and might take Simmo's mantle this year, and gut says Shiel who is just an absolute jet (plus GWS will move up the ladder this year).

Thanks MC they are my 3 picks ATM just. I understand Parker is underpriced but don't see him busting into top 10 mids as shiel is.
Been on docherty all pre season seems like Carlton have some direction and him being next in line after the veterans I think he'll step up. The dilemma is do I want to go against people with buddy with the chance of him belting out 110 point halves like he can?

[almonds]

s.martin vs nicnat

[MC]

s.martin vs nicnat

Honestly it's a coin flip for me. I'm running with NN at the moment, not really sure why though