Player X vs. Player Y

[backpocket]

Buddy, Walters, Sicily, touhy (d3)
Vs
Heeney, mundy, petracca, Sicily (d3)

Thoughts?

[YoungGun]

Buddy, Walters, Sicily, touhy (d3)
Vs
Heeney, mundy, petracca, Sicily (d3)

Thoughts?

Option 1 - move Sicily to D3 and go Petracca over Touhy?

[SilverLion]

Murphy + Cash (Naughton D4) vs. Bonner (D4)

[Maca24]

Murphy + Cash (Naughton D4) vs. Bonner (D4)

Hard to say because I don’t know how much cash, but Naughton is more than fine to have at D4 IMO. Do like Bonner though

Savage + Shaw vs Hibberd + Bonner + 130k

[SilverLion]

Murphy + Cash (Naughton D4) vs. Bonner (D4)

Hard to say because I don’t know how much cash, but Naughton is more than fine to have at D4 IMO. Do like Bonner though

Savage + Shaw vs Hibberd + Bonner + 130k

Would be the cash difference between Bonner and Murphy roughly ;) (About 160k)

And Second option out of those :)

[backpocket]

Buddy, Walters, Sicily, touhy (d3)
Vs
Heeney, mundy, petracca, Sicily (d3)

Thoughts?

Option 1 - move Sicily to D3 and go Petracca over Touhy?

Not bad. If mundy is going to average say 90 what are we all hoping Walters averages considering he’s playing less midfield time than mundy?

[dmac07]

D.Smith/Lobb F4/5 Sicily D3

Greene/Rioli F4/5 Sicily D3

Sicily/Christensen F4/5 Hibberd D3

Sicily/Rioli F4/5 Savage D3

My last three positions on field to decide on.

[SilverLion]

D.Smith/Lobb F4/5 Sicily D3

Greene/Rioli F4/5 Sicily D3

Sicily/Christensen F4/5 Hibberd D3

Sicily/Rioli F4/5 Savage D3

My last three positions on field to decide on.

I'd go D.Smith/Christensen with Hibberd if you could afford that.

If not, option 1.


I'll just expand on my one from earlier:

Murphy + 174.2k (Naughton D4) vs. Bonner (D4) + 19.3k vs. Seedsman (D4) (gotta do some swaps elsewhere to get the funds for him)

[Samsturmfels]

D.Smith/Lobb F4/5 Sicily D3

Greene/Rioli F4/5 Sicily D3

Sicily/Christensen F4/5 Hibberd D3

Sicily/Rioli F4/5 Savage D3

My last three positions on field to decide on.

I'd go D.Smith/Christensen with Hibberd if you could afford that.

If not, option 1.


I'll just expand on my one from earlier:

Murphy + 174.2k (Naughton D4) vs. Bonner (D4) + 19.3k vs. Seedsman (D4) (gotta do some swaps elsewhere to get the funds for him)

Id probably do one of the first 2 options. Mostly like no.1 if it allows you to trade in a possible keeper

[Samsturmfels]

Langdon vs Venables vs keefe , if they are all named rd 1 (although i doubt keefe will be)

[Holz]

Barry + Howe - howe better for byes and cash generation with barry assuming he plays which is a huge if

LDU + Lloyd - lloyd slightly underpriced not ideal bye, LDU JS is arguably the best of all rookies and was a good junior just meh JLT. 

[rodneycc]

Langdon vs Venables vs keefe , if they are all named rd 1 (although i doubt keefe will be)

Me too please. Throw in Ryan and Waterman (who is named on the field) in there as well if someone would like to take a shot at ranking them.

btw I would of gone Langdon>Waterman>Ryan>Venables>Keefe

[SilverLion]

Langdon vs Venables vs keefe , if they are all named rd 1 (although i doubt keefe will be)

Me too please. Throw in Ryan and Waterman (who is named on the field) in there as well if someone would like to take a shot at ranking them.

Langdon > Ryan > Keeffe (if named) > Venables > Waterman

[rodneycc]

Langdon vs Venables vs keefe , if they are all named rd 1 (although i doubt keefe will be)

Me too please. Throw in Ryan and Waterman (who is named on the field) in there as well if someone would like to take a shot at ranking them.

Langdon > Ryan > Keeffe (if named) > Venables > Waterman

So Waterman just the Kennedy fill in you reckon ?

[walloo44]

walters vs Mclean vs Petracca

had walters all pre season but feel iffy now and concidering petracca and mclean due to midfield minutes