Player X v Player Y

Started by ben_020285, December 22, 2015, 02:28:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

smashbox


whynot102


GoLions

Quote from: dicko_ on July 21, 2016, 06:00:07 PM
Quote from: Bubbles on July 19, 2016, 03:36:02 PM
Oleg Markov v Sam Naismith
Would definitely get Naimsith if you don't already have ruck cover, but have cover on other lines.

Zorko v Ward v Treloar for M8
If your forwards are complete, then Ward. If not, Zorko.

LaHug

Quote from: GoLions on July 21, 2016, 08:23:04 PM
Quote from: dicko_ on July 21, 2016, 06:00:07 PM
Quote from: Bubbles on July 19, 2016, 03:36:02 PM
Oleg Markov v Sam Naismith
Would definitely get Naimsith if you don't already have ruck cover, but have cover on other lines.

Zorko v Ward v Treloar for M8
If your forwards are complete, then Ward. If not, Zorko.

I'd go Zorko either way. He's better than the other two.

crowls

Quote from: GoLions on July 21, 2016, 08:23:04 PM
Quote from: dicko_ on July 21, 2016, 06:00:07 PM
Quote from: Bubbles on July 19, 2016, 03:36:02 PM
Oleg Markov v Sam Naismith
Would definitely get Naimsith if you don't already have ruck cover, but have cover on other lines.

Zorko v Ward v Treloar for M8
If your forwards are complete, then Ward. If not, Zorko.
+1

crowls

Bench cover.  4 trades left


B: Collins, Adams     but have laird, bartel and mcveigh.  (mcviegh on mid bench this week)
M: Trengrove, Matho, McVeigh
R:  Grimley
F.  Petracca, Phillips


Option 1.
Trengrove to Naismith via Phillips to mids.    gives me r/f cover.    Hall/Lids on bench this week,  tracca f5, naismith f6.   3 trades left
SMartin at D2 with no cover if late out.
Option 2.
As above and Adams to Clay Smith, via McVeigh.    Gives me playing m/f cover and I lose my d/m dpp.  down to 2 trades.


Maca24


Jimmykidd


crowls


js19

Bank Goldy's 87, or give Lycett a call up?

Ingram

#2845
Continuing the NRoo Vs Buddy debate. They're to replace Hall. Will have 2 trades left with Dhal on the bench afterwards. I guess I should opt for a less injury prone player in Buddy...

GoTheEagles

#2846
naismth v callum sinclair?

Naismith is the cheaper option but Callum Sinclair has much better game security?
Which one do I take?

MC

#2847
Hey boys, looking to upgrade Kerridge (+105k in a straight swap as my final forward (had to trade Hall down last week), leaving me with 2 contingency trades.

Current lineup: Zorko, Joey, Lynch (GCS), Westhoff, Greene, Kerridge (Naismith, Rose)


and am tossing up between the following:
Buddy - Leaning towards him, even if he is following his trend of falling away towards the end of the season.
Lynch (Crows) - My current 2nd - A few easy games to finish off the year could result in some handy scores.
JRoo - Usually consistent for a key forward, though has a tough run.
Lycett - NicNat's return the unknown, though should still score reasonably well. May somehow be useful in conjunction with Naismith if a ruck goes down.


What do you think?
Cheers in advance

GoTheEagles

Quote from: MC on July 25, 2016, 07:00:50 PM
Hey boys, looking to upgrade Kerridge (+10 in a straight swap as my final forward (had to trade Hall down last week), leaving me with 2 contingency trades.

Current lineup: Zorko, Joey, Lynch (GCS), Westhoff, Greene, Kerridge (Naismith, Rose)


and am tossing up between the following:
Buddy - Leaning towards him, even if he is following his trend of falling away towards the end of the season.
Lynch (Crows) - My current 2nd - A few easy games to finish off the year could result in some handy scores.
JRoo - Usually consistent for a key forward, though has a tough run.
Lycett - NicNat's return the unknown, though should still score reasonably well. May somehow be useful in conjunction with Naismith if a ruck goes down.


What do you think?
Cheers in advance

I would take Lynch because he has the easiest run

dylanclements

It's probably gotta be Buddy tbh. But if you're feeling gutsy I'd take the punt on lil Rooey. Like the thinking a lot and for whatever people think of him, he's not inconsistent and can really play the game