Player X v Player Y

[cptawesom3]

Wells and B. Crouch vs De Goey and Mills

[Bully]

Wells and B. Crouch vs De Goey and Mills

First option although all 4 should be a consideration.

[Big Mac]

Franklin vs Greene vs Hall

Greene >= Hall >>> Buddy I think. Top 2 are close and theres daylight between them and buddy imo.

Are you saying for the worst pick or the best? Would take Buddy over those guys any day of the week.

Yeh agreed

Would need to be doing something special with the extra $ if not going Buddy

Honestly not interested in Buddy at all this year. One good NAB game (vs Carlton no less) and everyones all over him. High ceiling but that floor is putrid.

Has nothing to do with his NAB game

More to do with his 7 years of averaging over 90

[Southstorm]

Seedsman or the Cannon? Both have been pretty good in the nab cup and I'm a bit torn. Can't even come down to byes because they both have one in Rd. 13!

[AaronKirk]

Seedsman or the Cannon? Both have been pretty good in the nab cup and I'm a bit torn. Can't even come down to byes because they both have one in Rd. 13!

Cannon if you really had to choose one of them.

[Sven]

Toby Greene or Aaron Hall?

Aaron Hall has averaged 111.7 in the 3 NAB Challenge matches, along with averaging 116.8 in the last 6 matches of 2015. But I worry, since during most of these matches Gold Coast have been without Gablett, O'Meara, Prestia, Swallow etc.

Toby Greene on the other hand, lot of hype and talk, with one NAB Challenge match of 133. Didn't finish 2015 well, averaging 85.3, but was playing a different role to this year with the loss of Adam Treloar to Collingwood.

[PiPies]

Hall for mine.

Greene butchers it a bit too much for my liking.

[Sven]

Hall for mine.

Greene butchers it a bit too much for my liking.

Aaron Hall - 69.3% effective disposal
Toby Greene - 69.1%

Aaron Hall - 2.7 clangers / game
Toby Greene - 3.5

Not a great deal in it....but fair point nonetheless.

[Keeper27]

place in order guys on who you think will have more Total points.

Fyfe/Gazza/Danger/Rocky/Pendles

[timtim]

place in order guys on who you think will have more Total points.

Fyfe/Gazza/Danger/Rocky/Pendles

Assuming all play the same # of games then:

Fyfe
Danger
Pendles
Gazz
Rocky

[timtim]

Heater or Laird or Bartel.... Pick 2

[Keeper27]

place in order guys on who you think will have more Total points.

Fyfe/Gazza/Danger/Rocky/Pendles

Assuming all play the same # of games then:

Fyfe
Danger
Pendles
Gazz
Rocky

You tipping danger and pendles to outscore Gazza.  Big call

[timtim]

place in order guys on who you think will have more Total points.

Fyfe/Gazza/Danger/Rocky/Pendles

Assuming all play the same # of games then:

Fyfe
Danger
Pendles
Gazz
Rocky

You tipping danger and pendles to outscore Gazza.  Big call

Just a hunch

"Culture" issues don't just go away over a pre-season... have a feeling it may pop up again as the season goes on and affect output

[IntegralX]

place in order guys on who you think will have more Total points.

Fyfe/Gazza/Danger/Rocky/Pendles

Assuming all play the same # of games then:

Fyfe
Danger
Pendles
Gazz
Rocky

You tipping danger and pendles to outscore Gazza.  Big call

Danger looks absolutely awesome and is a massive chance to outscore GAJ on merit this year.

Dusty + Wines vs Hannebury + Zerrett/S. Gray?

No Dusty leaves me with Barlow/S. Gray/Zerrett as F1-2-3

[Bubbles]

Ward & Shaw v Pendles & Birchall