Main Menu

Off Season Trade Rumours

Started by Ricochet, September 01, 2014, 02:44:32 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

WCarey18

Quote from: elephants on October 06, 2014, 02:29:52 PM
Given how beastly Greenwood was, anything less than a top-15 pick is a massive steal for whoever gets him imo. The bloke is a goal-kicking midfielder that tackles and possesses an enormous tank!

I'd take pick 4 from Brisbane in a three-way deal.  ;D

Toga

Don't think you have any chance of getting #21 Syd, and think you might even be lucky to get #38.

He's obviously got a great amount of talent, but I don't think his value would have increased since he was drafted given he didn't really get any games in his time at the Swans.

Jroo

Quote from: Toga on October 06, 2014, 02:43:21 PM
Don't think you have any chance of getting #21 Syd, and think you might even be lucky to get #38.

He's obviously got a great amount of talent, but I don't think his value would have increased since he was drafted given he didn't really get any games in his time at the Swans.
Yeah agreed, I reckon you'd be pretty lucky to get #38.

Ringo

Agree Pick 38 for a player who has played one game in Seniors is overs.

WCarey18

Here's an intriguing thought....

Is there a way to get a four-way trade down to get Beams to Brisbane, Greenwood to Collingwood, and O'Rourke to North?

Brisbane gives: pick 4 + pick 24
Brisbane receives: Beams + pick 30

GWS gives: O'Rourke
GWS receives: pick 17 + pick 24

North gives: Greenwood + pick 17
North receives: O'Rourke

Collingwood gives: Beams + pick 30
Collingwood receives: Greenwood + pick 4

Jroo

#1055
Quote from: WCarey18 on October 06, 2014, 03:17:01 PM
Here's an intriguing thought....

Is there a way to get a four-way trade down to get Beams to Brisbane, Greenwood to Collingwood, and O'Rourke to North?

Brisbane gives: pick 4 + pick 24
Brisbane receives: Beams + pick 30

GWS gives: O'Rourke
GWS receives: pick 17 + pick 24

North gives: Greenwood + pick 17
North receives: O'Rourke

Collingwood gives: Beams + pick 30
Collingwood receives: Greenwood + pick 4
Collingwood wouldn't accept that and no way Norf would pay Greenwood + a first rounder for JOR.

Looks like JOR is heading to the Hawks/Saints,  atm anyway.

AFEV

Pick 61 or whatever it is for Z Cordy is a major steal. Very agile for his size, could be a very good player for the Bulldogs.

SydneyRox

Quote from: Ringo on October 06, 2014, 03:02:27 PM
Agree Pick 38 for a player who has played one game in Seniors is overs.

From the trade radio grab just now, seems like it is going to be a straight forward swap for 38


The_Captain

Quote from: JROO8 on October 06, 2014, 03:19:53 PM
Quote from: WCarey18 on October 06, 2014, 03:17:01 PM
Here's an intriguing thought....

Is there a way to get a four-way trade down to get Beams to Brisbane, Greenwood to Collingwood, and O'Rourke to North?

Brisbane gives: pick 4 + pick 24
Brisbane receives: Beams + pick 30

GWS gives: O'Rourke
GWS receives: pick 17 + pick 24

North gives: Greenwood + pick 17
North receives: O'Rourke

Collingwood gives: Beams + pick 30
Collingwood receives: Greenwood + pick 4
Collingwood wouldn't accept that and no way Norf would pay Greenwood + a first rounder for JOR.

Looks like JOR is heading to the Hawks/Saints,  atm anyway.

Surely not the hawks... Do they even pay there players. How do they get Frawley? wasnt that spud requesting 600k a year?

WCarey18

Quote from: JROO8 on October 06, 2014, 03:19:53 PM
Quote from: WCarey18 on October 06, 2014, 03:17:01 PM
Here's an intriguing thought....

Is there a way to get a four-way trade down to get Beams to Brisbane, Greenwood to Collingwood, and O'Rourke to North?

Brisbane gives: pick 4 + pick 24
Brisbane receives: Beams + pick 30

GWS gives: O'Rourke
GWS receives: pick 17 + pick 24

North gives: Greenwood + pick 17
North receives: O'Rourke

Collingwood gives: Beams + pick 30
Collingwood receives: Greenwood + pick 4
Collingwood wouldn't accept that and no way Norf would pay Greenwood + a first rounder for JOR.

Looks like JOR is heading to the Hawks/Saints,  atm anyway.

Instead of just shutting it down, perhaps you could make a suggestion on improvements? No reason why O'Rourke can't come to North, not like O'Rourke has said where he'd like to end up....

Ricochet

Quote from: noto07 on October 06, 2014, 03:25:05 PM
Quote from: JROO8 on October 06, 2014, 03:19:53 PM
Quote from: WCarey18 on October 06, 2014, 03:17:01 PM
Here's an intriguing thought....

Is there a way to get a four-way trade down to get Beams to Brisbane, Greenwood to Collingwood, and O'Rourke to North?

Brisbane gives: pick 4 + pick 24
Brisbane receives: Beams + pick 30

GWS gives: O'Rourke
GWS receives: pick 17 + pick 24

North gives: Greenwood + pick 17
North receives: O'Rourke

Collingwood gives: Beams + pick 30
Collingwood receives: Greenwood + pick 4
Collingwood wouldn't accept that and no way Norf would pay Greenwood + a first rounder for JOR.

Looks like JOR is heading to the Hawks/Saints,  atm anyway.

Surely not the hawks... Do they even pay there players. How do they get Frawley? wasnt that spud requesting 600k a year?
Lost Buddy and now Sewell. So they have room

Jroo

Quote from: WCarey18 on October 06, 2014, 03:28:00 PM
Quote from: JROO8 on October 06, 2014, 03:19:53 PM
Quote from: WCarey18 on October 06, 2014, 03:17:01 PM
Here's an intriguing thought....

Is there a way to get a four-way trade down to get Beams to Brisbane, Greenwood to Collingwood, and O'Rourke to North?

Brisbane gives: pick 4 + pick 24
Brisbane receives: Beams + pick 30

GWS gives: O'Rourke
GWS receives: pick 17 + pick 24

North gives: Greenwood + pick 17
North receives: O'Rourke

Collingwood gives: Beams + pick 30
Collingwood receives: Greenwood + pick 4
Collingwood wouldn't accept that and no way Norf would pay Greenwood + a first rounder for JOR.

Looks like JOR is heading to the Hawks/Saints,  atm anyway.

Instead of just shutting it down, perhaps you could make a suggestion on improvements? No reason why O'Rourke can't come to North, not like O'Rourke has said where he'd like to end up....
Well currently this is what I've heard
@superfooty: Correction, 2-way race for Jono O'Rourke between Saints and Hawks. St Kilda and Carlton chasing Jaksch too!

Not sure why JOR would want to come to Norf and Pick 17 and Greenwood is way overs.

Collingwood wouldn't do that either, they wouldn't trade Beams for 4 + 24, so not sure why they'd give up 30, too  :P

I can't see a 3/4 way trade happening.

Holz

Quote from: WCarey18 on October 06, 2014, 03:28:00 PM
Quote from: JROO8 on October 06, 2014, 03:19:53 PM
Quote from: WCarey18 on October 06, 2014, 03:17:01 PM
Here's an intriguing thought....

Is there a way to get a four-way trade down to get Beams to Brisbane, Greenwood to Collingwood, and O'Rourke to North?

Brisbane gives: pick 4 + pick 24
Brisbane receives: Beams + pick 30

GWS gives: O'Rourke
GWS receives: pick 17 + pick 24

North gives: Greenwood + pick 17
North receives: O'Rourke

Collingwood gives: Beams + pick 30
Collingwood receives: Greenwood + pick 4
Collingwood wouldn't accept that and no way Norf would pay Greenwood + a first rounder for JOR.

Looks like JOR is heading to the Hawks/Saints,  atm anyway.

Instead of just shutting it down, perhaps you could make a suggestion on improvements? No reason why O'Rourke can't come to North, not like O'Rourke has said where he'd like to end up....

We will keep greenwood, we are pushing for a premiership and he is a vital player. I doubt north are stupid enough to let him leave at all and im sure they planned the Higgins and Waite moves coordinating with greenwood. Getting Higgins and Waite was to push for a flag so to drop Greenwood for an unproven player goes completely against the plan, might as well just kept Greenwood and not sign higgins.

meow meow

Quote from: Holz on October 06, 2014, 03:34:31 PM
We will keep greenwood

Collingwood, Richmond and the Bulldogs have offered him a better contract than North have.


Pies asked for either of Hanley, Zorko, Aish or Mayes in the Beams deal.

WCarey18

Quote from: Holz on October 06, 2014, 03:34:31 PM
Quote from: WCarey18 on October 06, 2014, 03:28:00 PM
Quote from: JROO8 on October 06, 2014, 03:19:53 PM
Quote from: WCarey18 on October 06, 2014, 03:17:01 PM
Here's an intriguing thought....

Is there a way to get a four-way trade down to get Beams to Brisbane, Greenwood to Collingwood, and O'Rourke to North?

Brisbane gives: pick 4 + pick 24
Brisbane receives: Beams + pick 30

GWS gives: O'Rourke
GWS receives: pick 17 + pick 24

North gives: Greenwood + pick 17
North receives: O'Rourke

Collingwood gives: Beams + pick 30
Collingwood receives: Greenwood + pick 4
Collingwood wouldn't accept that and no way Norf would pay Greenwood + a first rounder for JOR.

Looks like JOR is heading to the Hawks/Saints,  atm anyway.

Instead of just shutting it down, perhaps you could make a suggestion on improvements? No reason why O'Rourke can't come to North, not like O'Rourke has said where he'd like to end up....

We will keep greenwood, we are pushing for a premiership and he is a vital player. I doubt north are stupid enough to let him leave at all and im sure they planned the Higgins and Waite moves coordinating with greenwood. Getting Higgins and Waite was to push for a flag so to drop Greenwood for an unproven player goes completely against the plan, might as well just kept Greenwood and not sign higgins.

I hope we can keep him too, but the longer this drags on, the less likely we are to keep him.  :-\

If North are going to want a midfielder in return, this is where our trade will fail, as there a few available on the table. O'Rourke would be our best bet, as I doubt we could pry Howlett from Essendon (if that rumor is true...)