Round 6 - Hawks v Tigers - Sunday April 27th

[frenzy]

if georgio from the dees gets 1 week for hit on franklin, then this should get 2 imo

[Toga]

Definitely, medical report will play a big part.

[Mr.Craig]

if georgio from the dees gets 1 week for hit on franklin, then this should get 2 imo

I'll save you the wait.

"Contact between Alexis Georgiou and Lance Franklin was assessed. After viewing all the available footage, and receiving a medical report from the Sydney Football Club, it was the view of the panel that the force used in the contact was below that required to constitute a reportable offence. No further action was taken."

[Nige]

Buddy's acting was pretty good.

[JBs-Hawks]

Gibson will be in a bit of trouble

Piss weak, deserves a break.

Very average call! Was going the spoil!

Yeah I can understand where you're coming from but it's his duty to make sure no high contact is made or he's responsible for the concussion or injury from what the MRP has said so far this year.

High contact with a raised elbow wasn't a good look though.

Not saying he wont get a week or two for it, just saying it wasnt piss weak on gibbos behalf ;)

[Toga]

Ah fair enough :P

Yeah I dunno man like if it was a genuine spoiling attempt & he got some of the ball I probably would've been fine with it but he only got the man & hit him hard and high... Will be interesting to see what the MRP think. :-X

[Vinny]

They should have suspended Buddy for going down...weak cow.

[Nige]

They should have suspended Buddy for going down...weak cow.

Yeah, I agree.

At least give him an Oscar.

[Toga]

Here's the incident for anyone wondering :P

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2014-04-27/gibson-on-report

[LaHug]

From the video, I would say unintentional but reckless, high contact. Wait for medical report but probably 2-3 weeks with 1-2 for an early guilty plea.

[Rusty00]

Gibson will be in a bit of trouble

Piss weak, deserves a break.

Very average call! Was going the spoil!

He punched Conca's head not the ball. Head high contact, he's goneski.

So did Walker on Westhoff in Rd.1 and he was cleared. There was another similar one which I can't remember the players involved at the moment.

Not sure how you can call a mis-timed spoil piss-weak ???

[Jesty]

All I needed was 116 out of Mitchell for a league win, was looking good for it with 140DT but only got 96SC. Didnt see the game was he really that bad?

[Ricochet]

All I needed was 116 out of Mitchell for a league win, was looking good for it with 140DT but only got 96SC. Didnt see the game was he really that bad?

DE killed both his and Cotchin's scores. Was very unlike Mitchell actually

[Rusty00]

All I needed was 116 out of Mitchell for a league win, was looking good for it with 140DT but only got 96SC. Didnt see the game was he really that bad?

DE killed both his and Cotchin's scores. Was very unlike Mitchell actually

For this reason Mitchell has always been better for AF/DT than SC, but the disparity is not usually that bad :o

[tor01doc]

Gibson will be in a bit of trouble

Piss weak, deserves a break.

Very average call! Was going the spoil!

He punched Conca's head not the ball. Head high contact, he's goneski.

So did Walker on Westhoff in Rd.1 and he was cleared. There was another similar one which I can't remember the players involved at the moment.

Not sure how you can call a mis-timed spoil piss-weak ???

Good result.

Split second late, glancing blow off the scone onto the ball.

Only person who should get a spell is the DH ump who reported him but forgot the 50!  ::)