The Who to start Thread...

Started by Madmax75, August 23, 2011, 10:56:10 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Should is start gaff or smith

Gaff
2 (40%)
Smith
3 (60%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Jay

Quote from: n186 on August 25, 2011, 06:36:41 PM
Thought ill get things rolling...

For me J riewoldt in fwd line, or Z smith in ruck, with Petrie up forward or J riewoldt up fwd and Petrie ruck with Z Smith on bench.. thinking the 2nd option with no other Ruckman for GC.
z.smith for me.

Lower vs Puopolo???

FonFatty

Quote from: n186 on August 25, 2011, 06:36:41 PM
Thought ill get things rolling...

For me J riewoldt in fwd line, or Z smith in ruck, with Petrie up forward or J riewoldt up fwd and Petrie ruck with Z Smith on bench.. thinking the 2nd option with no other Ruckman for GC.
Smith on the bench for sure, J Roo will kick a few goals and score decent, keep Petrie in the ruck and if Cox is a late withdrawal you wont cop a donut..

FonFatty

Which 1 do I bench out of the following;
Burgoyne, Mzungu, Didak, N Riewoldt, Jamar..

Jay

Quote from: FonFatty on August 25, 2011, 06:51:16 PM
Which 1 do I bench out of the following;
Burgoyne, Mzungu, Didak, N Riewoldt, Jamar..
Nroo

tassieguns

Question says it all :D
please vote!!
huge game for me  ;D

FonFatty

Quote from: Jayman on August 25, 2011, 06:47:48 PM
Quote from: n186 on August 25, 2011, 06:36:41 PM
Thought ill get things rolling...

For me J riewoldt in fwd line, or Z smith in ruck, with Petrie up forward or J riewoldt up fwd and Petrie ruck with Z Smith on bench.. thinking the 2nd option with no other Ruckman for GC.
z.smith for me.

Lower vs Puopolo???
Puopolo on the ground for sure, however he is listed as 4th inter change which could possibly be a concern.. You would think he would play on the dogs best small fwd or tag their play maker in back line.. Lower should not feature predominantly in the scoring due to the superior opposition.. It is a tough one though, toss a coin?? LOL

jfitty

I voted Didak since that's who I'm playing. Maybe see if your opponent will play either one of them?

BillyPil

Mzungu will score well, but Didak will do better simply because the Pies will see so much of the ball. Mzungu will get the scaraps of one of the Pies prem mids.

Turbo

Fyfe!

Wait to see if Lower or Broughton is the sub tomorrow night, but if not leave Puopolo on the bench IMO.

whynot102

J & N Reiwoldt, I Smith & Mzungu.

I have no cover in the mids in case Pendles is a late withdrawl or no cover in the forward line if I Smith pulls out.

Peoples thoughts please.

Bennyy

Im going to trade in Brent Harvey for Pavlich this week with my last trade, but leaves me with a question on who to bench out of these 3? Forward line is:

Fyfe, Goodes, OKeefe, Franklin, Chapman, Petrie, N Riewoldt, Harvey(Once i trade pav). Bench: Dixon, I Smith

woofy

yeah id say nick aswell.. we all saw what happen to pavlich. i reakon nicks only playing because its an important game for st kilda.

i can actually put higgins on the field for nick but then id have no emergency in my mids. reakon i should play higgins instead of nick and risk having no emergency in the mids or play it safe? my opponent has nick but no higgins.

Mark

Who would u start...

charliesheen

Lower will probably have a run with role, which will give him opportunity to score.

Whether he will find the ball I dunno.  Could also be a sub dog.

jabroni

nicks playing injured and who knows he could be subbed off if the game is lost by 3/4 time