who to trade?

Started by yeahsup, May 15, 2009, 08:34:10 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

yeahsup

players not playing this week:
Houlihan
Malceski
Rance
Ablett
Grigg
Spencer
Skipworth
Ziebell
Higgins

extended bench players:
J. riewoldt (played poor last week and may not play)
Hartlett

Thats 10 players
obviously i wont need to trade hartlett or riewoldt and probably wont anyway since they arent injured and will both be back next week.
so 8.
ablett is staying
skipworth have held on to too long
spencer doesnt need to be playing

that leave houlihan, rance, malceski, higgins, grigg and ziebell

i want/need to trade malceski, and probably to grimes
so which other should i trade?????
should it be one of skip higgins and ziebell so no doughnut???

yeahsup

im thinking malceski --> grimes
ziebell --> franklin/s.johnson

anything wrong with that?

Prospector_1

Both sound good. Since I missed Ziebell anyway, I'm certainly thinking about that first trade. I only wonder - Grimes, or Cheney? Or should I stick with Prospector's rule #2 - NO DEMONS.

Bomber Rock

Not sure about Prospectors first 2 rules (agree with rule 3 though).

As a bomber, i think Skipworth may struggle a bit to hold a spot in the side. He may be in the age demographic the Ess needs, but his disposal can be pretty poor at times. At the time he is looking to come back, so will Mc Veigh, and a little later so will Welsh and then the Prismall. Its the leadership Skipworth brings to the club, but he will be competeing with these guys. I reckon Ziebell will play most of the year, so i would keep him and trade Skippy

yeahsup

does anybody else agree with bomber rock??
u have some good points there.

Bomber Rock

flower what everyone else thinks....  you are right!!