Roughead for Sylvia OR Rockliff??

Started by jam_737, April 30, 2010, 02:10:38 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

jam_737

Undecided what to do.

TRADE Roughead for Colin Sylvia and leave Bastinac/Martin in midfield/bench respectively. Leaving $40,000 in the kitty.

OR

TRADE Roughead for Rockliff and then TRADE Martin for Sylvia. Leaving $100,000 approx. in the kitty.

What do you think?

jvalles

I take the idea that if you can get a quality mid in the forward line (eg ROK, Harvey etc) then grab him in the forward line and keep the mid space for a specialist mid.

elxam

are you certain that Rocky will play till the end of the season ?
the rookie mids are not ready yet

jam_737

Good point. However i do have a few Mid/Fwd players in my forward line & none in my midfield. So if Sylvia, being a Fwd/Mid, goes into Midfield, then i will have a few more options if there's a few injuries later in the year.

elxam

sound good with mp but martin is still not ready yet, though sylvia is, so ...

personally i would go option 1