2019 Defenders

[IntegralX]

Now or never for Whitfield non-owners. He'll be back above 600k very soon.

I need to find a way to get Lloyd into my side but that r13 bye...I might have to wait until post-bye to do it.

[LaHug]

Which one would you get this week out of Lloyd, Whitfield, Hurn (ignoring byes for the sake of the question)?

[dylanclements]

Which one would you get this week out of Lloyd, Whitfield, Hurn (ignoring byes for the sake of the question)?

I have Lloyd but face the same question between Whitfield and Hurn. Right now I'm thinking Hurn

[crowls]

the one that will increase the most if you dont grab them this week.   so go on BE and expected values.

[quinny88]

Which one would you get this week out of Lloyd, Whitfield, Hurn (ignoring byes for the sake of the question)?

I have Lloyd but face the same question between Whitfield and Hurn. Right now I'm thinking Hurn

Take out Whitfields injury affected game and he's averaging 128.8. He's above the others but you can't go wrong really

[dylanclements]

Take out Whitfields injury affected game and he's averaging 128.8. He's above the others but you can't go wrong really

Whitfield and Hurn very close imo. I was going to go without one of them but both appear to be musts. Maybe you're right that Whitfield is better. But Hurn BE in the 80s means it's almost now or never.

Say both get around 130 - Whitfield is 560k, Hurn 600k.

[quinny88]

Take out Whitfields injury affected game and he's averaging 128.8. He's above the others but you can't go wrong really

Whitfield and Hurn very close imo. I was going to go without one of them but both appear to be musts. Maybe you're right that Whitfield is better. But Hurn BE in the 80s means it's almost now or never.

Say both get around 130 - Whitfield is 560k, Hurn 600k.

I guess that's ok if you plan on getting Whitfield in the following week but he will be 600k+ again and unreachable very soon if you don't do it then. Basically whichever one you don't get you're stuck without for the short term atleast and I'd rather not be without Whitfield. Plus he's 30k cheaper as an added bonus

[dylanclements]

Take out Whitfields injury affected game and he's averaging 128.8. He's above the others but you can't go wrong really

Whitfield and Hurn very close imo. I was going to go without one of them but both appear to be musts. Maybe you're right that Whitfield is better. But Hurn BE in the 80s means it's almost now or never.

Say both get around 130 - Whitfield is 560k, Hurn 600k.

I guess that's ok if you plan on getting Whitfield in the following week but he will be 600k+ again and unreachable very soon if you don't do it then. Basically whichever one you don't get you're stuck without for the short term atleast and I'd rather not be without Whitfield. Plus he's 30k cheaper as an added bonus

Yep, good points actually. I'm seeing things differently because I've decided to move heaven and earth to get both in the next two weeks. For me Hurn now and Whitfield after just looks like the right order. But if you aren't going all out to get both in the short term, which lots won't be, Whitfield is probably a nose in front because of the price diff as you say

[imjusflexin]

I think you lot are massively overrating Hurn.

Obviously an SC gun and will be top-3 defender most likely but is nowhere near Whitfield and considering he is MORE expensive I wouldn't go near him for a while if you don't already have Whitfield or Lloyd. I'd even put Sicily above Hurn at the moment considering his price.

Hurn's scores this year before the outlier game this weekend:

108
89
109
139
121
119
99
107

Obviously great scores but not 600k worthy and not close to Whitfield, who as mentioned earlier is nearly averaging 130 a game minus his injury score.

[kilbluff1985]

[imjusflexin]

[dylanclements]

Obviously great scores but not 600k worthy and not close to Whitfield, who as mentioned earlier is nearly averaging 130 a game minus his injury score.

If he keeps it up that's 600k worthy - it's an average of 117!

And he's only 585k. What a steal  ;D

[js19]

Obviously great scores but not 600k worthy and not close to Whitfield, who as mentioned earlier is nearly averaging 130 a game minus his injury score.

If he keeps it up that's 600k worthy - it's an average of 117!

And he's only 585k. What a steal  ;D

He’s priced pretty much right on his average. You get what you pay for...

[imjusflexin]

Obviously great scores but not 600k worthy and not close to Whitfield, who as mentioned earlier is nearly averaging 130 a game minus his injury score.

If he keeps it up that's 600k worthy - it's an average of 117!

And he's only 585k. What a steal  ;D

But if Whitfield averages anything like his output atm he will be worth far more than 600k.. and he's 30k cheaper! It's a no-brainer!

[dylanclements]

Obviously great scores but not 600k worthy and not close to Whitfield, who as mentioned earlier is nearly averaging 130 a game minus his injury score.

If he keeps it up that's 600k worthy - it's an average of 117!

And he's only 585k. What a steal  ;D

But if Whitfield averages anything like his output atm he will be worth far more than 600k.. and he's 30k cheaper! It's a no-brainer!

I reckon both are must haves. I'm getting both in the next two weeks. To be fair we just spoke about this above!