WXVW Round 4: HUGE Week!

Started by Levi434, February 20, 2018, 03:23:29 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Levi434

Here is what the WXV Rules are:

QuoteIf you do not submit a team once, you are not penalised.
If you do not submit a team 2 times, you are penalised a point.
If you do not submit a team 3 times, you are penalised 2 points.
If you do not submit a team 4 times, you are penalised 3 points, and you are sacked.

In addition, if a team isn't submitted 2 weeks in a row, you could also be sacked.

So in short... make sure you have a back up plan in case you can't submit.




Last year there was a no penalty per week for late teams. There was a 2 premiership point deduction for missing 3 weeks and that is it. Due to this being the 2nd season I fell like there needs to be a stricter and more impactful punishment. Here is what I am thinking in regards to unnamed teams:

1st Time:
Simply receive 1 strike. Your team this week will also be identical to your last submitted team and your weekly score will be deducted 100 points.

2nd Time:
For the 2nd time you will receive your 2nd strike. Your team this week will also be identical to your last submitted team. You will also be deducted 2 premiership points and your weekly score deducted 100 points.

3rd Time:
For the 3rd strike you will be deducted your 1st round draft pick and 4 premiership points. Your team this week will also be identical to your last submitted team and your weekly score deducted 100 points.




I'm open to discussion over the next day or so to if everyone is happy with these rules. These will be implemented this week.

Ziplock

Quote from: Levi434 on February 24, 2018, 02:19:07 PM
Here is what the WXV Rules are:

QuoteIf you do not submit a team once, you are not penalised.
If you do not submit a team 2 times, you are penalised a point.
If you do not submit a team 3 times, you are penalised 2 points.
If you do not submit a team 4 times, you are penalised 3 points, and you are sacked.

In addition, if a team isn't submitted 2 weeks in a row, you could also be sacked.

So in short... make sure you have a back up plan in case you can't submit.




Last year there was a no penalty per week for late teams. There was a 2 premiership point deduction for missing 3 weeks and that is it. Due to this being the 2nd season I fell like there needs to be a stricter and more impactful punishment. Here is what I am thinking in regards to unnamed teams:

1st Time:
Simply receive 1 strike. Your team this week will also be identical to your last submitted team and your weekly score will be deducted 100 points.

2nd Time:
For the 2nd time you will receive your 2nd strike. Your team this week will also be identical to your last submitted team. You will also be deducted 2 premiership points and your weekly score deducted 100 points.

3rd Time:
For the 3rd strike you will be deducted your 1st round draft pick and 4 premiership points. Your team this week will also be identical to your last submitted team and your weekly score deducted 100 points.




I'm open to discussion over the next day or so to if everyone is happy with these rules. These will be implemented this week.


wow worlds is savage. In euros you just cop last weeks team :P

I'd rather 50 point deduction than 100. The scoring in womens is so much lower that 100 points guarentees you a loss essentially- even if you didnt have the same team as last week.

Similarly, I'd prefer the deduction of a second round pick for the 3rd strike. For instance pick 1 being removed is the difference between being competitive in 3 years time or staying at the bottom of the ladder.

DO the strikes carry through the season? I mean to be fair, people really shouldn't be submitting late teams 3 times in a 7 round HA season :P

Levi434

#17
Brisbane VS Freo:

NameDTSC
Kara Donnellan8896
Jess Wuetschner8388
Ashlee Atkins6575
Jamie Stanton6569
Gabby O'Sullivan6468
Kate Lutkins7067
Emily Bates6265
Kaitlyn Ashmore5463
Emma Zielke5358
Nat Exon6457
Lara Filocamo6656
Sabrina Frederick-Traub5354
Nicole Hildebrand4052
Tahlia Randall4551
Alexandra Anderson6048
Dana Hooker5647
Hayley Miller5147
Brittany Gibson4943
Jordan Zanchetta4843
Belinda Smith3641
Lisa Webb4938
Breanna Koenen4336
Amy Lavell2735
Ebony Antonio3733
Melissa Caulfield3733
Leah Kaslar3933
Alicia Janz2730
Stacey Barr3227
Leah Mascall3127
Isabella Ayre2422
Emma Pittman2521
Alex Williams2420
Stephanie Cain2219
Kate McCarthy1919
Sharni Webb2819
Evangeline Gooch2117
Cassie Davidson1815
Ashley Sharp1514
Jodie White1514
Gabby Collingwood1210
Emily McGuire136
Arianna Clarke72

Purple 77

100 points feels harsh, but then again, I should have just submitted the team.

Shall cop on chin, and move on  :)

fanTCfool

You could name an entire XV that would score under 100 points in WXVW  :P

Levi434

Melbourne VS Collingwood

NameDTSC
Jasmine Garner8084
Harriet Cordner5875
Christina Bernardi5874
Stephanie Chiocci7474
Caitlyn Edwards6974
Jaimee Lambert7473
Emma King6571
Karen Paxman6967
Daisy Pearce5165
Meg Downie5760
Shelley Scott5157
Melissa Kuys5256
Elise O'Dea6756
Amelia Barden5452
Moana Hope5350
Richelle Cranston3848
Bianca Jakobsson4647
Ashleigh Guest3642
Jess Duffin4041
Kate Hore3338
Lauren Tesoriero3638
Tegan Cunningham3237
Iilish Ross4137
Brittany Bonnici4136
Sarah D'Arcy3436
Laura Duryea3334
Emma Grant4034
Meg Hutchins3533
Erin Hoare2729
Melissa Hickey2927
Katherine Smith2726
Alyssa Mifsud2325
Chloe Molloy3325
Lily Mithen3824
Anna Teague1919
Holly Whitford2219
Catherine Phillips2217
Jasmine Grierson1412
Aliesha Newman1512
Cecilia McIntosh1511
Ruby Schleicher115
Sarah Dargan93

Levi434

In regards to the first strike. I'm inclined to change the points deduction for the 1st strike only from 100 down to 50. The rest will stay at 100.

Levi434

Score Updates:

PosBogotaScoreBonusFinalPosPort MoresbyScoreBonusFinal
D1E. Bates65C130D1M. Hickey27127
D2D. Hardiman0DNP0D2J. Barclay010
D3G. Pound34134D3S. Campbell0DNP0
D4E. Bennetts010D4T. Hetherington010
M1A. Guest42142M1L. Mithen24VC24
M2J. Lambert73VC73M2T. Randall51151
M3J. Hosking22122M3N. Callinan21121
M4L. Filocamo56156M4J. McCormick010
R1R. Metcalfe010R1A. O’Connor51151
F1E. Zielke58158F1T. Cunningham37137
F2S. Perkins010F2C. Randall0C0
F3I. Ayre22122F3R. Killian010
F4M. Hunt0DNP0F4L. Tesoriero38138
I1M. Gay39139I1R. Beeson010
I2J. Grierson12112I2A. Gogos82182
E1B. Bonnici36OOP18E1D. Berry0OOP0
E2T. Lucas-Rodd3700E2S. Thompson000
E3L. Mascall27127E3J. White1400
Played:12Played:8
TOTAL:533TOTAL:331
PosBarcelonaScoreBonusFinalPosLimaScoreBonusFinal
D1C. Edwards74174D1A. Williams20120
D2B. Toogood78178D2P. McWilliams010
D3A. Atkins75175D3H. Cordner75175
D4N. Hilderbrand52152D4L. Bailey28128
M1E. Marinoff0C0M1K. Donnellan96C192
M2L. Webb38138M2A. Anderson48VC48
M3B. White010M3S. Scott57157
M4K. Loynes010M4J. Stanton69169
R1E. King71171R1L. Spark16116
F1S. Frederick-Traub54VC54F1C. Bernardi74174
F2C. Molloy25125F2K. Hore38138
F3B. Jakobsson47147F3C. Staunton010
F4J. Garner84184F4A. Schmidt010
I1M. Kuys56156I1D. Varnhagen010
I2H. Scott70170I2S. Armistead010
E1B. Tully000E1R. Forth000
E2R. Schleicher500E2K. McLeod2000
E3N. Exon5700E3K. Gillespie-Jones2700
Played:12Played:10
TOTAL:724TOTAL:617
PosAlgeriaScoreBonusFinalPosKarachiScoreBonusFinal
D1S. Chiocci74174D1N. Stevens39139
D2E. Grant34134D2E. Antonio33133
D3M. Hutchins33133D3C. Cramey010
D4M. Downie60160D4S. Cain13113
M1D. Pearce65C130M1E. O’Dea56156
M2C. Gum0VC0M2E. Phillips0C0
M3A. Farrugia010M3J. Bruton52152
M4A. Barden52152M4E. Gooch17117
R1E. Hoare29129R1L. Kaslar33133
F1R. Cranston48148F1E. Swanson010
F2S. Barr27127F2A. Eva0VC0
F3M. Rajcic010F3J. Duffin41141
F4L. Arnell72172F4A. Lavell35135
I1B. Lochland1311131I1A. Newman12112
I2A. Foley010I2E. Brush010
E1R. Hicks200E1I. Ross3700
E2K. Rennie2100E2A. Holmes000
E3J. Mules000E3C. Webb3000
Played:11Played:10
TOTAL:690TOTAL:331
PosRomeScoreBonusFinalPosJakartaScoreBonusFinal
D1K. Ashmore63163D1K. Paxman67C134
D2C. Davidson15115D2H. Miller47147
D3C. McIntosh11111D3B. Koenen36136
D4K. Lutkins67167D4B. Smith41141
M1E. Kearney133C266M1S. Hosking54154
M2M. Conti56156M2D. Cox010
M3K. Gibson010M3N. Barr010
M4K. Lamb78178M4P. Monahan010
R1T. Ernst30130R1E. McKinnon010
F1M. Hope50150F1E. Blackburn94VC94
F2D. Vescio25VC25F2D. Hooker47147
F3S. Allan010F3S. Audley57157
F4S. Webb19119F4J. Wuestschner010
I1J. Dal Pos010I1G. O’Sullivan68168
I2M. Keryk32132I2A. Downie32132
E1E. Humphries000E1B. Gibson4300
E2E. Gamble000E2R. Wallace000
E3M. Collier000E3A. Utri5500
Played:12Played:10
TOTAL:712TOTAL:610

Torpedo10

I had a dream last night that #Paxmania scored 50.

Close enough.  :P

Levi434

Bogota VS PMC is very close. Both teams underperforming here. It will definitely come down to how PMC Captain Chelsea Randall plays.

Barcelona are on fire! They are a serious chance to break 1000 this week! In fact 1100 isn't beyond them if Marinoff has another huge game. Lima are actually still in it though! I just don't think you can deny Barcelona this one.

Daisy Pearce is human? Algeria gave Karachi a sniff and the have the talent still to come but I'm not sure if they will be able to overcome this slow start.

Rome and Jakarta are in an absolute shootout here! What a game to watch! I can't help but feel Jakarta's midfield may well let it down again!

fanTCfool

Weustschner has played and scored 88. Cox is suspended and will not play so Gibson's score will come on.
Jakarta 741/12 lead Rome 712/12

Torpedo10

Quote from: fanTCfool on February 25, 2018, 12:46:18 PM
Weustschner has played and scored 88. Cox is suspended and will not play so Gibson's score will come on.
Jakarta 741/12 lead Rome 712/12
Minus the 50 means we are just ahead.  ;)

Will be tight, Collier needs to play for us to have a shot IMO!

fanTCfool

Quote from: Torpedo10 on February 25, 2018, 12:51:19 PM
Quote from: fanTCfool on February 25, 2018, 12:46:18 PM
Weustschner has played and scored 88. Cox is suspended and will not play so Gibson's score will come on.
Jakarta 741/12 lead Rome 712/12
Minus the 50 means we are just ahead.  ;)

Will be tight, Collier needs to play for us to have a shot IMO!

Both teams get a -50, but I appreciate your effort  :P

Torpedo10

Oh man I could've sworn the games started at 7:40 on Friday!

Oh well, it's going to be close either way.

Purple 77

Defenders finally came to the party!

I just need marinoff to not-spud