Player X vs. Player Y

[Samsturmfels]

Brayshaw or Brodie?

Brayshaw

[Koop]

Not sure who to go at D4. Have Billings, Greene and Smith so far.
Thinking McLean vs Dahl? Thoughts? Or any opinions on a better option?

McLean out of those two.

[Samsturmfels]

Not sure who to go at D4. Have Billings, Greene and Smith so far.
Thinking McLean vs Dahl? Thoughts? Or any opinions on a better option?

Im sure both of them could potentially be a good pick up. If i had to pick one id go Dahl, based off scoring history

[jfitty]

Kade Simpson vs Shane Savage?

Savage up to 12% ownership now, thinking of making the switch back to Mr Reliable (in 8% of sides).

Savage was a much more fun pick back when he was in around 5-6% of sides.. Not so sure now.

[ando_10]

Kade Simpson vs Shane Savage?

Savage up to 12% ownership now, thinking of making the switch back to Mr Reliable (in 8% of sides).

Savage was a much more fun pick back when he was in around 5-6% of sides.. Not so sure now.

as a saints supporter and a school mate of savs i hope its sav but i think he could be a little trap.

simpson is the man here.

[Koop]

Kade Simpson vs Shane Savage?

Savage up to 12% ownership now, thinking of making the switch back to Mr Reliable (in 8% of sides).

Savage was a much more fun pick back when he was in around 5-6% of sides.. Not so sure now.

Same boat here. Would appreciate people's opinions too.

[jfitty]

Kade Simpson vs Shane Savage?

Savage up to 12% ownership now, thinking of making the switch back to Mr Reliable (in 8% of sides).

Savage was a much more fun pick back when he was in around 5-6% of sides.. Not so sure now.

Same boat here. Would appreciate people's opinions too.

He's just crept up a little higher than I would have liked actually. Around 8% would have been ideal, since popping up in a few of the HS "experts" teams his ownership is climbing.

Simpson has always been one of my first picked and might stick with him again. Big responsibility this year without Doc.

[tkringle]

Brayshaw or Brodie?

Choosing between the top 2 midfield rookies of the year? Damn.

Yeah Coffield out has made me go up to Bonner.. Leaves only enough funds for one of Brodie or Brayshaw :(

[Koop]

Kade Simpson vs Shane Savage?

Savage up to 12% ownership now, thinking of making the switch back to Mr Reliable (in 8% of sides).

Savage was a much more fun pick back when he was in around 5-6% of sides.. Not so sure now.

Same boat here. Would appreciate people's opinions too.

He's just crept up a little higher than I would have liked actually. Around 8% would have been ideal, since popping up in a few of the HS "experts" teams his ownership is climbing.

Simpson has always been one of my first picked and might stick with him again. Big responsibility this year without Doc.

Had him in my December initial side, same thoughts as you mate. Just have concerns about Simmo slowing down, but no one else really fills me with boatloads of confidence.

[ubeaut]

Brayshaw or Brodie?

Both

[zoomba23]

Kade Simpson vs Shane Savage?

Savage up to 12% ownership now, thinking of making the switch back to Mr Reliable (in 8% of sides).

Savage was a much more fun pick back when he was in around 5-6% of sides.. Not so sure now.

as a saints supporter and a school mate of savs i hope its sav but i think he could be a little trap.

simpson is the man here.

Gut tells me positional change will work well for Savage. Never been a proven scorer, but he tonned up a fair bit in the back half of last season and impressed in JLT. Reckon he's the type of rebounder the Saints need if they're going to push September, which puts him above both Simpson and Lloyd in my book.

[jfitty]

Kade Simpson vs Shane Savage?

Savage up to 12% ownership now, thinking of making the switch back to Mr Reliable (in 8% of sides).

Savage was a much more fun pick back when he was in around 5-6% of sides.. Not so sure now.

as a saints supporter and a school mate of savs i hope its sav but i think he could be a little trap.

simpson is the man here.

Gut tells me positional change will work well for Savage. Never been a proven scorer, but he tonned up a fair bit in the back half of last season and impressed in JLT. Reckon he's the type of rebounder the Saints need if they're going to push September, which puts him above both Simpson and Lloyd in my book.

Think you make some good points, reckon I'll stick with him.

Simpson will go about his business and be around the same price all year you'd think, really want to look for the next wave of backline premiums.

[zoomba23]

T. Mitchell or D. Martin ?

If you're looking for consistency definitely Titch. As good as Dusty is, he'll throw in a stinker somewhere which'll get his price down. Dusty higher ceiling, Titch higher average imo.

[Koop]

Dow or one of Fogarty/Constable/etc. (whoever is named Sunday)

[MC]

Dow or one of Fogarty/Constable/etc. (whoever is named Sunday)

I'm staying away from them all! Fog could just as easily be dropped for Tex next week. Dow's scoring was pretty poor in JLT etc.
Constable I guess if you trust his JS.


Please pick 3 of the following:
Bell vs Bundy Christensen
Treloar vs Bont
Dahlhaus vs McLean