2018 rookies

[Toga]

Spargo v Ronke?

Leaning towards Spargo at the moment with that easier draw coming up that Big Mac mentioned... Ronke tackles so well though so could have a higher floor - but is there anyone likely to come in and take his spot?

[HappyDEZ]

Spargo v Ronke?

Leaning towards Spargo at the moment with that easier draw coming up that Big Mac mentioned... Ronke tackles so well though so could have a higher floor - but is there anyone likely to come in and take his spot?

Hard to say about either of their JS. I would probs lean towards Spargo only because of DPP.

[Goosey]

Spargo v Ronke?

Leaning towards Spargo at the moment with that easier draw coming up that Big Mac mentioned... Ronke tackles so well though so could have a higher floor - but is there anyone likely to come in and take his spot?

Hard to say about either of their JS. I would probs lean towards Spargo only because of DPP.

Spargo this week, Ronke next week?

[RoughRed]

Lewis Jetta, WCE expected to me a couple of weeks with a calf injury - Ainsworth likely replacement

WA Today " Jetta’s expected absence is likely to open the door for another first-year draftee Brayden Ainsworth.

If Ainsworth is called into the in-form Eagles outfit the hard-nut utility will be the sixth West Coast debutant so far this year.

Ainsworth further served notice he is on the brink of a senior call-up with another top performance at Eagles alignment team East Perth on Sunday with 28 disposals"

http://www.watoday.com.au/sport/wa-sport/dockers-derby-damage-could-see-walters-missing-for-lengthy-stint-20180501-p4zcn2.html

[sammy123]

So kelly to crouch next week?

[RaisyDaisy]

So kelly to crouch next week?

Wish I had the luxury

I'll probably keep Kelly until his bye and get rid of all the other duds first

[sammy123]

So kelly to crouch next week?

Wish I had the luxury

I'll probably keep Kelly until his bye and get rid of all the other duds first

Sorry to read your SC season has gone to hell

[Koop]

So kelly to crouch next week?

Wish I had the luxury

I'll probably keep Kelly until his bye and get rid of all the other duds first

Sorry to read your SC season has gone to hell

Really? I haven't seen anything from RD about it.

[Marstar]

So kelly to crouch next week?

Wish I had the luxury

I'll probably keep Kelly until his bye and get rid of all the other duds first

Sorry to read your SC season has gone to hell

Really? I haven't seen anything from RD about it.

;D 8) :-X

[RaisyDaisy]

Yeah I haven't said anything - I'm flying, not far off 1st overall

[brodiejay]

My season hasn't started well... but yours sounds rough RD, so I won't complain.

My trades will likely be:

1) Josh Kelly -> Patrick Cripps.       I've held Kelly for this long because GWS keep saying he's close but I think I'm losing too many points with him on the bench for another 2 weeks.

2) Banfield or Holman -> Lachie Neale.       Neale has had a slow start and is priced really low considering his potential and scoring history. I think he'll average 110 from here on out.  Just need to decide which rookie to trade out. Leaning towards Banfield, as his BE is higher and Holman is capable of bigger scores.

Will likely go double downgrade next week of something like:

1) Holman -> Spargo
2) J Stephenson or J Henry -> Ronke


Can anyone convince me to trade Holman before Banfield???

[HappyDEZ]

At this stage I am trading Holman ahead of Banfield. I just get the feeling Holman is a lot closer to playing NEAFL than Banfield is to playing WAFL.

[Bully]

At this stage I am trading Holman ahead of Banfield. I just get the feeling Holman is a lot closer to playing NEAFL than Banfield is to playing WAFL.

I'd keep Holman, perfect guy to have over the bye period.

[ubeaut]

At this stage I am trading Holman ahead of Banfield. I just get the feeling Holman is a lot closer to playing NEAFL than Banfield is to playing WAFL.

I'd keep Holman, perfect guy to have over the bye period.

In the short term, rather keep Holman and hope he gets another good score to make more cash.
But because he can also get 30s there's no way I'd keep him over the byes. He could easily lose a lot of that cash keeping him that long.

[Bully]

At this stage I am trading Holman ahead of Banfield. I just get the feeling Holman is a lot closer to playing NEAFL than Banfield is to playing WAFL.

I'd keep Holman, perfect guy to have over the bye period.

In the short term, rather keep Holman and hope he gets another good score to make more cash.
But because he can also get 30s there's no way I'd keep him over the byes. He could easily lose a lot of that cash keeping him that long.

He's the perfect player over the byes, any low scores will drop off & he plays all 3 rounds. Doubt he will lose cash if he can score well this week.