Main Menu

Brownlow 2017

Started by jvalles69, March 21, 2017, 07:57:41 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

jvalles69

Haven't had a chance to poll my votes yet.  :)

dmac07

Round 2

Coll 80 v Rich 99
3. T.Cotchin
2. A.Trelorlar
1. B.Grundy

WB 110 v Syd 87
3. M.Bontempelli
2. L.Jong
1. L.Franklin

Haw 89 v Ade 113
3. R.Sloane
2. S.Jacobs
1. T.Mitchell

GWS 160 v GC 58
3. T.Greene
2. J.Cameron
1. J.Kelly

Bris 84 v Ess 111
3. Z.Merrett
2. D.Beams
1. O.Fantasia

WC 116 v StK 97
3. L.Shuey
2. A.Gaff
1. E.Yeo

Geel 112 vs NM 111
3. S.Higgins
2. P.Dangerfield
1. J.Selwood

Melb 86 v Carl 64
3. C.Salem
2. C.Oliver
1. M.Muprhy

PA 145 v Fre 56
3. R.Gray
2. O.Wines
1. S.Powel-Pepper

Which gives me a leaderboard like this

5-
Z.Merrett
O.Wines

4-
M.Bontempelli
D.Beams
P.Dangerfield
C.Oliver

SydneyRox

How you have Bont at 3 for that game and not given picken a vote is criminal!!


dmac07

Quote from: SydneyRox on April 04, 2017, 02:51:28 PM
How you have Bont at 3 for that game and not given picken a vote is criminal!!

Its not necessarily my ranking of best players, but who I think will get the votes. Bont was quiet early but overall had 30 touches and 2 goals to Pickens 21 and 2. Also 5 more tackles. Bont is more noticable in general too.

Pickens votes history is terrible too, he has 4 brownlow votes in 8 years and 0 last season in the best year of his career.

jvalles69

Quote from: dmac07 on April 04, 2017, 05:11:40 PM
Quote from: SydneyRox on April 04, 2017, 02:51:28 PM
How you have Bont at 3 for that game and not given picken a vote is criminal!!

Its not necessarily my ranking of best players, but who I think will get the votes. Bont was quiet early but overall had 30 touches and 2 goals to Pickens 21 and 2. Also 5 more tackles. Bont is more noticable in general too.

Pickens votes history is terrible too, he has 4 brownlow votes in 8 years and 0 last season in the best year of his career.

^This is prudent in Brownlow voting, if tossing up with votes always pick the guy that usually gets votes over someone who polls terribly.

meow meow

Should probably lock in Lewis Taylor, all the other guys are nothing more than flashy players who the media like to talk up.

_wato

NM v GEEL
3 S Higgins (NM)
2 P Dangerfield (Geel)
1 J Selwood (Geel)

MELB v CARL
3 C Oliver (Melb)
2 C Salem (Melb)
1 M Murphy (Carl)

PA v FREO
3 R Gray (PA)
2 O Wines (PA)
1 S Powell-Pepper (PA)

For the remaining games I hadn't done.

_wato

Already early but I think Danger will poll super well again. Fyfe in a losing team every week won't help him, hasn't really shown massive things so far. Gaz no good. Dusty will slow down imo. Bont will have too many blokes steal votes.

Danger @$4.50 wowee

jvalles69

Quote from: _wato on April 05, 2017, 04:27:57 PM
Already early but I think Danger will poll super well again. Fyfe in a losing team every week won't help him, hasn't really shown massive things so far. Gaz no good. Dusty will slow down imo. Bont will have too many blokes steal votes.

Danger @$4.50 wowee

Danger and Bont for me.

Every year someone talks about stealing votes, don't see it happening especially with the Dogs.  Voss, Black and Aker, Judd, Cousins and Priddis all won with relatively stacked midfields.

jvalles69

Round 2

Tigers vs Pies
3 â€" Cotchin
2 â€" Treloar
1 â€" Grundy

Dogs vs Swans
3 â€" Bontempelli
2 â€" Franklin
1 â€" Reid

Hawks vs Crows
3 â€" Sloane
2 â€" Lynch
1 â€" Mitchell

Giants vs Suns
3 â€" Greene
2 â€" Cameron
1 â€" Kelly

Lions vs Bombers
3 â€" Merrett
2 â€" Fantasia
1 â€" Rockliff

Eagles vs Saints
3 â€" Shuey
2 â€" Yeo
1 â€" Kennedy

Cats vs Roos
3 â€" Dangerfield
2 â€" Selwood
1 â€" Higgins

Dees vs Blues
3 â€" Oliver
2 â€" Murphy
1 â€" Salem

Power vs Dockers
3 â€" Gray
2 â€" Wines
1 - Fyfe

_wato

SYD v COLL
3 T Adams (Coll)
2 D Hannebery (Syd)
1 A Treloar (Coll)

That was a tough game to judge. Fasolo, Sidebottom and Pendles could all steal a vote there.

dmac07

Quote from: _wato on April 08, 2017, 03:03:08 AM
SYD v COLL
3 T Adams (Coll)
2 D Hannebery (Syd)
1 A Treloar (Coll)

That was a tough game to judge. Fasolo, Sidebottom and Pendles could all steal a vote there.

Agree with these votes byt very tough game to do. JPK and Grundy two more who could get votes.. so really throw a blanlet over about 7 guys any order.

AaronKirk

My 321 for last night are the same as Wato

jvalles69

Interesting...I had the same votes too, although I found it one of the hardest to pick!

Hawka

Quote from: dmac07 on April 08, 2017, 09:12:39 AM
Quote from: _wato on April 08, 2017, 03:03:08 AM
SYD v COLL
3 T Adams (Coll)
2 D Hannebery (Syd)
1 A Treloar (Coll)

That was a tough game to judge. Fasolo, Sidebottom and Pendles could all steal a vote there.

Agree with these votes byt very tough game to do. JPK and Grundy two more who could get votes.. so really throw a blanlet over about 7 guys any order.
Add Grundy in the mix to
Glad im not doing votes for this game haha