Player X v Player Y

[HotTiges]

KK and Birch

Vs

Brodie Smith and Shaw

[Bully]

KK and Birch

Vs

Brodie Smith and Shaw

Smith & Shaw easily.

[HotTiges]

KK and Birch

Vs

Brodie Smith and Shaw

Smith & Shaw easily.

Cheers..thinking shaw most likely no.1 DEF Smith possibly top 8? KK maybe top 10 Birch top 15

[Bully]

KK and Birch

Vs

Brodie Smith and Shaw

Smith & Shaw easily.

Cheers..thinking shaw most likely no.1 DEF Smith possibly top 8? KK maybe top 10 Birch top 15

Shaw is the only sure thing, if Birch has another mid eighties season then he becomes an outlier. KK is another who might just be a pedestrian type. Don't think Smith will crack the ton but he is more than capable of finishing in the 90's, particularly given he will be a midfielder this year.

[H1bb3i2d]

Which one do i NOT pick?

Yeo vs Bartel vs KK vs Rampe vs Birchall

Rampe < KK < Yeo < Birchall < Bartel

I forget which way the arrows go haha is bartel or rampe first

Rampe bad, Bartel good. (They're facing the opposite way they usually do on this forum, cus you asked your question backwards)

[tommy10]

Priddis v Hanners v Gray v JPK and in which order please

[Ringo]

Priddis v Hanners v Gray v JPK and in which order please

All this is subjective as we will no doubt have differing views amongst members/

My order would be Gray who has a huge upside then Priddis - Super consistent with a very little deviation though,  and then hard to separate JPK and Hanners as both similar and will finish very close together average wise overall.

[MC]

Priddis v Hanners v Gray v JPK and in which order please

Tough call, they're all so similar!
If I had to:

JPK > Priddis > Gray > Hannebery

- JPK has the ceiling and is decent value I think
- Priddis is just so consistent
- Gray because Port will win quite a bit more
- Hannebery last only because he has only had 1 decent year.

[dosstheboss]

Priddis v Hanners v Gray v JPK and in which order please

Gray > Hannebury > Priddis > JPK, but there's nothing in it

[GoLions]

Priddis v Hanners v Gray v JPK and in which order please

JPK, Gray, Hanners, Priddis

[H1bb3i2d]

Gray > Hanners > JPK > Priddis

[mattttwillll]

is Pendlebury a must have?

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Priddis v Hanners v Gray v JPK and in which order please

Gray---  think he'll kill it this year
JPK ---  will kick goals and get lots of contested possessions
Priddis  ultra consistent but think he may have a slight drop this year
Hanners  Just a little behind the others but not a great deal between first and last                      ;)

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :)

J Lonergan  V  P Seedsman            any chance either might become a keeper ??                       ::)

[MC]

:)

J Lonergan  V  P Seedsman            any chance either might become a keeper ??                       ::)

I wouldn't choose either in the traditional SC format of the game. Seeds averaged 80-odd in his second season and can go big, though a new club might take some getting used to. Lonergan has the potential to step right up with some healthy mid time, perhaps a smokey to bump to 85 or so - though I wouldn't bank on it.