Rate my team - NEED HELP!!

[needshelp]

Backs - Mackie, Enright, C Cornes, Mcphee, Malceski, D Myers, Broadbent
Petrenko, Klemke

Midfield - G Ablett, J Selwood, Judd, Kerr, Skipworth, Coughlin
Rich, Sidebottom

Ruck - Cox, Leunberger
Sellar,Vickery

Forward - Deledio, Franklin, Brown, Corrie, Higgins, Henschtel, Gumbleton
Walker Ziebell

[Heater]

I'm not a fan of McPhee as he tends to make a heap of mistakes.  Other than that your backs look OK.

Your mids look pretty strong.  Skipworth is the only one who may not play early on and Sidebottom perhaps too.

I'm not sold on J.Brown or N.Brown (Rich) and Corrie may not get a game...?  Why not have Ryan O'Keefe instead?  Not sure Ziebell will play early on; we are talking about the Fantasy Coach AntiChrist, Laidley!!

[Hawks_1976]

Mackie may become more accountable with Harley out and his scores may suffer. I'd  downgrade him to a Birchall, Mundy or Hargrave. Use this to improve on Broadbent ( might find it hard to break into Port's best 22 ).
Klemke would need to be elevated off the rookie list to get a game.
Elevate Rich to your 22 and give Skippy and Cogs a miss. Skippy was injured in a recent intra club match and yesterday Cogs had another knee complaint. Swallow could be a cheap mid replacement.
Luenberger will play as No.2 ruck for Brisbane but his numbers won't be great. His injury last year means that his breakout season may be another 12 months away.
Corrie is a major risk and keep a close eye on Henstchel.