Is Travis Cloke the biggest potato in the AFL?

[Vinny]

Please Discuss.

[tor01doc]

He'd be better at Carlton with Malthouse.

And get Setanta back to kick his butt.

[quinny88]

Vin I would have saved this for after friday night. You have left yourself open if he kicks a bag against ya now :P

[Bill Manspeaker]

haha love it vin  ;D

[elephants]

The poll options should really be 'yes' or 'yes' not 'yes' and 'no' hey Vin ;) haha

[kilbluff1985]

still better then Waite

[Nails]

Even if he's a big potato he's still better than every single forward on the Carlton list. I'd nearly go as far to say he's better than all of Carlton's forwards combined.

[tor01doc]

Hang on. That's a bit harsh.

How about Peter McKenna?

[JBs-Hawks]

Cloke may be a spud, but Carlton is a Potato Farm!

[Nige]

Vin I would have saved this for after friday night. You have left yourself open if he kicks a bag against ya now :P

[T Dog]

Vin I would have saved this for after friday night. You have left yourself open if he kicks a bag against ya now :P

Not if..when.. ;D

[Vinny]

Okay here we go.  :P

He'd be better at Carlton with Malthouse.

And get Setanta back to kick his butt.

Hahaha

Vin I would have saved this for after friday night. You have left yourself open if he kicks a bag against ya now :P

Not if..when.. ;D

Nah I'll be alright, he sucks. Will kick 2.3 ;)

Cloke may be a spud, but Carlton is a Potato Farm!

Not in the last two weeks. Kind of...haha.

still better then Waite

Not this year man!

The poll options should really be 'yes' or 'yes' not 'yes' and 'no' hey Vin ;) haha

Hahah yeah it should. But I had to leave an option for the deluded pies supporters. :P #bringontheheat

haha love it vin  ;D

;)

[Mailman the 2nd]

People say the Carlton forward line was overrated, but Cloke is more overrated than all of them combined.

And he's still a potato. He looks like the strongest man in the AFL but is just so piss-weak

[Vinny]

People say the Carlton forward line was overrated, but Cloke is more overrated than all of them combined.

And he's still a potato. He looks like the strongest man in the AFL but is just so piss-weak

+10,000,000.



Our Carlton forward line isn't overrated, it's rated pretty badly cause it's pretty bad.

But Henderson and Waite look to be in good form and Garlett and Levi are coming along nicely ish.

Henderson/Waite > Cloke this year easy.

Cloke also has some of the best delivery in the competition.

[Spite]

People say the Carlton forward line was overrated, but Cloke is more overrated than all of them combined.

And he's still a potato. He looks like the strongest man in the AFL but is just so piss-weak

+10,000,000.



Our Carlton forward line isn't overrated, it's rated pretty badly cause it's pretty bad.

But Henderson and Waite look to be in good form and Garlett and Levi are coming along nicely ish.

Henderson/Waite > Cloke this year easy.

Cloke also has some of the best delivery in the competition.

You don't watch many collingwood games do you? Just because we have an elite midfield doesn't mean the delivery to cloke is so special. In fact, most of the time we use him, it's a long bomb and hope he can just catch it while he is being double teamed. Does his lead up and mark need more work? hell yes. But thats what we got Jesse white for and Jamie Elliot isn't doing a bad job either at it. The elite midfielders are mostly kicking the goals themselves and Cloke isn't the target he used to be last year - a point we have tried to prove by not relying on him this year and spread the goalkickers more evenly.