Discuss the game here
Hammer dominating early along with Ebert
Stevenson and Wines have started strongly.
Wines 3 frees for already... But only been able to take it once ::)
Wines seems like he has played 200 games plays like such a veteran
Rising star winner for sure.
viney the standout, 6 possessions 5 contested, 100% disposal efficiency - CLASS ACT
Starting to regret the decision not to start with Viney would have to bring him in soon if he keeps this up.
i knew Jack Watts was not to be trusted.
watts will be a star, give him time :) HOWWWWE good is howe going be too
Why didn't anyone talk Viney up much? I'm a White Goodman for getting stuck with Mitchell on field and not even having Viney.
Quote from: Nails on March 31, 2013, 02:37:40 PM
Why didn't anyone talk Viney up much? I'm a White Goodman for getting stuck with Mitchell on field and not even having Viney.
kid is a superstar. would have gone top 2 in the draft i think everyone knew that :P
already played senior footy as an underaged player
get him in !
pittard on the other hand i wish i had benched and started heath but stevenson performing as expected, not starting neade but not unhappy with him either for a toothpick :)
jones i also have and he looks a good pick if he can hold his spot, but when blease is fit one mid has to go to make way for him....
toumpas i reckon ? or jones :(
perfect - i sledge pittard and he kicks a goal :)
hartlett is looking like a must also, dominant port midfielder who kicks goals not a bad guy to slot into your defence?
More than likely will bring in Hartlett next week for Goddard still unsure how Heppell got in my team when I had Hammer the entire pre season.
Quote from: Noz on March 31, 2013, 02:51:25 PM
More than likely will bring in Hartlett next week for Goddard still unsure how Heppell got in my team when I had Hammer the entire pre season.
EXACTLY what happened to me.... Why oh why!!
no one talked Viney up, everyone spoke Mitchell up. My team is so bad, how did I get sucked in #no Viney. My team should be good, but I've lost out on like every 50/50 decision
#ebert #hopehegunsit
How good is Brad Ebert? Imagine if he was in a top 4 team now. Better than when he was at his old club.
howe good is howe imagine if he was in a top 4 team.
Anyone not have Mitchell on the field?
Quote from: Madsnake on March 31, 2013, 03:01:21 PM
Anyone not have Mitchell on the field?
His on the bench for me always knew he would start as the sub
Atleast 1 good decision went my way this week.
Quote from: Madsnake on March 31, 2013, 03:01:21 PM
Anyone not have Mitchell on the field?
I don't have him at all now got him out before lockout and put Viney back in
I have Viney,Stevenson and Pittard all playing.
how does dunn still get games = spud
VINEY - 14 touches 11 contested and a GOAL over his shoulder if you don't mind -wow wee boy oh boy
I had Viney for quite a while actually, traded him out when he didn't play NAB. Not sure what I was thinking, didn't realise how popular he was. This will wreck my entire season now. Oh well. If I knew he was so popular :o I needed to look at other's teams more
Had Viney on the bench all week but switched him with Mitchell, good decision at this stage
this is a shootout for mark of the year
Howe, Schultz, Pedersen and now Wingard has an attempt
redden is dominating in the ruck, scoring shower in DT but his SC would be great every hitout to advantage, impressive...
Having Mitchell sub is the worst call of the season so far. He's almost their best player. Ebert, HH and Boak the only players I Rate ahead of him. Absolute superstar.
That 2000 is looking all that much harder with Mitchell sub; unless he can get subbed on at half time, I'll be lucky to make 1900-1950, unless Swanny destroys.
Am happy with the debuts (so far) of Stevenson, Pittard and Wines (all on my ground), while Viney and Neade (on my bench) have both shown good signs.
Quote from: Jukes on March 31, 2013, 03:17:10 PM
Having Mitchell sub is the worst call of the season so far. He's almost their best player. Ebert, HH and Boak the only players I Rate ahead of him. Absolute superstar.
That 2000 is looking all that much harder with Mitchell sub; unless he can get subbed on at half time, I'll be lucky to make 1900-1950, unless Swanny destroys.
Am happy with the debuts (so far) of Stevenson, Pittard and Wines (all on my ground), while Viney and Neade (on my bench) have both shown good signs.
The best DTer of all time, Jukes cannot even get 2000?
Quote from: Colliwobblers on March 31, 2013, 03:10:23 PM
VINEY - 14 touches 11 contested and a GOAL over his shoulder if you don't mind -wow wee boy oh boy
BT would have a field day with Viney haha!
Wouldn't mind seeing Pittard with a bit more run off half back too.
none of the DT Talk boys had Viney on their team in the cheat sheet.
Damn it. How did I miss him? I knew he was f/s jet but didn't play NAB which is what I watch for my rooks.
Hope I can win the 50K from outside 100K after rd 1 lol
And Stevenson
i agree with you on Mitchell.
i have viney on the field in all comps except sportal and supercoach where wines got hte gig ahead of him. but not next week kid is a dead set star.
at least i own him in every comp, just not smart enough to start him in every comp. still wines could still catch up to him the way port are playing.
question is who comes off for blease? toumpas or jones (matt) i own him to but on my bench.
good signs the 3 port defenders most us have are all doing well enough for rooks and in a winning team, should all score as well or better when the ball in in their back line more?
hartlett is a gun sure, but was his shoulder sore as he came from the field at half time, can he stay fit? does it matter with 44 trades?
redden has been solid in the ruck, may be SC relevant but still irrelevant in DT.
shulz another one who could be a gun player if he stays fit and monfries is ok as is byrnes and pettard of those mid priced options, none of which i have.
happy with neade on my bench
watts on 9 is disgraceful, guy could be a star not sure what he is doing, should be loose in the backline should be racking them up???
howe will be a star, will DECOY dawes return help him further.,,?
you'd be disappointed if you owned jack grimes but after goddard and heppell not doing much worse really is he?
@ Nails -s orry had no time to do my DT Detective thread this season or I would have revved viney up - you need to buy a prospectus next season, if you read the write up on viney, as soon as he was named round 1 you wouldn't have considered not having him.
but i agree and as i said above based on wines nab cup form i DID start him in several comps where i had a deeper premium midfield INSTEAD of viney....
still DT 44 trades, nothing is irreparable - looking at you danger
Toumpas - 4 disp at 50%
Matt Jones - 12 disp at 92%
don't think Jones will be subbed
Quote from: Doggoneit on March 31, 2013, 03:36:05 PM
Toumpas - 4 disp at 50%
Matt Jones - 12 disp at 92%
don't think Jones will be subbed
seems that way, but if the game is lost it might be better to get the minutes into toumpas? still not like toumpas hasnt played senior footy himself either, just struggling to get involved, more likely his role than his ability to be fair
Quote from: Doggoneit on March 31, 2013, 03:36:05 PM
Toumpas - 4 disp at 50%
Matt Jones - 12 disp at 92%
don't think Jones will be subbed
If Toumpas' next two possessions are effective, his DE will already be above Ablett's for 2013 :P
I'm worried about Viney getting subbed.
Colli Redden is only on 29 SC at halftime.
I always thought Grimes was overrated. Wasn't in my pre-season side once.
Wish I went Hartlett over Duffman though. :-\
Toumpas looks like he's running around wondering why did I get drafted by Melbourne!!!
Grimes 6 frees for already (8 minutes into the third quarter).
Woosha Woosha sign him up!
Quote from: Jukes on March 31, 2013, 03:50:10 PM
Grimes 6 frees for already (8 minutes into the third quarter).
Woosha Woosha sign him up!
7*
Good I backed out on Jimmy the gun :)
Quote from: Adamant on March 31, 2013, 03:44:51 PM
I always thought Grimes was overrated. Wasn't in my pre-season side once.
Wish I went Hartlett over Duffman though. :-\
Nek minnit 30+ point quarter.
Viney has gone quiet. Only like 10 points this quarter.
After a thrashing like this hopefully Terlich can get a gig next week
Quote from: Nails on March 31, 2013, 04:02:30 PM
Quote from: Adamant on March 31, 2013, 03:44:51 PM
I always thought Grimes was overrated. Wasn't in my pre-season side once.
Wish I went Hartlett over Duffman though. :-\
Nek minnit 30+ point quarter.
Yeah... I was wrong lol.
Quote from: Adamant on March 31, 2013, 04:08:50 PM
Quote from: Nails on March 31, 2013, 04:02:30 PM
Quote from: Adamant on March 31, 2013, 03:44:51 PM
I always thought Grimes was overrated. Wasn't in my pre-season side once.
Wish I went Hartlett over Duffman though. :-\
Nek minnit 30+ point quarter.
Yeah... I was wrong lol.
So was I, I should've said "40+ point quarter"
At least I can say i'm happy with the Hammer!
Monfries ;D ;D ;D
Quote from: luvfooty on March 31, 2013, 03:40:50 PM
Colli Redden is only on 29 SC at halftime.
that shocks me are you watching the game? he has won just about every hit out and all to advantage, hence the clearance differential...
he has towelled jamar up commentators agree with me, although jamar wins the most taps by far, the ones redden has been in he has won and HIS are to advantage. SC is stitching him up! not that i would have him just thought he would be doing well
@ the GRIMES comments = yeah he stood up that quarter, a captains quarter, not much he can do to turn the whole team effort around but at least he has put in 110% which is what we expect of him.
Viney- M Jones - Grimes BOG for Dees, howe too but he hasnt had much of it up there...
hmmmm
the Dees look worse than last year - is that possible?
good signs for Port though - still making some mistakes and bad decisions but the desire to win the ball is 2nd to none. As long as they have the desire they can fix the skill errors - could upset a few teams this year.
Quote from: TexandtheMullet on March 31, 2013, 04:14:54 PM
Monfries ;D ;D ;D
And he gets subbed off......... WTF???
Still happy with his score but subbing him off? Is he injured?
Port for top 4 this year.
Get on it!!
monfries was underdone so makes sense to sub him off - good sign for you who own him, he is underdone injury interupted preseason...
jordie has done well also for the dees.
Hard to see anyone but melb or gws for the spoon.
Quote from: Colliwobblers on March 31, 2013, 04:21:38 PM
monfries was underdone so makes sense to sub him off - good sign for you who own him, he is underdone injury interupted preseason...
jordie has done well also for the dees.
Still fairly happy, got him in CentreBet! Hartlett and Gus saving me!
We could deffinetly have 9 wins within the first 11 rounds with 7 games to play at home after our bye and a match against GWS and hosting Brisbane, Suns and Carlton at home we could win all 4 of the games taking it to 13 wins for the season pulling in one or two upsets over the year could leave us with 15-16 wins which could be enough for top 4.
Get around!
lmao @ noz
you just need to worry about next week - at home to GWS will be a harder game than todays
Port favourite for SHOWDOWN :o
Quote from: Doggoneit on March 31, 2013, 04:35:15 PM
lmao @ noz
you just need to worry about next week - at home to GWS will be a harder game than todays
Beating a team by nearly 100 points away from home and their best 22 in. Winning against another wooden spoon favourite at home will be easy
Plus Gray may return and Carlile could as well.
We are not the same team as last year
can there be 2 rising star nominations in the 1 game?
who gets it? i think Viney's first half was better but Wines ran the game out better. probably Wines for me
No point for rd 1. Both will eventually get one...
Viney and Wines will both get a nomination through out the year because the selectors will see them playing consistent footy
Nick Kommer might get it.
Quote from: Noz on March 31, 2013, 05:04:14 PM
Viney and Wines will both get a nomination through out the year because the selectors will see them playing consistent footy
Nick Kommer might get it.
Kommer is a little old ??? 22 and a half?
yeah no doubt they'll both get nominated eventually. wouldn't surprise me if either of them won it.
Quote from: whatlez on March 31, 2013, 05:05:39 PM
Quote from: Noz on March 31, 2013, 05:04:14 PM
Viney and Wines will both get a nomination through out the year because the selectors will see them playing consistent footy
Nick Kommer might get it.
Kommer is a little old ??? 22 and a half?
Oh whoops he is too
Maybe Hoskin-Elliot will get it