Hi all
Another season finished and I'm sure there's a few players who have got admission to your blacklist, so who are they? What players will you never pick again? Any come off the list?
For me Rockliff has gone on, will consider if a foward but. Also Shaw, Mitchell after that 51 which lost me finals and Howard who I got as a smokey and contributed 40 points -.-
Heath Shaw
Greg Broughton (will probs get sucked in again though)
Tom Rock (unless Mid/Fwd)
Quote from: Footy_Boiz on September 04, 2012, 10:23:17 PM
Hi all
Another season finished and I'm sure there's a few players who have got admission to your blacklist, so who are they? What players will you never pick again? Any come off the list?
For me Rockliff has gone on, will consider if a foward but. Also Shaw, Mitchell after that 51 which lost me finals and Howard who I got as a smokey and contributed 40 points -.-
Quote from: Toga on September 04, 2012, 10:24:56 PM
Heath Shaw
Greg Broughton (will probs get sucked in again though)
Tom Rock (unless Mid/Fwd)
i've had Shaw all year and although hes missed a few games he really hasnt been that bad has he??
Rockliff, unless mid/Fwd
Carrazzo! after destroying all my gfs >:(
haha nah proly just Shaw and maybe Broughts
I can't imagine Shaw, Cloke, Martin, Mumford or Robinson returning to my side.
so many youngsters like on the up like, Robbo, Ziebell, Hartlett, Dusty, Conca, Rocky and the likes, all these guys will be fantastic players, look at Waters and guys like Swan, Boyd, Thommo, all took years to become the fantasy players they are.
We might be holding grudges to these younger players but come march 2013 even 2014, will we still be ousting them?
Quote from: tbagrocks on September 04, 2012, 11:02:03 PM
so many youngsters like on the up like, Robbo, Ziebell, Hartlett, Dusty, Conca, Rocky and the likes, all these guys will be fantastic players, look at Waters and guys like Swan, Boyd, Thommo, all took years to become the fantasy players they are.
We might be holding grudges to these younger players but come march 2013 even 2014, will we still be ousting them?
Don't get wrong, Dusty and particularly Robbo were servicable. My concern with Robbo (and the reason I didn't pick him to start with this year) is what's going on between those deformed ears of his. He could have quite easily been suspended a number of times but got lucky and I'm sick of holding my breath every time he lays a bump or tackle.
I certainly won't be starting with them in 2013 but if they prove to be must have upgrades then I'd be silly to ignore them.
Mumford
Goodes (has been a gun - but years have caught up with him in my opinion)
Lake (too inconsistant)
ESKI - scores way to many 50s and 60s for my liking
Will give Martin and Rockliff another chance next year if they are FWDs....
Headache Heath.
Jelwood well won't be picked next year, could be underpriced.
That's about it.
Quote from: Ricochet on September 04, 2012, 10:46:59 PM
Carrazzo! after destroying all my gfs >:(
haha nah proly just Shaw and maybe Broughts
Destroying your grand finals or girl friends ;)
Blacklisting me trading payers who arent out for more than 3 weeks (Ablett, Waters).
Heath Shaw is going to be a no go at the start.
Didnt have a bad year overall so cant complain too much...
Quote from: whatlez on September 04, 2012, 11:19:35 PM
Headache Heath.
Jelwood well won't be picked next year, could be underpriced.
That's about it.
Now that you mention it, J. Selwood wont be starting in my team either, but doesnt really fit the "blacklist" category, just think hes slipping DT wise. Plus he's due to be next years 2012 Tippet and have several concussions...
Quote from: Ricochet on September 04, 2012, 10:46:59 PM
Carrazzo! after destroying all my gfs >:(
haha nah proly just Shaw and maybe Broughts
What girlfriends ;) :P
Quote from: whatlez on September 04, 2012, 11:40:04 PM
Quote from: Ricochet on September 04, 2012, 10:46:59 PM
Carrazzo! after destroying all my gfs >:(
haha nah proly just Shaw and maybe Broughts
What girlfriends ;) :P
all 5 :P
Only one for the blacklist, Broughton. I will also refrain from getting Jelwood and Mitchell.
I think those blacklisting Dusty Martin are crazy - he's a young player who had a plateau in his development. He will go crazy in the next few years.
Heath Shaw...not riding that roller coaster again.
Broughton... Never..... Again....
Shaw, I don't like the idea of him in my team again.... But his price... might be tempting.... NO! SNAP OUT OF IT....... hmm.... maybe... depends on price.... DON'T GET SUCKED IN!!
Robbo is a nut..... think 1 year is enough for me...
That's bout it really..
Broughton and Shaw made my blacklist when he got suspended for betting
Quote from: 13Brummy on September 04, 2012, 11:53:51 PM
Only one for the blacklist, Broughton. I will also refrain from getting Jelwood and Mitchell.
I think those blacklisting Dusty Martin are crazy - he's a young player who had a plateau in his development. He will go crazy in the next few years.
+1 about dusty!
ROCKLIFF - cost me a GF win against Dr Dreamteam
I've had Rocky from the start.
Never again as a pure MID, but will seriously consider if MID/FWD DPP.
Freo players mainly.
I think I'll wait until the season starts(not the NAB Cup) to see if they are playing DT friendly roles before I pick them.And see if they keep getting moved to positions that don't suit them like Broughton this year.
Yeh Heater is gone for me. I want to say Travis Cloke so badly but he's going to be soo cheap next year. But still I don't think I'd be gutsy enough to get him.
Drummond
Broughton
Knights (may have to reconsider if cheap and moves)
Grimes - May have pulled himself off of my list
Adcock
Quote from: DT Gun on September 05, 2012, 08:42:42 PM
Drummond
Broughton
Knights (may have to reconsider if cheap and moves)
Grimes - May have pulled himself off of my list
Adcock
Definitely consider Knights if he goes to the Tiges...should be low 200k!
about 650+ players that will be on lists next year
players around the 30yo mark (Goodes)
Taggers (Lewis)
Injury prones (Missy Higgins)
Brain Farters (Heater)
Fringe Players
Quote from: Adamant on September 05, 2012, 08:58:17 PM
Quote from: DT Gun on September 05, 2012, 08:42:42 PM
Drummond
Broughton
Knights (may have to reconsider if cheap and moves)
Grimes - May have pulled himself off of my list
Adcock
Definitely consider Knights if he goes to the Tiges...should be low 200k!
he use to be an 80+ player hey?
Shaw, Robinson and Goodes.
Quote from: Hagebear on September 05, 2012, 08:09:31 PM
Yeh Heater is gone for me. I want to say Travis Cloke so badly but he's going to be soo cheap next year. But still I don't think I'd be gutsy enough to get him.
I was thinking about Travvy... If he is cheap enough surely he'd be worth a look? Could end up as a F8 and given he should r so cheap surely it wouldn't hurt....?
Quote from: Adamant on September 05, 2012, 08:58:17 PM
Quote from: DT Gun on September 05, 2012, 08:42:42 PM
Drummond
Broughton
Knights (may have to reconsider if cheap and moves)
Grimes - May have pulled himself off of my list
Adcock
Definitely consider Knights if he goes to the Tiges...should be low 200k!
+1 hed be a bargain! Unless he becomes the super sub or something... :'(
ALL freo defenders
seriously, Broughton and MJ have turned me right off
Quote from: pommyadam on September 07, 2012, 04:56:59 PM
ALL freo defenders
seriously, Broughton and MJ have turned me right off
Duffield?
No-one!!
Everyone deserves a second chance! (or tenth in Heath Shaw's case :P)