Poll
Question:
mummy-->sandlands a good trade?
Option 1: yes
votes: 27
Option 2: no
votes: 9
Mummy not being named is getting me a donut
i have 23 trades remaining
i am going for league
should i trade mumford to sandi?
Yes.
2 weeks now he's gone down with "back soreness". It seems like something that will trouble him all year and he'll miss many more weeks due to this. Get rid of him for Sandi while you can.
Cheers ESTAR
would you do mummy to sandi above fyfe to sidebum & shaw to carrazz? Or would you do 2?
im going mummy --> sandi (as i should have done preseason...polls can lie)
Quote from: Jayman on April 20, 2012, 06:46:22 PM
Cheers ESTAR
would you do mummy to sandi above fyfe to sidebum & shaw to carrazz? Or would you do 2?
I personally wouldn't be trading Fyfe, and I would only trade Shaw if you were facing a 0 this week (which I am, so I had to trade him).
Back soreness can lead to pretty serious complications in a big fella like Mummy so I would be getting rid of him as soon as you can. Shaw should be back after ANZAC Day, and while keeping Fyfe is a risk you have to save as many trades as you can this early. If Fyfe is playing, then he stays.
well looks like mummy/fyfe out 4 me n sandilands/sidebottom in do we think dis is a good choice
Mummy out - sick of these injuries that come and go. Sandi in.
Keeping Fyfe but have moved him to my mids where I have better emergencies... just in case :)
This is one of those sideways trades that has to be done.
I am usually against sideways trades with prems but mummy looks to be shot. Back soreness does not go away over night, he has been struggling with it for 3 weeks.
Sandi looks to be back to his best as well, 54 hit outs 2 weeks in a row, who does that? Guy is a genetic freak.
Great Trade. Sandi has been in superb form. :)
Sandi be anyone?????
97
Not making new thread.
Mummy Out.
Swap Hale Into Ruck.
Chad C In + ~200k.
Sandi will be an upgrade target regardless. Thoughts?
Sandi BE 110
Is anyone considering Ryder and pocketing $80k?
Quote from: foolysik on April 20, 2012, 07:10:46 PM
Sandi BE 110
Is anyone considering Ryder and pocketing $80k?
considering kruezer and pocketing 170k
Quote from: foolysik on April 20, 2012, 07:10:46 PM
Sandi BE 110
Is anyone considering Ryder and pocketing $80k?
His B/E is 97.
He will have that score at 1/4 time against McEvoy.
Quote from: FonFatty on April 20, 2012, 07:12:12 PM
Quote from: foolysik on April 20, 2012, 07:10:46 PM
Sandi BE 110
Is anyone considering Ryder and pocketing $80k?
His B/E is 97.
He will have that score at 1/4 time against McEvoy.
where did you get b/e of sandilands is 97... fanfooty says 110...
I'm on YSCC and it says BE 110 :(
Quote from: foolysik on April 20, 2012, 07:10:46 PM
Sandi BE 110
Is anyone considering Ryder and pocketing $80k?
Yes I am but cannot decide. Ryder is young and with Hille gone for a while should go okay.
But Sandi is a proven gun and providing he can stay injury free will continue.
Tough call although I am leaning towards Sandi unless anyone can change my mind.
Quote from: The Bomber on April 20, 2012, 07:13:40 PM
Quote from: FonFatty on April 20, 2012, 07:12:12 PM
Quote from: foolysik on April 20, 2012, 07:10:46 PM
Sandi BE 110
Is anyone considering Ryder and pocketing $80k?
His B/E is 97.
He will have that score at 1/4 time against McEvoy.
where did you get b/e of sandilands is 97... fanfooty says 110...
Supercoach GOLD.
Get a refund?
in all fairness he should get both of those b/e...interesting to see if he gets like 105...
Quote from: foolysik on April 20, 2012, 07:17:08 PM
Get a refund?
I would take Supercoach GOLD's word for it. The 110 B/E posted by YSCC and Fanfooty would be of the mark.
You sure you boys aren't getting confused with his score last week? He scored 110 last week
Can see fanfooty has 110 as well. Out of interest - Mummys BE says 169 - what does GOLD say?
Glad I did Mummy -> Sandi before last week, considering this week. Now all I need is for Dempsey to pull out at the last minute!
still can't decide between sandi/ryder or nic nat.. leaning towards sandles
Quote from: foolysik on April 20, 2012, 07:28:11 PM
Can see fanfooty has 110 as well. Out of interest - Mummys BE says 169 - what does GOLD say?
B/E is 156
get sandi...hoping he is a better set and forget