Always get a kick out of seeing people knee jerk with the trades the day after lockout.
Watch this space in days to come. I'll keep updating.
Top 10 Most Popular Trade Out Combos:
1 Bugg, T Lake, B 955 (1%)
2 Kennedy, A Folau, I 778 (1%)
3 Kennedy, A Pfeiffer, D 726 (1%)
4 Kennedy, A Saad, A 536 (1%)
5 Hargrave, R Lake, B 430 (1%)
6 Kennedy, A Weedon, G 403 (1%)
7 Mohr, T Lake, B 400 (1%)
8 Kennedy, A Cameron, J 396 (1%)
9 Kennedy, A Zorko, D 344 (0%)
10 Kennedy, A Byrnes, S 325 (0%)
Top 10 Traded OUT Players:
1 Lake, B 4.42%
2 Pfeiffer, D 1.65%
3 Folau, I 1.43%
4 Saad, A 1.08%
5 Scarlett, M 1.03%
6 Shiel, D 1.00%
7 Winderlich, J 0.94%
8 Byrnes, S 0.90%
9 Coniglio, S 0.86%
10 Varcoe, T 0.82%
Top 10 Most Traded IN Players:
1 Kennedy, A 20.33%
2 Bugg, T 11.21%
3 Magner, J 5.22%
4 Mohr, T 2.49%
5 Smith, C 2.20%
6 Callinan, I 2.08%
7 Fyfe, N 1.91%
8 Adcock, J 1.89%
9 Ebert, B 1.75%
10 Hampton, C 1.46%
Unbelievable isn't it!!
ahhh i cant believe that used to be me.....
my mate did Hale > Tippett
silliest thing ever.
A few people want Kennedy then?
can't trades be reversed prior to lock out this year... meaning... trade away!
how did you find those statistics windigo?
thats pretty awesome great work ;)
resist the urge to trade
last year was my 1st year had no trades left to cover injuries at the end of season wont do that again
Quote from: glam77 on April 02, 2012, 09:49:45 AM
can't trades be reversed prior to lock out this year... meaning... trade away!
But still. ::)
Quote from: Windigo on April 02, 2012, 10:06:24 AM
Quote from: glam77 on April 02, 2012, 09:49:45 AM
can't trades be reversed prior to lock out this year... meaning... trade away!
But still. ::)
yeah the thing i'm not sure on is u can undo and pick another player but can u actually undo and keep your trade instead?
Quote from: essendon2 on April 02, 2012, 09:47:52 AM
my mate did Hale > Tippett
silliest thing ever.
hahaha
Quote from: glam77 on April 02, 2012, 09:49:45 AM
can't trades be reversed prior to lock out this year... meaning... trade away!
They can and if you ask me, this option sucks. It takes away the educated decision making and planning that makes DT so consuming and ends up making teams all the same. People will trade out Monday and not learn the hard way; hear a rumour or Thursday night teams won't have their traded player named and they'll just reverse their Monday trade and copy everyone else. It's a poor addition to the rules.
Quote from: esquire on April 02, 2012, 10:13:39 AM
Quote from: glam77 on April 02, 2012, 09:49:45 AM
can't trades be reversed prior to lock out this year... meaning... trade away!
They can and if you ask me, this option sucks. It takes away the educated decision making and planning that makes DT so consuming and ends up making teams all the same. People will trade out Monday and not learn the hard way; hear a rumour or Thursday night teams won't have their traded player named and they'll just reverse their Monday trade and copy everyone else. It's a poor addition to the rules.
They have to accomodate the common man, not the legends that we are.
Quote from: bomberboy0618 on April 02, 2012, 10:15:48 AM
Quote from: esquire on April 02, 2012, 10:13:39 AM
Quote from: glam77 on April 02, 2012, 09:49:45 AM
can't trades be reversed prior to lock out this year... meaning... trade away!
They can and if you ask me, this option sucks. It takes away the educated decision making and planning that makes DT so consuming and ends up making teams all the same. People will trade out Monday and not learn the hard way; hear a rumour or Thursday night teams won't have their traded player named and they'll just reverse their Monday trade and copy everyone else. It's a poor addition to the rules.
They have to accomodate the common man, not the legends that we are.
+1 ;)
definitely takes the advantage away. I used to get a huge advantage over some of my friends by simply waiting to friday to make my trades, whereas they did theirs monday mornings...... now they can get away with it !!!
Kids these days....
Quote from: essendon2 on April 02, 2012, 09:47:52 AM
my mate did Hale > Tippett
silliest thing ever.
mate its crazy time of year. that is a silly trade. thank god we have reversable trades!!
mind you tippet and the crows do look good and have a favourable draw
Pretty sure what you've listed is the Top 10 most popular trade INs?
It's listing the players who are traded in not the most commonly traded out? ???
I always thought that you could reverse your trade, but if you wanted to trade again, that guy you reversed would be your only option...
Quote from: Nails on April 02, 2012, 11:54:41 AM
Pretty sure what you've listed is the Top 10 most popular trade INs?
It's listing the players who are traded in not the most commonly traded out? ???
Yeah, the most popular trade combo's.
Lake>Bugg is the most commonly used trade the past 24 hours or so.
those poor people who traded out zorko will trade him back in in 1? 2? 3? rounds max ;D
All updates are on my first post. ;)
Top 10 Traded OUT Players:
1 Lake, B 4.69%
2 Pfeiffer, D 1.71%
3 Folau, I 1.59%
4 Shiel, D 1.18%
5 Saad, A 1.06%
6 Broughton, G 0.99%
7 Coniglio, S 0.97%
8 Porplyzia, J 0.90%
9 Shaw, H 0.89%
10 Winderlich, J 0.89%
wow really????
Yep. 8)
Look at all these kids panicking...
lol @ ppl already sideways trading premos
WTF Coniglio wow. Who would consider trading out Coniglio after one round? crazy. He will probably smash out an 80 this week and punish these fools.
Quote from: Kuruki on April 02, 2012, 03:05:34 PM
WTF Coniglio wow. Who would consider trading out Coniglio after one round? crazy. He will probably smash out an 80 this week and punish these fools.
i hope he does smash it this week he looked the goods i can`t believe people traded him out bloody noobs
how can people be so stupid to criticize the reversible trades, you make a trade only to have the player get injured or be pulled out at the last minute, you can also make trades and see how they make your team look without having to make a final decisions, there isnt any skill involved in waiting till friday to make trades
its times like these that i wish that the Heath Shaw button wasnt there. Serves these guys right for trading already
Vote 1 remove the Heath Shaw button
Quote from: Kuruki on April 02, 2012, 03:05:34 PM
WTF Coniglio wow. Who would consider trading out Coniglio after one round? crazy. He will probably smash out an 80 this week and punish these fools.
I was watching the game on ground, and the poor kid went down 3 times with various tweaks... would have scored a lot higher if it wasnt for them...
Updated again. People actually have Scarlett!? :o
Top 10 Most Traded IN Players:
1 Kennedy, A 20.19%
2 Bugg, T 11.30%
3 Magner, J 5.47%
4 Mohr, T 2.48%
5 Adcock, J 2.10%
6 Smith, C 2.08%
7 Callinan, I 2.02%
8 Fyfe, N 2.02%
9 Ebert, B 1.74%
10 Tippett, K 1.40%
this is ridiculous
Yeah, I know. It goes to show just how many take DT seriously.
if there is something to dog about, rest assured someone will dog about it.
does it really matter if you can reverse trades? i kind of like the idea of being able to tinker with trades and testing the structure of my team and undoing it when if i don't like the way it turned out. i think the reversible trades are more for that reason than letting the monday traders off the hook.
Wow, Coniglio and Shiel top ten traded out ::)
Quote from: maccar86 on April 02, 2012, 08:03:06 PM
if there is something to dog about, rest assured someone will dog about it.
does it really matter if you can reverse trades? i kind of like the idea of being able to tinker with trades and testing the structure of my team and undoing it when if i don't like the way it turned out. i think the reversible trades are more for that reason than letting the monday traders off the hook.
+1
The main ppl that trade early I would think are those newer to the game. Is it really such a bad thing to let them play with their team during the week before making a decision? I think not
I think most of the complainers are just ppl that have burnt themselves by trading to early in the past and get a kick out of watching others perform similar mistakes
Quote from: Ajax22 on April 03, 2012, 07:44:19 AM
Quote from: maccar86 on April 02, 2012, 08:03:06 PM
if there is something to dog about, rest assured someone will dog about it.
does it really matter if you can reverse trades? i kind of like the idea of being able to tinker with trades and testing the structure of my team and undoing it when if i don't like the way it turned out. i think the reversible trades are more for that reason than letting the monday traders off the hook.
+1
The main ppl that trade early I would think are those newer to the game. Is it really such a bad thing to let them play with their team during the week before making a decision? I think not
I think most of the complainers are just ppl that have burnt themselves by trading to early in the past and get a kick out of watching others perform similar mistakes
+1
reversable trades before lockout make sense more realistic no complaints there. Players can be subbed and shifted and captain changed, emergencies set and changed so why not trades also.
The main reason for it IMO is the Heater inncident :o showers and giggles that was, if you want to hear other fantasy coached screaming you wanted to be around that Friday afternoon ;D
However most of the trades shown to have happened so far on these lists won't be reversed unless players not playing or injured these seem like standard trades for round one every season.
IMO should wait until round 2 90% of them but there are always a lot of trigger fingers after round 1.
Wait until round 2 then it really gets interesting looking at the trades going on.
Shiel is going to kill you for trading him out.
I reckon Lake to Bugg is a really good trade - I didn't start off with Lake but the coaches who did it'll free up 150k and be really helpful down the track
Quote from: essendon2 on April 03, 2012, 10:44:19 AM
I reckon Lake to Bugg is a really good trade - I didn't start off with Lake but the coaches who did it'll free up 150k and be really helpful down the track
+1
Bugg will average more than Lake by season's end and he'll do it for 150K less.
I'm not a 1st round trader but I support trading out Lake 1st round, he's just such a stupid selection in the first place people should get rid of him A.S.A.P.
I agree with most of those top 10 traded out players, except for those of Shiel and Coniglio. They were playing against the Swans, who are pretty hard to rack the dt points up against. Expect them to bust out a 90 this week and show all those who traded them out.
Surprised Shaw isn't in there but Broughton is.
We are still seeing mass exodus from the Lake Bandwagon.
Surprisingly, Travis Varcoe has snuck into the top 12 trade outs... :P
The only things stopping me from McDonald to Clay Smith is I wanna have the loophole this week with Marc Murphy and I don't like knee-jerk trades so I wanna see Smith prove himself again.
Quote from: Windigo on April 02, 2012, 09:37:53 AM
Always get a kick out of seeing people knee jerk with the trades the day after lockout.
Watch this space in days to come. I'll keep updating.
Top 10 Most Popular Trade Out Combos:
1 Bugg, T Lake, B 752 (1%)
2 Kennedy, A Folau, I 617 (1%)
3 Kennedy, A Pfeiffer, D 557 (1%)
4 Kennedy, A Saad, A 422 (1%)
5 Hargrave, R Lake, B 341 (1%)
6 Kennedy, A Cameron, J 326 (1%)
7 Mohr, T Lake, B 318 (1%)
8 Kennedy, A Weedon, G 313 (1%)
9 Kennedy, A Zorko, D 278 (0%)
10 Kennedy, A Byrnes, S 251 (0%
Top 10 Traded OUT Players:
1 Lake, B 4.50%
2 Pfeiffer, D 1.63%
3 Folau, I 1.46%
4 Saad, A 1.08%
5 Scarlett, M 0.99%
6 Shiel, D 0.99%
7 Winderlich, J 0.92%
8 Coniglio, S 0.89%
9 Byrnes, S 0.88%
10 Varcoe, T 0.80%
Top 10 Most Traded IN Players:
1 Kennedy, A 20.34%
2 Bugg, T 11.25%
3 Magner, J 5.34%
4 Mohr, T 2.47%
5 Smith, C 2.08%
6 Callinan, I 2.03%
7 Fyfe, N 1.93%
8 Adcock, J 1.92%
9 Ebert, B 1.74%
10 Hampton, C 1.45%
It's annoying that out of top 10 TRADED IN players I have 5.....Or maybe that's a good thing. I have NO IDEA why people would trade Winderlich out when he'll play round 2 almost guaranteed. if you don't want him you shouldn't have put him in your team at the start.
Shiel will gun it this week - only gave him the vest because he was coming back from injury and didn't have the match fitness.
I wonder if you can refine the stats to show the top 10 trades from the top 5000 or so teams? That would filter out a lot of the silly trades.
Quote from: Cayenne on April 03, 2012, 02:22:57 PM
Shiel will gun it this week - only gave him the vest because he was coming back from injury and didn't have the match fitness.
I wonder if you can refine the stats to show the top 10 trades from the top 5000 or so teams? That would filter out a lot of the silly trades.
The top 5000 are the top 5000 because they don't do stupid trades after Rd1.
There shouldn't really be any talk of trades unless one of your players are injured, i mean really, you should've done the research and picked up the rookies that will scors well and will play, if you didn't then your not gonna finish well whether you trade or not.
Quote from: Madsnake on April 03, 2012, 02:36:23 PM
Quote from: Cayenne on April 03, 2012, 02:22:57 PM
Shiel will gun it this week - only gave him the vest because he was coming back from injury and didn't have the match fitness.
I wonder if you can refine the stats to show the top 10 trades from the top 5000 or so teams? That would filter out a lot of the silly trades.
The top 5000 are the top 5000 because they don't do stupid trades after Rd1.
There shouldn't really be any talk of trades unless one of your players are injured, i mean really, you should've done the research and picked up the rookies that will scors well and will play, if you didn't then your not gonna finish well whether you trade or not.
Big +1. Congrats on being 36th too mate!
Quote from: elephants on April 03, 2012, 02:46:52 PM
Quote from: Madsnake on April 03, 2012, 02:36:23 PM
Quote from: Cayenne on April 03, 2012, 02:22:57 PM
Shiel will gun it this week - only gave him the vest because he was coming back from injury and didn't have the match fitness.
I wonder if you can refine the stats to show the top 10 trades from the top 5000 or so teams? That would filter out a lot of the silly trades.
The top 5000 are the top 5000 because they don't do stupid trades after Rd1.
There shouldn't really be any talk of trades unless one of your players are injured, i mean really, you should've done the research and picked up the rookies that will scors well and will play, if you didn't then your not gonna finish well whether you trade or not.
Big +1. Congrats on being 36th too mate!
Thanks man ;D
trigger happy... rediculous
just my 2 cents worth......... CAVEAT EMPTOR............... let the buyer beware. i'd laugh if lakey was to rip ou a 90 next
week. can't understand for the life of me why people spend 4-6 weeks analysing players to put together a team and then
after 1 bad game, to want to trade a player out. tough tiitties i say
were did you get this info windi?
Quote from: underdog11 on April 03, 2012, 11:13:58 PM
were did you get this info windi?
+1 to you underdog didnt even know this thread exsisted :o till it came to the top :P
+1 for the info 2, but y trade out congilio the knobs?
Quote from: elephants on April 03, 2012, 01:14:57 PM
The only things stopping me from McDonald to Clay Smith is I wanna have the loophole this week with Marc Murphy and I don't like knee-jerk trades so I wanna see Smith prove himself again.
+1
Quote from: essendon2 on April 03, 2012, 11:25:06 PM
Quote from: elephants on April 03, 2012, 01:14:57 PM
The only things stopping me from McDonald to Clay Smith is I wanna have the loophole this week with Marc Murphy and I don't like knee-jerk trades so I wanna see Smith prove himself again.
+1
yep give him another week so he can actually prove himself. how many rookies have we seen kill it 1st game and becomes a person working in the mines the rest of the season (bad i know i.e goes underground)
Quote from: underdog11 on April 03, 2012, 11:13:58 PM
were did you get this info windi?
its one of the features with the assistant coach service you can pay $20 for , it shows the trades info, % price changes, projected scores etc..
Quote from: Macquarie on April 04, 2012, 12:13:05 AM
Quote from: underdog11 on April 03, 2012, 11:13:58 PM
were did you get this info windi?
its one of the features with the assistant coach service you can pay $20 for , it shows the trades info, % price changes, projected scores etc..
Yeah, what he said. ;)
Quote3 Folau, I 1.43%[/q
Please explain :P
Haha, you'd be surprised how many people have him.