Poll
Question:
Selwood or Swan
Option 1: Swan
Option 2: Selwood
Recent events or making me think twice about picking Dane Swan. He has looked a little under done in the NAB Cup and his comments in the papers speak for themselves. Thus I am thinking about trading him for Joel Selwood. Thoughts?
What comments, do you have a link, I missed those comments, wouldnt mind reading them...
I find Dane Swan to be a half assed in his approach to comments to the media, I wouldn't read too much into it.
He's a proven gun, and I think he is slightly under priced.
I'd be making room for both mate!
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/collingwood-star-dane-swan-sets-2014-as-his-retirement-date/story-e6frf9jf-1226278748909
It seems like he is thinking bout retirement already. He just seems like he doesn't care this season. I already have GAJ, Thompson and Gibbs as my premiums. So it's between Selwood and Swan for my Other premium.
Yeah, I reckon thats the way he approaches the media...I wouldnt read into it..
Selwood and Swan... I'd go Swan - just.
Farking hell, Swan by a mile. Why does everybody hate on Swanny this season? Has been the best dt'er for the last few years and will continue that reign.
To me that article says he doesnt want to one of those players like James McDonald desperate to hang on to there footy
if you do trade him dont get selwood.
Quote from: its me lads on March 08, 2012, 08:09:17 PM
if you do trade him dont get selwood.
+1. I currently have both.
Only players I'd oust Swan for are; GAJ, Rockliff, Pendles or Boyd.
Probaly swan (He just doesnt care about NAB cup)
but i reckon selwood is a little underpriced and going into season as captain he'll improve for sure
Swan is a DTer god id pay 700k thats how underpriced he is.