Im going to start this thread where you post your rookies in each line
then we can see which rookies ar the most popular and most likely to do well
My rookies atm are
DEF: S. Docherty, M. Talia, J. Lockyer, M. Buntine
MID: C. Wingard, M. Grigg, D. Shiel
RUCK: J. Hamling, S. Rowe
FWD: N. Haynes, A. Saad, I. Folau(not really a rookie but), M. Panos
Cheers if u can reply
Back - Clarke, Bower, Ellis,
Mid - Docherty, Pfeiffer, Shiel, Miles, Clifton, McDonald
Ruck - Giles, Stephenson,
Fwd - Zorko, Treloar
Quote from: Ago97 on January 18, 2012, 01:11:03 PM
Im going to start this thread where you post your rookies in each line
then we can see which rookies ar the most popular and most likely to do well
My rookies atm are
DEF: S. Docherty, M. Talia, J. Lockyer, M. Buntine
MID: C. Wingard, M. Grigg, D. Shiel
RUCK: J. Hamling, S. Rowe
FWD: N. Haynes, A. Saad, I. Folau(not really a rookie but), M. Panos
Cheers if u can reply
Joel Hamling won't play this year. Folau IMO will struggle a lot, and much better rookies to pick from than Panos, Lockyer and Haynes won't play much as well IMO
Quote from: Ago97 on January 18, 2012, 01:11:03 PM
Im going to start this thread where you post your rookies in each line
then we can see which rookies ar the most popular and most likely to do well
My rookies atm are
DEF: S. Docherty, M. Talia, J. Lockyer, M. Buntine
MID: C. Wingard, M. Grigg, D. Shiel
RUCK: J. Hamling, S. Rowe
FWD: N. Haynes, A. Saad, I. Folau(not really a rookie but), M. Panos
Cheers if u can reply
I wouldve thought Giles and Stephenson would be much better ruck rookies. You look to have a fair few unique rookies in your line up. But seriously this doesn't even matter until NAB cup.
I'll post mine after nab cup, but guarantee they wont look anything like yours m8 :P
Mine are...
DEF: T. Mohr, B. Smedts, T. Bugg
MID: S. Clifton, K. Horsely, J. McDonald/T. Mitchell, D. Shiel
RUCK: J. Giles and O. Stephenson
FWD: T. Walsh, A. Saad, D. Zorko, A. Treloar
Can't decide between the bolded pair?
Quote from: elephants on January 18, 2012, 02:06:31 PM
Mine are...
DEF: T. Mohr, B. Smedts, T. Bugg
MID: S. Clifton, K. Horsely, J. McDonald/T. Mitchell, D. Shiel
RUCK: J. Giles and O. Stephenson
FWD: T. Walsh, A. Saad, D. Zorko, A. Treloar
Can't decide between the bolded pair?
I would think pick mcdonald gws need his strong body to protect the youngsters and it wouldnt make sense to recruit a 35yr old and have him sit on the sidelines
Quote from: elephants on January 18, 2012, 02:06:31 PM
Mine are...
DEF: T. Mohr, B. Smedts, T. Bugg
MID: S. Clifton, K. Horsely, J. McDonald/T. Mitchell, D. Shiel
RUCK: J. Giles and O. Stephenson
FWD: T. Walsh, A. Saad, D. Zorko, A. Treloar
Can't decide between the bolded pair?
same mate, that's tough one. Depends who gets a game straight away, If mitchell doesn't get a go straight away then it'll be an easy choice. :)
Cool cheers lads.
Def: Ellis. Mohr. Smedts. Brown
Mid: coniglio. Wingard. Shiel. Wingard( will change if he doesn't get elevated)
Rucks. Stephenson. Giles. Rowe.
Fwd. Walsh. Zorko. Crozier
Thoughts?
Backs - M.Clarke, B.Ellis, W.Sierakowski, B.Smedts
Mids - A.Miles, D.Zorko, L.Brown, T.Mitchell
Rucks - J.Giles, O.Stephenson
Fwds - A.Saad, A.Treloar, M.Panos, T.Walsh
any thoughts on this lot , obviously nab cup will tell a lot but still happy to hear comments on these guys , will lee get games
DEF M. Clarke, S. Morris (B. Wilkes, J. Tynan)
MID: K. Stevens (D. Zorko, B. Lee)
RUC: (J. Giles, O. Stephenson)
FWD: A. Saad, T. Walsh (A. Treloar, M. Panos)
M.Clarke, Ellis (Morris, Brown)
Horsley, Shiel (Mcdonald, Stevens)
Treloar, Zorko (Smedts, Walsh)
Not bothered with DPP at the start of the season will look into it more when im downgrading before the byes.
DEF: M. Clarke, L. Spurr, W. Sierakowski, S. Morris
MID: K. Stevens, S. Clifton, K. Horsely, S. Reid
RUC: J. Giles, O. Stephenson
FWD: B. Smedts, A. Hall, T. Dickson
DEF: M.Clarke, Morris, Ellis, Wilkes, Brown
MID: McDonald, Shiels, Clifton, Pfeiffer
FWD: Zorko, Treloar, Hampton, Saad
Quote from: theflyinghawk on January 18, 2012, 06:21:06 PM
M.Clarke, Ellis (Morris, Brown)
Horsley, Shiel (Mcdonald, Stevens)
Treloar, Zorko (Smedts, Walsh)
Not bothered with DPP at the start of the season will look into it more when im downgrading before the byes.
I like this one. I don't have Horsley or Walsh.
Clarke, Ellis, Bugg, Brown/Spurr??
J.polec, c.Smith, shiel, pfieffer
giles, stephenson
Treloar, zorko, kerridge, smedts
Quote from: miffysp on January 18, 2012, 03:25:23 PM
Def: Ellis. Mohr. Smedts. Brown
Mid: coniglio. Wingard. Shiel. Wingard( will change if he doesn't get elevated)
Rucks. Stephenson. Giles. Rowe.
Fwd. Walsh. Zorko. Crozier
Thoughts?
Two Wingards. Sweet. I assume you mean Horsely :P
firstly can i say there are some absolute ripping rooks on teams rookie lists so if they were elevated this might read differently.
DEF: Clarke(not a rook but taking one of the spots), Mohr, Ellis, Wilkes
MID: Clifton,Shiel,Zorko,Mcdonald(not a rook but taking one of the spots)
RUCK: Giles,Stephensen.
FWD: Saad,Smedts,Treloar,Cameron.
Subject to change eradically sporadically and without any notice at all. :)