Hey guys if anyone has any question at all regarding supercoach i am here to give my opinion. :)
post in here and ill answer.
Bryce Gibbs or Heath Shaw? Just not sure about gibbs due to bye in RND24. But is heath shaw fit? Got a better option than these 2?
boyd or bartel??
Ryder or Cox?
pendles or m.murphy?
montagna or cross?
gibbs>shaw
cox>ryder
pendles>murphy
montagna>cross
my opinions seeing as though we arent getting any answers lol.
I think your on the money with all those picks. Cox did look good last week and by all reports is fitter than he has ever been but they always say that.
yeah hes worth the punt m going with him.
Quote from: MightyLions on February 19, 2011, 02:01:42 PM
Bryce Gibbs or Heath Shaw? Just not sure about gibbs due to bye in RND24. But is heath shaw fit? Got a better option than these 2?
Mate im pretty sure heath sahw is fit and well, he scored a 150 in one of his NAB cup matches. certainly not a bad option although you dont want to many pies. Go with Gibbs :) he is a lock whether they have a bye in round 24 or not.
Quote from: magpies11 on February 19, 2011, 02:02:26 PM
boyd or bartel??
Boyd just. Only reason is Bartels interrupted preseason.
Quote from: Mozza3 on February 19, 2011, 02:16:47 PM
Ryder or Cox?
Its a tough decision. Cox is getting on and Im not sure whether his body will hold up. Go for Ryder. Will be a the key to the dons.
Quote from: steven_ora on February 19, 2011, 02:20:02 PM
pendles or m.murphy?
montagna or cross?
Pendles will be better. all depends if you want swan.
Montagna over cross for me. pulls out big scores and think he is more suited to SC than cross.
Thanks Maca 24, I think that decision will haunt me till lockout.
Quote from: Mozza3 on February 19, 2011, 02:46:29 PM
Thanks Maca 24, I think that decision will haunt me till lockout.
yeh no worries. you could go either way really.
my advice just keep watching them closely.
any news (eg. slight injuries, porr form or good form, really fit.) could make the decision for you
whats your thoughts on gamble and krakouer
Quote from: dylsta05 on February 19, 2011, 02:54:06 PM
whats your thoughts on gamble and krakouer
Gamble had a great night last night. Could be a good pick but im not sold just yet. Will be interesting to see how he goes sharing the forward line with Roo and kosi.
Krakouer has been burning the track up apparently. So watch out for him.
Foley vs Martin vs Scully, who should I choose??
Quote from: WatsamataU on February 19, 2011, 03:00:26 PM
Foley vs Martin vs Scully, who should I choose??
Definetly Foley as you should avoid second year players. (Scully and Martin)
Quote from: WatsamataU on February 19, 2011, 03:00:26 PM
Foley vs Martin vs Scully, who should I choose??
Yea defs Foley. Scully and martin aren't going to become premiums in their second year.
IMO none of them but foley if any.
BUT MARTIN IS JET!!!!
Yeh true that
murphy vs priddis vs watson.
4th premium mid (boyd, bartel etc..) and knights up fwd
OR
4th premium fwd( green or goodes? with rioli as 5th fwd) and anthony in mids????
Wondering who i should get, i have jselwood, m muphy and swan and mcglynn atm with 36k left in salary should i upgrade any, if so who to?
Quote from: ando_10 on February 19, 2011, 03:48:40 PM
murphy vs priddis vs watson.
This may surprise you, but i think watson.
Looks like he has had a great preseason and should get some more support this year. Watson > murphy > priddis
Quote from: magpies11 on February 19, 2011, 03:58:43 PM
4th premium mid (boyd, bartel etc..) and knights up fwd
OR
4th premium fwd( green or goodes? with rioli as 5th fwd) and anthony in mids????
im not sure what you mean. maybe post your full mids and forwards. :)
Quote from: littleblueboy2906 on February 19, 2011, 04:21:29 PM
Wondering who i should get, i have jselwood, m muphy and swan and mcglynn atm with 36k left in salary should i upgrade any, if so who to?
if mcglynn is in your mids, get him out. there are far better options for that price. If you want a swan, try Kieran Jack as a smokie.
andrew swallow or jobe watson thoughts? (despite the fact jobe misses grand final week) or spend the xtra cash and go for a montagna or cross?
Swan, judd, montagna and anthony with a green or goodes as a 4th mid and rioli as 5th
or
swan, judd, montagna and another premium with rioli as a 4th mid and knights as a 5th?
Quote from: cich_189 on February 20, 2011, 01:46:12 AM
andrew swallow or jobe watson thoughts? (despite the fact jobe misses grand final week) or spend the xtra cash and go for a montagna or cross?
I really like them both. think you could go either way.
Save your cash and pick one of them. the decision is yours ;)
Quote from: magpies11 on February 20, 2011, 02:51:05 AM
Swan, judd, montagna and anthony with a green or goodes as a 4th mid and rioli as 5th
or
swan, judd, montagna and another premium with rioli as a 4th mid and knights as a 5th?
Option 1, cas a mid premium is better than a forward prem.
also i prefer knights over anthony. think with your mids you have2 stay away from mid pricers.
bump. anyone else?
im open to answering anything.
1. Goddard, B
$633,700
2. Lake, B
$508,700
3. Deledio, B
$495,900
4. Grundy, H
$434,600
5. Harbrow, J
$415,900
6. Otten, A
$185,100
7. Heppell, D
$153,600
23. Puopolo, P
$103,600
24. Hibberd, M
$103,600
25. Duigan, N
$103,600
8. Swan, D
$617,300
9. Montagna, L
$558,700
10. Gibbs, B
$508,300
11. Pavlich, M
12. Swallow, D
$188,600
13. Gaff, A
$173,600
26. Conca, R
$163,600
27. Harris, D
$125,700
28. Callinan, I
$91,700
14. Sandilands, A
$554,700
15. Petrie, D
$216,000
29. Smith, Z
$117,700
30. Bailey, M
$110,200
16. Chapman, P
$566,500
17. Riewoldt, N
$529,900
18. Goodes, A
$458,900
19. Riewoldt, J
$449,400
20. Krakouer, A
$200,600
21. Gamble, R
$184,900
22. Prestia, D
$148,600
31. Richardson, C
$110,200
32. Mzungu, T
$110,200
33. Smith, I
$103,600
Hi there i know that this is not rate my super coach catergory but i would appreciate your input maca ...... Cheers in advance.
Nice unique backs. I like harbrow but Lake hasnt had a preseason so you should probably stay away..
Conca on the bench is no good, you gotta have cheaper blokes on the pine... Pavlich should be in your forwards.
Forwards look alrite, but a tad weak.
Im off the Prestia bandwagon but its up to you.
Overall good team :)