R12 bye:
Richmond
North
Geelong
West Coast
Bye free:
Melbourne
Sydney
St Kilda
Brisbane
Carlton
Western Bulldogs
Port
Gold Coast
Bubble:
Scharenberg (13)
Cousins (13)
Willsmore (13)
Brodie (9)
Early:
Ryan (13)
Dawson? (11)
English (11)
Otten > Docherty
SPP > Cousins
Fyfe > Rocky
Myers > Cousins
Caddy > Lynch
Only two trades this week.
Have 20 playing this week with Williamson and Powell-Pepper having the lowest averages. (Housten and Balic probably won't be named but if they are I'll have 21/22)
Next week however I am flowered and as it is all premiums (apart from Greenwood, Balic and Cousins) that have the bye there's not much I can do about it.
parsons>brown
pickett>ryan
stewart>hibberd
Keeping it simple for now
Tuohey > Docherty
Newmans > Hibberd
Not sure if I like any of the downgrade options. Will diagnose them during the week. Taranto is just about ready to cull though. He's been a good servant.
Is Mummy the best pick to replace Sandi? Already have Stef, dont want Nank in the ruck.
Otten > Scharenberg
Myers > Cousins
WHE > Lynch
Need to cull some rd 13 bye rookies or I'm stuffed next week
Parsons to Cousins
Otten to Hibberd
McInness to JJ
Should give me 22 this week.
Would have 18 before trades for next week. 15 of which are keepers which I think would put me at an advantage over most.
Quote from: quinny88 on June 04, 2017, 11:06:47 PM
Otten > Scharenberg
Myers > Cousins
WHE > Lynch
Need to cull some rd 13 bye rookies or I'm stuffed next week
He says, as he trades in two R13 bye rookies :P
Sandi > Wallis
Parsons gets downgraded if numbers get dicey.
Quote from: john23132 on June 04, 2017, 11:04:21 PM
Is Mummy the best pick to replace Sandi? Already have Stef, dont want Nank in the ruck.
Gawn. Put Nank in the rucks until you can bring Gawn in at $500k :)
Quote from: GoLions on June 04, 2017, 11:07:52 PM
Quote from: quinny88 on June 04, 2017, 11:06:47 PM
Otten > Scharenberg
Myers > Cousins
WHE > Lynch
Need to cull some rd 13 bye rookies or I'm stuffed next week
He says, as he trades in two R13 bye rookies :P
Haha I know that's what I mean. They are the only rookies I have worth anything though :'(
20 ready to rumble again this week so nothing for me, seems to be bucking the trend a little bit.
Do we pull the trigger on Newman? He's reached his peak
Sandi and Taranto to Lynch and Wallis is mighty tempting, helps out a lot for R13 as well. Lynch and Wallis about to rise in price so doesn't hurt too much that Taranto still has a bit of cash left in him.
Might pass on Scharenberg as I can't really afford to get another R13 player in right now. Plus, happy to grab Ryan in a couple weeks instead if he can keep his spot.
Quote from: GoLions on June 04, 2017, 11:29:52 PM
Sandi and Taranto to Lynch and Wallis is mighty tempting, helps out a lot for R13 as well. Lynch and Wallis about to rise in price so doesn't hurt too much that Taranto still has a bit of cash left in him.
Might pass on Scharenberg as I can't really afford to get another R13 player in right now. Plus, happy to grab Ryan in a couple weeks instead if he can keep his spot.
Newman -> Ryan and Barrett -> Neale is slated for R14. Mmmmmmmmmmmm.
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.
Quote from: john23132 on June 04, 2017, 11:28:36 PM
Do we pull the trigger on Newman? He's reached his peak
Would be the last rookie I trade out as there's a good chance he is a D6 keeper.
Thinking
Otten-docherty
Barrett-ebert(pod ave 111)
Is he worth the risk u rekon?
Currently 1670Th and wanting to climb
If Sandi flys to Brisbane
Myers to Cousins
SPP to Rocky
If Sandi doesn't fly to Brisbane
Myers to Cousins
SPP to Bont/Oliver/JPK
Sandi to Stef/Kruez
Obv, I really hope Sandi flys to Brisbane ;D
Is NRoo too risky to bring in? Think with the 3 week rest he should be primed to go.
If Sandi is out considering bringing him in. Fyfe/Treloar to Rocky, Otten to Docherty.
Docherty, Adams, Laird, Howe, Montagna, Newman
Rockliff C, Pendlebury, Merrett, Fyfe, JPK, Murphy, SPP/Greenwood
Dahlhaus, Macrae, NRoo, Buddy, Lynch
^^ To hopefully be the 18. Desperately need to make up for last weeks dire effort.
Out: Newman, Parsons, Myers
In: Shaz, Rocky, Cuz
Next week: (if all goes to plan.)
Out: Stewart, Otten, Barrett
In: D.Martin, Doch, Ryan
Complete team, but only 16 if I'm lucky on the park for rnd13. Oh well can't do well in all the byes...
Who needs to go first....Newman or Stewart?
One of them become Docherty.
Am planning on going:
Newman - Docherty
Fisher / Myers - Cousins
Balic - McCrae
Good trades?
Quote from: Hazza09 on June 05, 2017, 01:46:24 AM
Who needs to go first....Newman or Stewart?
One of them become Docherty.
Newman BE of 80 and Stew BE of 12.
Quote from: Ingram on June 05, 2017, 01:48:37 AM
Quote from: Hazza09 on June 05, 2017, 01:46:24 AM
Who needs to go first....Newman or Stewart?
One of them become Docherty.
Newman BE of 80 and Stew BE of 12.
That's what I thought but Newman could be better cover than Stewart.
Is Myers ready to go? Both him and Fisher have been below average, not sure which one has to go.
Myers has the bye aswell.
Doesn't look like Balic will be back anytime soon.
Quote from: _wato on June 05, 2017, 01:13:09 AM
Is NRoo too risky to bring in? Think with the 3 week rest he should be primed to go.
If Sandi is out considering bringing him in. Fyfe/Treloar to Rocky, Otten to Docherty.
Docherty, Adams, Laird, Howe, Montagna, Newman
Rockliff C, Pendlebury, Merrett, Fyfe, JPK, Murphy, SPP/Greenwood
Dahlhaus, Macrae, NRoo, Buddy, Lynch
^^ To hopefully be the 18. Desperately need to make up for last weeks dire effort.
Have thought about it. I think Roo is the Gaz of the forward line. Lots of risk. Plenty of question marks. Plenty of good scoring behind him. Massive ceiling.
No from me. He was massive at Etihad last year (116 average) and has already posted 4 sub 80 scores there this year. Big sign age is catching up to him.
Quote from: _wato on June 05, 2017, 01:13:09 AM
Is NRoo too risky to bring in? Think with the 3 week rest he should be primed to go.
If Sandi is out considering bringing him in. Fyfe/Treloar to Rocky, Otten to Docherty.
Docherty, Adams, Laird, Howe, Montagna, Newman
Rockliff C, Pendlebury, Merrett, Fyfe, JPK, Murphy, SPP/Greenwood
Dahlhaus, Macrae, NRoo, Buddy, Lynch
^^ To hopefully be the 18. Desperately need to make up for last weeks dire effort.
Not happy with Treloar last 3 weeks? I'd be wanting to bring him in! The week off did him wonders
Anyone worried Newman will be back to the NEAFL this week if McVeigh is back?
Taranto B/E?
I was looking at keeping him for 1 more round, but might have to cash out early since there will be minimal bubble boys next week and I'll need the extra cash next week to go Fyfe > Rockliffe
Taranto B/E 61
Looking at
Otten to Docherty
Parsons/Myers to Cousins
Swallow to Rocky.
Barrett or SPP > Cousins
Otten > Docherty
Trying to keep trades down. 11 trades left after those 2.
Barrett Still has BE of 12, money to make still and clear of a bye.
SPP BE of 50.
Also possible T.Williams or Vickers-Willis > Shaz.
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 05, 2017, 10:07:46 AM
Not happy with Treloar last 3 weeks? I'd be wanting to bring him in! The week off did him wonders
I'm quite worried about the effects of a Vince tag x2, PA x2, Adelaide, Geelong, and WCE (away).
Dons, GC, Hawks and North are the only games I am quite confident he will score well in. Whilst he's scored well the last 3 weeks he's effectively not done what I needed him to do and that was eat up the easier first half of the year draw.
Fyfe has a much better record against his opponents on the way home and finishes with GC, Sydney, Richmond and Essendon. Also has Hawks, NM and Brisbane so much larger scope of teams to improve against than Treloar.
Plus also the $70k difference in price is a big selling point. Fyfe against Brisbane this week could see him score anything. Then hopefully the week off freshens him up, Sandi back too and then bam kills the second half of the year.
Otten -> Doch
SPP -> Cousins
It's been a while :P
McGrath --> Doch
Mutimer --> Cousins
Stewart --> Ryan/Scharenberg
And I would personally be holding Treloar wato, has repaid the faith in the last 3 weeks and doesn't look to be slowing down.
Otten -> Schaz
SPP -> Rocky
Turner -> Lynch (GCS)
Otten to Roberton
Myers to Hibberd (melb)
22/23 to play
Quote from: GCSkiwi on June 05, 2017, 01:51:41 PM
Otten -> Schaz
SPP -> Rocky
Turner -> Lynch (GCS)
Why Lynch?
Can't see the attraction tbh
A few have been talking him up but his numbers just don't do it for me.
Quote from: tor01doc on June 05, 2017, 02:32:53 PM
Quote from: GCSkiwi on June 05, 2017, 01:51:41 PM
Otten -> Schaz
SPP -> Rocky
Turner -> Lynch (GCS)
Why Lynch?
Can't see the attraction tbh
A few have been talking him up but his numbers just don't do it for me.
His ability to put in massive numbers make a perfect f6/7 alongside Nank
Quote from: _wato on June 05, 2017, 11:34:08 AM
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 05, 2017, 10:07:46 AM
Not happy with Treloar last 3 weeks? I'd be wanting to bring him in! The week off did him wonders
I'm quite worried about the effects of a Vince tag x2, PA x2, Adelaide, Geelong, and WCE (away).
Dons, GC, Hawks and North are the only games I am quite confident he will score well in. Whilst he's scored well the last 3 weeks he's effectively not done what I needed him to do and that was eat up the easier first half of the year draw.
Fyfe has a much better record against his opponents on the way home and finishes with GC, Sydney, Richmond and Essendon. Also has Hawks, NM and Brisbane so much larger scope of teams to improve against than Treloar.
Plus also the $70k difference in price is a big selling point. Fyfe against Brisbane this week could see him score anything. Then hopefully the week off freshens him up, Sandi back too and then bam kills the second half of the year.
Treloar did fine yesterday when Blakely was tagging him in the 2nd half. I'm not against the trade to Rocky but on form would trade Fyfe over him if you were going to make that move.
Quote from: tor01doc on June 05, 2017, 02:32:53 PM
Quote from: GCSkiwi on June 05, 2017, 01:51:41 PM
Otten -> Schaz
SPP -> Rocky
Turner -> Lynch (GCS)
Why Lynch?
Can't see the attraction tbh
A few have been talking him up but his numbers just don't do it for me.
Yeah I'm still not 100% sold myself to be honest, but here's my thoughts thus far:
Fwds in general are a bit of a crap shoot at the moment. Have Yeo, Macrae, Dahl and Nank which I'd say most do. F5/6, who knows. Heeney, Buddy, Greene, both Lynch's, JJK, NRoo, Cameron all options. If we're going to be short-sighted, put Wallis and Dixon in there too, but not really for me. Steele a good pick for those who started him but I'm not sure I'm confident bringing him in. So what is there separating all of those guys?
It's dicey for me to bring in a rd13 bye players, so bye Greene, Cameron, AdeLynch. Injuries to NRoo and JJK rule them out.
Down to Heeney, Buddy, GCLynch.
Heeney still 50/50, has a high BE so price not going anywhere (possibly down), and I'm not convinced 500k for what hes shown so far is worth it. 4/6 games over 90, including 3/6 over 100, 1/6 125+.
Buddy offset by a massive game, other than that has been pretty ordinary this year. You'd be picking him on class, not form, and at some point I feel even with proven prems form has to come into the equation. Has to show something before he's worth picking imo, especially at 490k. 4/10 over 100, including 2 125+
GCLynch - two terrible scores dragging down his average, and currently, his price. 6/10 over 90, including 4/10 over 100, 1 125+. Better output than Franklin for 60k less. Plus looking at his season last year, a couple of crap scores before bye, averaged 99.6 after. For 430k I'll take someone who should average 90+ and maybe pop out the odd 120+ at F5/F6.
Myers>Cousins.
Otten>Roberton
Have a full midfield but want to bring in Rocky, not sure if Fyfe to Rocky is worth it though.
Hey everyone.
I have 250k in my kitty and need some help making upgrade decisions.
Thinking
Shaw to Williams or Doch
Dahl to Macrae
SPP to Ablett / Sloane or any elite mid.
Dont rhink i can make all 3 work but essentially looking to accomplish this over next 2 weeks.
What are everyones thoughts??
Quote from: tor01doc on June 05, 2017, 02:32:53 PM
Quote from: GCSkiwi on June 05, 2017, 01:51:41 PM
Otten -> Schaz
SPP -> Rocky
Turner -> Lynch (GCS)
Why Lynch?
Can't see the attraction tbh
A few have been talking him up but his numbers just don't do it for me.
What about Wallis? Had his bye too.
Quote from: AaronKirk on June 05, 2017, 03:09:23 PM
Quote from: _wato on June 05, 2017, 11:34:08 AM
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 05, 2017, 10:07:46 AM
Not happy with Treloar last 3 weeks? I'd be wanting to bring him in! The week off did him wonders
I'm quite worried about the effects of a Vince tag x2, PA x2, Adelaide, Geelong, and WCE (away).
Dons, GC, Hawks and North are the only games I am quite confident he will score well in. Whilst he's scored well the last 3 weeks he's effectively not done what I needed him to do and that was eat up the easier first half of the year draw.
Fyfe has a much better record against his opponents on the way home and finishes with GC, Sydney, Richmond and Essendon. Also has Hawks, NM and Brisbane so much larger scope of teams to improve against than Treloar.
Plus also the $70k difference in price is a big selling point. Fyfe against Brisbane this week could see him score anything. Then hopefully the week off freshens him up, Sandi back too and then bam kills the second half of the year.
Treloar did fine yesterday when Blakely was tagging him in the 2nd half. I'm not against the trade to Rocky but on form would trade Fyfe over him if you were going to make that move.
No way Treloar is a trade option after his past 3 weeks lol (125, 141, 128) - imo that's just trolling
They still play hawthorn, essendon, GC, eagles (H) and north who are all giving away massive midfield points
I get it if he was priced $650k and you were trading to someone under priced ie a JPK to make money to invest elsewhere but no way he's leaving my side
Quote from: TableKing on June 05, 2017, 04:04:16 PM
Hey everyone.
I have 250k in my kitty and need some help making upgrade decisions.
Thinking
Shaw to Williams or Doch
Dahl to Macrae
SPP to Ablett / Sloane or any elite mid.
Dont rhink i can make all 3 work but essentially looking to accomplish this over next 2 weeks.
What are everyones thoughts??
Probably would look to bring in Macrea another way. Trading Dahl for him is just a sideways trade that doesn't really accomplish anything. Both averaging 99 and 101 respectively. . Same again with Shaw for the time being, just another sideways trade
::)
OUT :- SPP, T Stewart, Berry IN :- Cousins, Docherty, M Hibberd.. Defence finished. Wanted 1 mid and 1 For.
;)
Quote from: GCSkiwi on June 05, 2017, 03:59:24 PM
Quote from: tor01doc on June 05, 2017, 02:32:53 PM
Quote from: GCSkiwi on June 05, 2017, 01:51:41 PM
Otten -> Schaz
SPP -> Rocky
Turner -> Lynch (GCS)
Why Lynch?
Can't see the attraction tbh
A few have been talking him up but his numbers just don't do it for me.
Yeah I'm still not 100% sold myself to be honest, but here's my thoughts thus far:
Fwds in general are a bit of a crap shoot at the moment. Have Yeo, Macrae, Dahl and Nank which I'd say most do. F5/6, who knows. Heeney, Buddy, Greene, both Lynch's, JJK, NRoo, Cameron all options. If we're going to be short-sighted, put Wallis and Dixon in there too, but not really for me. Steele a good pick for those who started him but I'm not sure I'm confident bringing him in. So what is there separating all of those guys?
It's dicey for me to bring in a rd13 bye players, so bye Greene, Cameron, AdeLynch. Injuries to NRoo and JJK rule them out.
Down to Heeney, Buddy, GCLynch.
Heeney still 50/50, has a high BE so price not going anywhere (possibly down), and I'm not convinced 500k for what hes shown so far is worth it. 4/6 games over 90, including 3/6 over 100, 1/6 125+.
Buddy offset by a massive game, other than that has been pretty ordinary this year. You'd be picking him on class, not form, and at some point I feel even with proven prems form has to come into the equation. Has to show something before he's worth picking imo, especially at 490k. 4/10 over 100, including 2 125+
GCLynch - two terrible scores dragging down his average, and currently, his price. 6/10 over 90, including 4/10 over 100, 1 125+. Better output than Franklin for 60k less. Plus looking at his season last year, a couple of crap scores before bye, averaged 99.6 after. For 430k I'll take someone who should average 90+ and maybe pop out the odd 120+ at F5/F6.
And our personal conversations continues...
Take out Lynch's and Buddy's highest and lowest scores and they average 89 and 91 respectively.
I already have Buddy but to be honest, if I were too select a new F5/6 now (have Yeo, McCrae, Dahl, Nank, Buddy already) it would be out of Wallis and Heeney.
Wallis having DPP doesn't interest me much as 3 others there do as well.
If it is this week then Wallis but if it can wait, Heeney.
Traded Taranto > Cousins. Didn't really want to do it as Cousins is relatively unknown with his place in the side and Taranto should continue to play if he keeps up this form, and increase in price
But by doing this allows me the extra cash to trade Fyfe > Rockliff next week (giving me 17 premos fielded round 13) so I really see no other point keeping Taranto besides cash generation (Rockliff just about finishes off my side anyway depending whether SSelwood is a keeper or not.)
Overall trades
In: Docherty, Hibberd, Cousins
Out: Tuohey, Newman, Taranto with 300k in the kitty for future moves (Fyfe > Rocky, Witts > Gawn, SSelwood > Bont/Martin/Sloane)
Thoughts?
Newman -> Hibberd
Myers -> Ablett
Roughy -> Buddy
Quote from: tor01doc on June 05, 2017, 04:41:16 PM
Quote from: GCSkiwi on June 05, 2017, 03:59:24 PM
Quote from: tor01doc on June 05, 2017, 02:32:53 PM
Quote from: GCSkiwi on June 05, 2017, 01:51:41 PM
Otten -> Schaz
SPP -> Rocky
Turner -> Lynch (GCS)
Why Lynch?
Can't see the attraction tbh
A few have been talking him up but his numbers just don't do it for me.
Yeah I'm still not 100% sold myself to be honest, but here's my thoughts thus far:
Fwds in general are a bit of a crap shoot at the moment. Have Yeo, Macrae, Dahl and Nank which I'd say most do. F5/6, who knows. Heeney, Buddy, Greene, both Lynch's, JJK, NRoo, Cameron all options. If we're going to be short-sighted, put Wallis and Dixon in there too, but not really for me. Steele a good pick for those who started him but I'm not sure I'm confident bringing him in. So what is there separating all of those guys?
It's dicey for me to bring in a rd13 bye players, so bye Greene, Cameron, AdeLynch. Injuries to NRoo and JJK rule them out.
Down to Heeney, Buddy, GCLynch.
Heeney still 50/50, has a high BE so price not going anywhere (possibly down), and I'm not convinced 500k for what hes shown so far is worth it. 4/6 games over 90, including 3/6 over 100, 1/6 125+.
Buddy offset by a massive game, other than that has been pretty ordinary this year. You'd be picking him on class, not form, and at some point I feel even with proven prems form has to come into the equation. Has to show something before he's worth picking imo, especially at 490k. 4/10 over 100, including 2 125+
GCLynch - two terrible scores dragging down his average, and currently, his price. 6/10 over 90, including 4/10 over 100, 1 125+. Better output than Franklin for 60k less. Plus looking at his season last year, a couple of crap scores before bye, averaged 99.6 after. For 430k I'll take someone who should average 90+ and maybe pop out the odd 120+ at F5/F6.
And our personal conversations continues...
Take out Lynch's and Buddy's highest and lowest scores and they average 89 and 91 respectively.
I already have Buddy but to be honest, if I were too select a new F5/6 now (have Yeo, McCrae, Dahl, Nank, Buddy already) it would be out of Wallis and Heeney.
Wallis having DPP doesn't interest me much as 3 others there do as well.
If it is this week then Wallis but if it can wait, Heeney.
The attraction with most key forwards is getting them cheap because of their high variance between scores. Lynch will play all year and average 90-95. For a F4-f6 (this year) that's perfectly acceptable. Throw in the fact he's had his bye and is pretty cheap. A sound trade IMHO.
Quote from: King_Robbo on June 05, 2017, 04:11:24 PM
Quote from: AaronKirk on June 05, 2017, 03:09:23 PM
Quote from: _wato on June 05, 2017, 11:34:08 AM
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 05, 2017, 10:07:46 AM
Not happy with Treloar last 3 weeks? I'd be wanting to bring him in! The week off did him wonders
I'm quite worried about the effects of a Vince tag x2, PA x2, Adelaide, Geelong, and WCE (away).
Dons, GC, Hawks and North are the only games I am quite confident he will score well in. Whilst he's scored well the last 3 weeks he's effectively not done what I needed him to do and that was eat up the easier first half of the year draw.
Fyfe has a much better record against his opponents on the way home and finishes with GC, Sydney, Richmond and Essendon. Also has Hawks, NM and Brisbane so much larger scope of teams to improve against than Treloar.
Plus also the $70k difference in price is a big selling point. Fyfe against Brisbane this week could see him score anything. Then hopefully the week off freshens him up, Sandi back too and then bam kills the second half of the year.
Treloar did fine yesterday when Blakely was tagging him in the 2nd half. I'm not against the trade to Rocky but on form would trade Fyfe over him if you were going to make that move.
No way Treloar is a trade option after his past 3 weeks lol (125, 141, 128) - imo that's just trolling
They still play hawthorn, essendon, GC, eagles (H) and north who are all giving away massive midfield points
I get it if he was priced $650k and you were trading to someone under priced ie a JPK to make money to invest elsewhere but no way he's leaving my side
It ain't trolling m8, why would I troll around here? Reckon if you've been here long enough you'd know that I don't troll and are pretty honest and efficient with everything I do. Oh wait, big Robbo the ruck coach from 2016, might not understand that hey?!?!? Treloar is very prone to 70's and all it takes is 20-25 touches and a few clangers and he won't meet the mark. Needs 30+ to get close to 110, 35+ to go 120. Although I do admit the bad draw doesn't take place until Rd 19 so will probably hold.
Need to get Rocky and am not prepared to get rid of anyone in the mids yet. What do you suggest? Fyfe is the only one and I reckon he comes good.
going
Myers > Cousins
Stewart > Ryan via DPP
Berry > Hibberd
Leaves me with one upgrade to come next week in the mids and I'll be full premium with ~10 trades left. Will then look at improving Fyfe, Newman, Witts then I might be happy ;D
Have been hanging out to get Docherty in, but atm have just enough cash to go
Myers to Bont
Stewart to Hibberd
If there are no good rookie downgrades this week (who aren't RD13), I might do something like this instead and pass on Dochers until Newman is ready to be moved on
Quote from: Ricochet on June 05, 2017, 08:04:57 PM
Have been hanging out to get Docherty in, but atm have just enough cash to go
Myers to Bont
Stewart to Hibberd
If there are no good rookie downgrades this week (who aren't RD13), I might do something like this instead and pass on Dochers until Newman is ready to be moved on
Couldn't go Newman to Doc? Or do you need to trade Stewart due to the bye?
Marchbank to Ryan
Hampton to Hibberd
NRoo likely to miss this week for those considering him
Alarm bells if true, wouldn't touch him
Was planning
Myers, Butler and Parsons out for
Hibberd, Cousins and Wallis 8)
But $100 short :'(
So far:
Myers, Sandi & Stewart out
Lynch (GC), Cousins, Hibberd in.
Don't even know what to do anymore.
Quote from: tkringle on June 05, 2017, 09:48:05 PM
Quote from: Ricochet on June 05, 2017, 08:04:57 PM
Have been hanging out to get Docherty in, but atm have just enough cash to go
Myers to Bont
Stewart to Hibberd
If there are no good rookie downgrades this week (who aren't RD13), I might do something like this instead and pass on Dochers until Newman is ready to be moved on
Couldn't go Newman to Doc? Or do you need to trade Stewart due to the bye?
Yeh could do that, but with the way he's scoring i'll hang onto him until he's maxed out and go to Dochers then. Probably just after RD13
Quote from: _wato on June 05, 2017, 10:54:38 PM
Don't even know what to do anymore.
Me too man
Absolutely stumped with what to do
I want Rocky, but the extra 40-50k by get Bont or JPK could be handy
Also don't know what the hell to do with Sandi
Lynch at 433k is value too
Argh!
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 05, 2017, 11:17:57 PM
Quote from: _wato on June 05, 2017, 10:54:38 PM
Don't even know what to do anymore.
Me too man
Absolutely stumped with what to do
I want Rocky, but the extra 40-50k by get Bont or JPK could be handy
Also don't know what the hell to do with Sandi
Lynch at 433k is value too
Argh!
I'm stumped on the exact same 2 players lol
Mids currently is Danger Pendles Treloar Fyfe JPK Murph Merrett Scooter SPP Fisher Lloyd
Have nobody to trade to get Rocky in (not trading SPP bc I don't have the funds)
And then Sandi, fml he is frustrating. Already have Lynch so genuinely stumped.
Ablett, Wallis, Docherty could work.
Quote from: Ricochet on June 05, 2017, 11:03:23 PM
Quote from: tkringle on June 05, 2017, 09:48:05 PM
Quote from: Ricochet on June 05, 2017, 08:04:57 PM
Have been hanging out to get Docherty in, but atm have just enough cash to go
Myers to Bont
Stewart to Hibberd
If there are no good rookie downgrades this week (who aren't RD13), I might do something like this instead and pass on Dochers until Newman is ready to be moved on
Couldn't go Newman to Doc? Or do you need to trade Stewart due to the bye?
Yeh could do that, but with the way he's scoring i'll hang onto him until he's maxed out and go to Dochers then. Probably just after RD13
Fair enough. Newman has a BE of 81 so unless he goes big again he might not make you as much as keeping Stewart (BE 12) till the end of round 13.
Quote from: tkringle on June 05, 2017, 11:40:16 PM
Quote from: Ricochet on June 05, 2017, 11:03:23 PM
Quote from: tkringle on June 05, 2017, 09:48:05 PM
Quote from: Ricochet on June 05, 2017, 08:04:57 PM
Have been hanging out to get Docherty in, but atm have just enough cash to go
Myers to Bont
Stewart to Hibberd
If there are no good rookie downgrades this week (who aren't RD13), I might do something like this instead and pass on Dochers until Newman is ready to be moved on
Couldn't go Newman to Doc? Or do you need to trade Stewart due to the bye?
Yeh could do that, but with the way he's scoring i'll hang onto him until he's maxed out and go to Dochers then. Probably just after RD13
Fair enough. Newman has a BE of 81 so unless he goes big again he might not make you as much as keeping Stewart (BE 12) till the end of round 13.
You are pure genius
Maybe that is my answer
Nice and simple this week EVW > Roberton
Gives me 20 this week
Quote from: tor01doc on June 06, 2017, 12:07:05 AM
Quote from: tkringle on June 05, 2017, 11:40:16 PM
Quote from: Ricochet on June 05, 2017, 11:03:23 PM
Quote from: tkringle on June 05, 2017, 09:48:05 PM
Quote from: Ricochet on June 05, 2017, 08:04:57 PM
Have been hanging out to get Docherty in, but atm have just enough cash to go
Myers to Bont
Stewart to Hibberd
If there are no good rookie downgrades this week (who aren't RD13), I might do something like this instead and pass on Dochers until Newman is ready to be moved on
Couldn't go Newman to Doc? Or do you need to trade Stewart due to the bye?
Yeh could do that, but with the way he's scoring i'll hang onto him until he's maxed out and go to Dochers then. Probably just after RD13
Fair enough. Newman has a BE of 81 so unless he goes big again he might not make you as much as keeping Stewart (BE 12) till the end of round 13.
You are pure genius
Maybe that is my answer
Also, consider this...Swans don't play any teams below them on the ladder until round 23.
THURSDAY NIGHT GAME
Quote from: _wato on June 05, 2017, 11:33:41 PM
I'm stumped on the exact same 2 players lol
Mids currently is Danger Pendles Treloar Fyfe JPK Murph Merrett Scooter SPP Fisher Lloyd
Have nobody to trade to get Rocky in (not trading SPP bc I don't have the funds)
And then Sandi, fml he is frustrating. Already have Lynch so genuinely stumped.
Ablett, Wallis, Docherty could work.
Happen to have Nank in the FWDs? Trade Sandi out, put Nank in RUCKS, and bring in a cheaper FWD?
Then you could bring in Gawn later on if you want that flexible RUCK/FWD DPP.
I have noticed many SC 's on Supercoach Gold have traded out Stewart over Newman.
Is there reason for this?
Newman B/E of 81 projected to increase very little from now on.
I am thinking Newman - Docherty (have 409k into bank) and Myers / Fisher - Cousins
What are the benefits of holding Newman?
Quote from: Hazza09 on June 06, 2017, 12:58:01 PM
I have noticed many SC 's on Supercoach Gold have traded out Stewart over Newman.
Is there reason for this?
Newman B/E of 81 projected to increase very little from now on.
I am thinking Newman - Docherty (have 409k into bank) and Myers / Fisher - Cousins
What are the benefits of holding Newman?
Much higher ceiling than Stewart.
Quote from: oh_lol on June 06, 2017, 11:33:27 AM
Quote from: _wato on June 05, 2017, 11:33:41 PM
I'm stumped on the exact same 2 players lol
Mids currently is Danger Pendles Treloar Fyfe JPK Murph Merrett Scooter SPP Fisher Lloyd
Have nobody to trade to get Rocky in (not trading SPP bc I don't have the funds)
And then Sandi, fml he is frustrating. Already have Lynch so genuinely stumped.
Ablett, Wallis, Docherty could work.
Happen to have Nank in the FWDs? Trade Sandi out, put Nank in RUCKS, and bring in a cheaper FWD?
Then you could bring in Gawn later on if you want that flexible RUCK/FWD DPP.
Have toyed with the same plan. Sandi out for lynch and WHE for wallis. Would mean that nank has to stay in rucks but gotta make some risky moves. Figure both have a high ceiling that may come in handy for some points. In saying this, if sandi is named to go on the plane do I reverse it.....
I'm so stuck on what to do this week!
I'm about stuffed next week, so thinking I'll 'tank' round 13.
SPP > Ebert
Myers > Cousins
Is the plan, but need to do a third trade for the cash.
Perhaps Fisher > Brown if he's named
Ugh!
Quote from: jfitty on June 06, 2017, 01:32:37 PM
I'm so stuck on what to do this week!
I'm about stuffed next week, so thinking I'll 'tank' round 13.
SPP > Ebert
Myers > Cousins
Is the plan, but need to do a third trade for the cash.
Perhaps Fisher > Brown if he's named
Ugh!
Much the same for me the problem only RD. 13 rookies to choose this week which stuffs up next week so suicide to be trading out RD. 11 cows this week for me so it looks like
Myers > Cousins 13 for 13
Parsons > Lynch ( GC )
will give me 19 this week but only 17 next week , rookies have been my achilles heel this year :(
Quote from: jvalles69 on June 06, 2017, 01:05:22 PM
Quote from: Hazza09 on June 06, 2017, 12:58:01 PM
I have noticed many SC 's on Supercoach Gold have traded out Stewart over Newman.
Is there reason for this?
Newman B/E of 81 projected to increase very little from now on.
I am thinking Newman - Docherty (have 409k into bank) and Myers / Fisher - Cousins
What are the benefits of holding Newman?
Much higher ceiling than Stewart.
Newman's had his bye as well.
Don't know why everyone's trading out Myers. Surely better use of trades elsewhere. Reeks of desperation for cash.
Quote from: Hogan17 on June 06, 2017, 02:11:43 PM
Don't know why everyone's trading out Myers. Surely better use of trades elsewhere. Reeks of desperation for cash.
A lot of us are desperate for cash :P
Quote from: Hogan17 on June 06, 2017, 02:11:43 PM
Don't know why everyone's trading out Myers. Surely better use of trades elsewhere. Reeks of desperation for cash.
When you look at your team that's what you see but it's not when I look at my team ;)
Quote from: Hogan17 on June 06, 2017, 02:11:43 PM
Don't know why everyone's trading out Myers. Surely better use of trades elsewhere. Reeks of desperation for cash.
For me, he's the best option to turn into a premo and need to move rd 13 players so I don't cop a donut.
Quote from: jvalles69 on June 06, 2017, 02:41:32 PM
Quote from: Hogan17 on June 06, 2017, 02:11:43 PM
Don't know why everyone's trading out Myers. Surely better use of trades elsewhere. Reeks of desperation for cash.
For me, he's the best option to turn into a premo and need to move rd 13 players so I don't cop a donut.
+1
I'll be moving Myers this week for Rocky and next week Lloyd for Brown which frees me up for a grab at my final mid. Just have to accept that rookies are shower house this year and the Greenwoods and Newmans are few and far between.
Been playing around with things and have come up with this (Which allows me to keep SPP for now)
EVW to Cousins
Sandi to Lynch
Myers to Rocky
Gives me 20 on field this week and 20 on field next week without trading next week
Scooter M8, and in two weeks time I'll do SPP to Ryan and Stewart to Lloyd which leaves me enough in the bank to upgrade Scooter to final prem mid, or keep him and use money to get Gawn if warranted
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 06, 2017, 03:24:30 PM
Been playing around with things and have come up with this (Which allows me to keep SPP for now)
EVW to Cousins
Sandi to Lynch
Myers to Rocky
Gives me 20 on field this week and 20 on field next week without trading next week
Scooter M8, and in two weeks time I'll do SPP to Ryan and Stewart to Lloyd which leaves me enough in the bank to upgrade Scooter to final prem mid, or keep him and use money to get Gawn if warranted
Like those trades a lot, was trying something similar but can't squeeze in Lynch.
For me it's -
Myers to Cousins
Otten to Ryan
Fisher to Rocky
have enough cash to go Sandi to Yeo next week.
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 06, 2017, 03:24:30 PM
Been playing around with things and have come up with this (Which allows me to keep SPP for now)
EVW to Cousins
Sandi to Lynch
Myers to Rocky
Gives me 20 on field this week and 20 on field next week without trading next week
Scooter M8, and in two weeks time I'll do SPP to Ryan and Stewart to Lloyd which leaves me enough in the bank to upgrade Scooter to final prem mid, or keep him and use money to get Gawn if warranted
Sandi to Lynch. You're welcome 8)
But seriously, they look rock solid options. I'll be doing similar but I'll be keeping Myers, got a gut feeling he'll come good
Hey guys going insane this week! I'm inside the top 700 for the first time ever at this time of year I've always been around the top 2000 but doing well.
Stuck though
I caught up 600 spots last week cause I planned on keeping trades and being aggressive over the byes!
Team is
Laird Adams Lloyd shaw newman otten bench Stewart evw
Dusty danger Fyfe Bont Selwood Zorko Oliver Sloane bench spp fisher Myers
Witts Ryder strandy
Nank Dahl yeo macrae whe greenwood Bolton eddy
Option a
Got 14 trades with 90k
Fisher -cousins
Otten -roberton
Gives me another absolute top 6 lock in roberton
Leaves 12 trades 30k
Option b
Fisher cousins
Otten to hibberd
Fyfe to jpk
Get rid of otten who's done his job to hibberd looks great and Fyfe who I think a lot will hold onto for jpk. This is a risk and jpk ends years massive. Don't have to worry about byes with this
Leaves 11 trades and 38k
Option c
Fisher to cousins
Otten to hibberd
Fyfe to pendles
Fyfe out to pendles feels a lot safer then jpk with pendles being a top 2-5 mid. But he has the bye. Looking at my team I should be strong enough next week numbers wise. But would jpk seeing he plays the extra game be worth losing pendles extra 10 points a week? Leaves 11 trades no money
Tough choice. Will be endeavouring to get rid of spp, Stewart, evw for cash and getting rid of whe/Newman for docherty and whoever (buddy, heeney, Greene,Cameron) leaves greenwood and a heap of cash. Could sub him to mids and trade spp to another gun forward. I know my team isn't as strong as most in the top 1000 but any feedback would be greatly appreciated :)
Quote from: King_Robbo on June 06, 2017, 06:59:29 PM
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 06, 2017, 03:24:30 PM
Been playing around with things and have come up with this (Which allows me to keep SPP for now)
EVW to Cousins
Sandi to Lynch
Myers to Rocky
Gives me 20 on field this week and 20 on field next week without trading next week
Scooter M8, and in two weeks time I'll do SPP to Ryan and Stewart to Lloyd which leaves me enough in the bank to upgrade Scooter to final prem mid, or keep him and use money to get Gawn if warranted
Sandi to Lynch. You're welcome 8)
But seriously, they look rock solid options. I'll be doing similar but I'll be keeping Myers, got a gut feeling he'll come good
Would like to keep Myers myself, but no other real options if I want Cousins and the funds to get Doch next week
Quote from: aces-high on June 06, 2017, 09:18:23 PM
Hey guys going insane this week! I'm inside the top 700 for the first time ever at this time of year I've always been around the top 2000 but doing well.
Stuck though
I caught up 600 spots last week cause I planned on keeping trades and being aggressive over the byes!
Team is
Laird Adams Lloyd shaw newman otten bench Stewart evw
Dusty danger Fyfe Bont Selwood Zorko Oliver Sloane bench spp fisher Myers
Witts Ryder strandy
Nank Dahl yeo macrae whe greenwood Bolton eddy
Option a
Got 14 trades with 90k
Fisher -cousins
Otten -roberton
Gives me another absolute top 6 lock in roberton
Leaves 12 trades 30k
Option b
Fisher cousins
Otten to hibberd
Fyfe to jpk
Get rid of otten who's done his job to hibberd looks great and Fyfe who I think a lot will hold onto for jpk. This is a risk and jpk ends years massive. Don't have to worry about byes with this
Leaves 11 trades and 38k
Option c
Fisher to cousins
Otten to hibberd
Fyfe to pendles
Fyfe out to pendles feels a lot safer then jpk with pendles being a top 2-5 mid. But he has the bye. Looking at my team I should be strong enough next week numbers wise. But would jpk seeing he plays the extra game be worth losing pendles extra 10 points a week? Leaves 11 trades no money
Tough choice. Will be endeavouring to get rid of spp, Stewart, evw for cash and getting rid of whe/Newman for docherty and whoever (buddy, heeney, Greene,Cameron) leaves greenwood and a heap of cash. Could sub him to mids and trade spp to another gun forward. I know my team isn't as strong as most in the top 1000 but any feedback would be greatly appreciated :)
I have 19 playing this week
I have 19 if I get pendles next week or 20 if I get jpk
Fisher to Cousins
Fyfe to Docherty (via Hibberd to mids)
Luxury trade? Stupid trade?
Quote from: aces-high on June 06, 2017, 09:22:49 PM
Quote from: aces-high on June 06, 2017, 09:18:23 PM
Hey guys going insane this week! I'm inside the top 700 for the first time ever at this time of year I've always been around the top 2000 but doing well.
Stuck though
I caught up 600 spots last week cause I planned on keeping trades and being aggressive over the byes!
Team is
Laird Adams Lloyd shaw newman otten bench Stewart evw
Dusty danger Fyfe Bont Selwood Zorko Oliver Sloane bench spp fisher Myers
Witts Ryder strandy
Nank Dahl yeo macrae whe greenwood Bolton eddy
Option a
Got 14 trades with 90k
Fisher -cousins
Otten -roberton
Gives me another absolute top 6 lock in roberton
Leaves 12 trades 30k
Option b
Fisher cousins
Otten to hibberd
Fyfe to jpk
Get rid of otten who's done his job to hibberd looks great and Fyfe who I think a lot will hold onto for jpk. This is a risk and jpk ends years massive. Don't have to worry about byes with this
Leaves 11 trades and 38k
Option c
Fisher to cousins
Otten to hibberd
Fyfe to pendles
Fyfe out to pendles feels a lot safer then jpk with pendles being a top 2-5 mid. But he has the bye. Looking at my team I should be strong enough next week numbers wise. But would jpk seeing he plays the extra game be worth losing pendles extra 10 points a week? Leaves 11 trades no money
Tough choice. Will be endeavouring to get rid of spp, Stewart, evw for cash and getting rid of whe/Newman for docherty and whoever (buddy, heeney, Greene,Cameron) leaves greenwood and a heap of cash. Could sub him to mids and trade spp to another gun forward. I know my team isn't as strong as most in the top 1000 but any feedback would be greatly appreciated :)
I have 19 playing this week
I have 19 if I get pendles next week or 20 if I get jpk
Sam Docherty, Lance Franklin would have to be two on your radar i think. Personally I like the Fisher -> Cousins trade, and the Otten -> Hibberd one. Not a fan of Fyfe to Pendles though.
Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on June 06, 2017, 09:27:03 PM
Fisher to Cousins
Fyfe to Docherty (via Hibberd to mids)
Luxury trade? Stupid trade?
Luxuriously stupid
and stupidly luxurious
Docherty BE 127
Rocky BE 55
Quote from: tor01doc on June 06, 2017, 09:33:40 PM
Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on June 06, 2017, 09:27:03 PM
Fisher to Cousins
Fyfe to Docherty (via Hibberd to mids)
Luxury trade? Stupid trade?
Luxuriously stupid and stupidly luxurious
Docherty BE 127
Rocky BE 55
Yeah but my miss are stacked mate. Got a bit carried away in recent weeks. Defense is as weak as Mark Robinsons apology to Fasolo.
Mids: Danger, Titchell, Sloane, Cripps, Treloar, Bont, Murphy, Fyfe (S Selwood, Greenwood, Fisher)
Def: Adams, Laird, Shaw, Hibberd, Scharenberg, Berry (Stewart, Hibberd)
I'm only considering trading Fyfe in order to start bolstering defense. Selwood can play M8 for a while. I have been waiting for Docherty to have a rubbish week but it hasn't happened and I want him now (Veruca Salt impersonation)
Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on June 06, 2017, 09:47:35 PM
Quote from: tor01doc on June 06, 2017, 09:33:40 PM
Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on June 06, 2017, 09:27:03 PM
Fisher to Cousins
Fyfe to Docherty (via Hibberd to mids)
Luxury trade? Stupid trade?
Luxuriously stupid and stupidly luxurious
Docherty BE 127
Rocky BE 55
Yeah but my miss are stacked mate. Got a bit carried away in recent weeks. Defense is as weak as Mark Robinsons apology to Fasolo.
Mids: Danger, Titchell, Sloane, Cripps, Treloar, Bont, Murphy, Fyfe (S Selwood, Greenwood, Fisher)
Def: Adams, Laird, Shaw, Hibberd, Scharenberg, Berry (Stewart, Hibberd)
I'm only considering trading Fyfe in order to start bolstering defense. Selwood can play M8 for a while. I have been waiting for Docherty to have a rubbish week but it hasn't happened and I want him now (Veruca Salt impersonation)
Yeah but no but yeah but no
Scooter can't play M8 this week - so hold Rocky and score more and make cash (Captain loophole too)
Don't care how, hold Rocky now.
Quote from: PowerBug on June 06, 2017, 09:28:49 PM
Quote from: aces-high on June 06, 2017, 09:22:49 PM
Quote from: aces-high on June 06, 2017, 09:18:23 PM
Hey guys going insane this week! I'm inside the top 700 for the first time ever at this time of year I've always been around the top 2000 but doing well.
Stuck though
I caught up 600 spots last week cause I planned on keeping trades and being aggressive over the byes!
Team is
Laird Adams Lloyd shaw newman otten bench Stewart evw
Dusty danger Fyfe Bont Selwood Zorko Oliver Sloane bench spp fisher Myers
Witts Ryder strandy
Nank Dahl yeo macrae whe greenwood Bolton eddy
Option a
Got 14 trades with 90k
Fisher -cousins
Otten -roberton
Gives me another absolute top 6 lock in roberton
Leaves 12 trades 30k
Option b
Fisher cousins
Otten to hibberd
Fyfe to jpk
Get rid of otten who's done his job to hibberd looks great and Fyfe who I think a lot will hold onto for jpk. This is a risk and jpk ends years massive. Don't have to worry about byes with this
Leaves 11 trades and 38k
Option c
Fisher to cousins
Otten to hibberd
Fyfe to pendles
Fyfe out to pendles feels a lot safer then jpk with pendles being a top 2-5 mid. But he has the bye. Looking at my team I should be strong enough next week numbers wise. But would jpk seeing he plays the extra game be worth losing pendles extra 10 points a week? Leaves 11 trades no money
Tough choice. Will be endeavouring to get rid of spp, Stewart, evw for cash and getting rid of whe/Newman for docherty and whoever (buddy, heeney, Greene,Cameron) leaves greenwood and a heap of cash. Could sub him to mids and trade spp to another gun forward. I know my team isn't as strong as most in the top 1000 but any feedback would be greatly appreciated :)
I have 19 playing this week
I have 19 if I get pendles next week or 20 if I get jpk
Sam Docherty, Lance Franklin would have to be two on your radar i think. Personally I like the Fisher -> Cousins trade, and the Otten -> Hibberd one. Not a fan of Fyfe to Pendles though.
What are your thoughts on keeping him though? Like getting an edge over others is more the thought process. If he continues to deliver an average of 100 and pendles/jpk average 110/115 for the rest of the year I miss out on 100+ points. Do you see him getting back into form? He's playing good footy but don't think he's gonna be banging monsters on the run home
option 1.
mcgrath>bont
evw>ryan
otten>hibberd.
20 starters with 16 prems. harbrow and Sandi on the park but not playing.
3 rookies down back, ryan, newman, scharenberg
next week - newman>lloyd only rookie starting will be stewart d6, fwds/mids are already finished with steele at f7/m9
SPP to Cousins
Fyfe to Rocky
Shaw to Roberton
Need some rd13 playing premos, and Fyfe and Shaw might need a run in my seconds ::)
Quote from: tor01doc on June 06, 2017, 09:33:40 PM
Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on June 06, 2017, 09:27:03 PM
Fisher to Cousins
Fyfe to Docherty (via Hibberd to mids)
Luxury trade? Stupid trade?
Luxuriously stupid and stupidly luxurious
Docherty BE 127
Rocky BE 55
Disagree Doc. Maneuvering around the byes is a big tick. Docherty is an absolute must - certainly not at $600k but the sooner you bring him in the better. Fyfe's going to be at least 10ppg under a top 10 midfielder. Don't think there's anything luxurious about moving on from Fyfe- but certainly Rocky should be the first trade in target.
Quote from: batt on June 06, 2017, 11:36:56 PM
Quote from: tor01doc on June 06, 2017, 09:33:40 PM
Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on June 06, 2017, 09:27:03 PM
Fisher to Cousins
Fyfe to Docherty (via Hibberd to mids)
Luxury trade? Stupid trade?
Luxuriously stupid and stupidly luxurious
Docherty BE 127
Rocky BE 55
Disagree Doc. Maneuvering around the byes is a big tick. Docherty is an absolute must - certainly not at $600k but the sooner you bring him in the better. Fyfe's going to be at least 10ppg under a top 10 midfielder. Don't think there's anything luxurious about moving on from Fyfe- but certainly Rocky should be the first trade in target.
I too disagree....with me
I thought he meant Rocky not Fyfe
My bad
Just ignore me
Scharenberg or wait for Ryan? Don't know if either are worth it but don't have much of a choice :-\
Quote from: quinny88 on June 07, 2017, 01:04:59 AM
Scharenberg or wait for Ryan? Don't know if either are worth it but don't have much of a choice :-\
I'm just grabbing Ryan, the extra cash will be gold at this stage. With trades so low it would pay to make every one count. Hoping Freeman gets a game soon as he will probably be my last rookie.
Im messing around atm
Myers or Pickett to Cousins
Marchbank or Newman( 99% marchy) to Hibberd
and maybeee just maybe
Preuss to Strindica for cash and use nank for dpp
Quote from: King_Robbo on June 05, 2017, 04:11:24 PM
Quote from: AaronKirk on June 05, 2017, 03:09:23 PM
Quote from: _wato on June 05, 2017, 11:34:08 AM
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 05, 2017, 10:07:46 AM
Not happy with Treloar last 3 weeks? I'd be wanting to bring him in! The week off did him wonders
I'm quite worried about the effects of a Vince tag x2, PA x2, Adelaide, Geelong, and WCE (away).
Dons, GC, Hawks and North are the only games I am quite confident he will score well in. Whilst he's scored well the last 3 weeks he's effectively not done what I needed him to do and that was eat up the easier first half of the year draw.
Fyfe has a much better record against his opponents on the way home and finishes with GC, Sydney, Richmond and Essendon. Also has Hawks, NM and Brisbane so much larger scope of teams to improve against than Treloar.
Plus also the $70k difference in price is a big selling point. Fyfe against Brisbane this week could see him score anything. Then hopefully the week off freshens him up, Sandi back too and then bam kills the second half of the year.
Treloar did fine yesterday when Blakely was tagging him in the 2nd half. I'm not against the trade to Rocky but on form would trade Fyfe over him if you were going to make that move.
No way Treloar is a trade option after his past 3 weeks lol (125, 141, 128) - imo that's just trolling
They still play hawthorn, essendon, GC, eagles (H) and north who are all giving away massive midfield points
I get it if he was priced $650k and you were trading to someone under priced ie a JPK to make money to invest elsewhere but no way he's leaving my side
Well TROLLoar is a the biggest troll there is so it kinda makes sense. ;D
Treloar is not a troll. Couldn't be further from it
I get the running gag and people love getting stuck into you about it but Treloar was simply going through a form slump and nothing more. Trading him helped you short term but let's see at the end of the year before making calls
He's a jet either way
Thinking this atm. Pending Team announcements.
Otten to Docherty
Parsons/Myers to Cousins
D Swallow to Rocky
Just the two for me I think, looking at a big fat 0 next week otherwise.
Sandi->Lynch (via Nank)
Myers->Rockliff
Plan to sideways Greenwood to Gawn when he's dropped in price right in time for the finals and will swing Nank back down to float through F6/7 with Lynch/Steele and loopholing with Eddy when I can.
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 07, 2017, 10:09:32 AM
Treloar is not a troll. Couldn't be further from it
I get the running gag and people love getting stuck into you about it but Treloar was simply going through a form slump and nothing more. Trading him helped you short term but let's see at the end of the year before making calls
He's a jet either way
RD
What scores has Treloar had since he was traded out when he missed that one game?
He's gone alright Doc ;)
What are peoples thoughts on which combo to get?
Rocky + Lynch (GC) or Bont/JPK + Wallis
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 07, 2017, 01:42:45 PM
He's gone alright Doc ;)
What are peoples thoughts on which combo to get?
Rocky + Lynch (GC) or Bont/JPK + Wallis
Quote from: batt on June 07, 2017, 02:10:14 PM
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 07, 2017, 01:42:45 PM
He's gone alright Doc ;)
What are peoples thoughts on which combo to get?
Rocky + Lynch (GC) or Bont/JPK + Wallis
Quote from: batt on June 07, 2017, 02:10:14 PM
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 07, 2017, 01:42:45 PM
He's gone alright Doc ;)
What are peoples thoughts on which combo to get?
Rocky + Lynch (GC) or Bont/JPK + Wallis
+1
Lynch has Hawthorn and Carlton in his next 2, could go huge considering their lack of key, tall defenders atm. Will probably never be cheaper
Quote from: GCSkiwi on June 05, 2017, 01:51:41 PM
Otten -> Schaz
SPP -> Rocky
Turner -> Lynch (GCS)
Sandi confirmed out changes this situation.
Outs: SPP, Myers, Sandi, Ins: Rocky, Cousins, fwd of some description via Nank (still pretty keen on GCLynch)
Quote from: Bluesalltheway on June 07, 2017, 02:20:00 PM
Quote from: batt on June 07, 2017, 02:10:14 PM
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 07, 2017, 01:42:45 PM
He's gone alright Doc ;)
What are peoples thoughts on which combo to get?
Rocky + Lynch (GC) or Bont/JPK + Wallis
+1
Lynch has Hawthorn and Carlton in his next 2, could go huge considering their lack of key, tall defenders atm. Will probably never be cheaper
Thanks guys
Yeah I thought everyone would vote that option. Rocky's durability my only concern
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 07, 2017, 03:17:52 PM
Quote from: Bluesalltheway on June 07, 2017, 02:20:00 PM
Quote from: batt on June 07, 2017, 02:10:14 PM
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 07, 2017, 01:42:45 PM
He's gone alright Doc ;)
What are peoples thoughts on which combo to get?
Rocky + Lynch (GC) or Bont/JPK + Wallis
+1
Lynch has Hawthorn and Carlton in his next 2, could go huge considering their lack of key, tall defenders atm. Will probably never be cheaper
Thanks guys
Yeah I thought everyone would vote that option. Rocky's durability my only concern
How far short are you on Rocky and Wallis RD? I'm basically tossing up the same option, except can afford either Lynch or Wallis along with Rocky... Still leaning towards Lynch tbh, but who knows what will happen by the time I hit the trade button.
I'm about 25k short so can't grab both
I'll have that window between 6:25pm and 7:30pm Thu to make the trades, because if Rocky doesn't return I'll have to pass and grab Bont or JPK instead
Surely Rocky wouldn't get named and then be a late out...
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 07, 2017, 03:39:11 PM
I'm about 25k short so can't grab both
I'll have that window between 6:25pm and 7:30pm Thu to make the trades, because if Rocky doesn't return I'll have to pass and grab Bont or JPK instead
Surely Rocky wouldn't get named and then be a late out...
Wouldn't even surprise me at this point
Quote from: Bluesalltheway on June 07, 2017, 04:14:07 PM
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 07, 2017, 03:39:11 PM
I'm about 25k short so can't grab both
I'll have that window between 6:25pm and 7:30pm Thu to make the trades, because if Rocky doesn't return I'll have to pass and grab Bont or JPK instead
Surely Rocky wouldn't get named and then be a late out...
Wouldn't even surprise me at this point
Hope flowering not :-X
Time for Sandi to go. Can't carry him any longer, especially with two more goose eggs from him.
Sandilands -> Stef Martin
Newman -> Docherty
Spud Myers -> Cousins
Leaves me with 9 trades, 8 after going WHE to Yeo next week, Steele will be rotating between M9/F7 and one more upgrade to be made (S Selwood to his brother or Lachie Neale or Pendles eventually).
Meyers or Mutimer - Cousins?
Everyone getting on Rocky, Is he a must have?
Seriously considering Fyfe >Rocky but feels like a luxury/Sideways trade.
Quote from: WaspMan on June 07, 2017, 08:00:32 PM
Everyone getting on Rocky, Is he a must have?
Seriously considering Fyfe >Rocky but feels like a luxury/Sideways trade.
Depends on your midfield. I don't have him but I am full premo in the mids so I am not trading him in yet.
Fyfe to Rocky is not a smart trade. Need to get to full premo before making sideways trades like that one.
Quote from: AaronKirk on June 07, 2017, 08:03:28 PM
Quote from: WaspMan on June 07, 2017, 08:00:32 PM
Everyone getting on Rocky, Is he a must have?
Seriously considering Fyfe >Rocky but feels like a luxury/Sideways trade.
Depends on your midfield. I don't have him but I am full premo in the mids so I am not trading him in yet.
Fyfe to Rocky is not a smart trade. Need to get to full premo before making sideways trades like that one.
Cheers mate.
Full premo except Scooter with plenty of cash still to make from him so might just cool my jets this week and stick with:
Parsons > Cousins and Newman > Hibberd.
I'm so glad I kept Rocky over his injury...
Otten > Shaz
SPP > Rocky
Sandi > Ryder
Next week
Newman > Lloyd
Fyfe > Docherty via Berry
Then $150k to upgrade Scooter to bottomed out Neale or Bont.
Berry covering defender mids with Shaz, Greenwood covering forwards and Ryder/Nank covering rucks.
Not sure what to do with Team and Sandi will be 9 trades left, at round 14 7 trades and need Doc to finish premo team.
before trades team
Adams, Laird, Harbrow, Otten, Newman, Scharenberg (evw, stewart)
danger, pendles, murphy, steele, fyfe, beams, jpk, dusty (mcgrath, myers, bolton)
stef, sandi,strndica
dahl, macrae, Tlynch (gcs), higgins, nank, ryder,( greenwood parsons)
option 1 keep sandi 40k balance newman/shaz/stewart/ryan d5-8, myers m10 , Steele f7/m9 ryder [/size]
OUT McGrath ($368,200)INBontempelli ($553,600)
OUT Vickers-Willis ($268,100)INRyan ($117,300)
OUT Otten ($376,200)INHibberd ($472,800)
option 2 trade sandli get 100k bank stewart/evw d7/8, mcgrath m9/d7 next week, evw>ryan, stewart>lloyd or hold stewart-lloyd until round 14. ryder becomes r2, steele f6
OUT Myers ($214,300) INBontempelli ($553,600)
OUT Sandilands ($464,700) INCousins ($102,400)
OUT Otten ($376,200) INHibberd ($472,800)
i might go sandi>goldy next week
Quote from: crowls on June 07, 2017, 09:49:11 PM
Not sure what to do with Team and Sandi will be 9 trades left, at round 14 7 trades and need Doc to finish premo team.
before trades team
Adams, Laird, Harbrow, Hibberd, Newman, Scharenberg (evw, stewart)
danger, pendles, murphy, steele, fyfe, beams, jpk, dusty (mcgrath, cousins, bolton)
stef, sandi,strndica
dahl, macrae, Tlynch (gcs), higgins, nank, ryder,( greenwood parsons)
option 1 keep sandi 40k balance newman/shaz/stewart/ryan d5-8, myers m10 , Steele f7/m9 ryder [/size]
OUT McGrath ($368,200)INBontempelli ($553,600)
OUT Vickers-Willis ($268,100)INRyan ($117,300)
OUT Otten ($376,200)INHibberd ($472,800)
option 2 trade sandli get 100k bank stewart/evw d7/8, mcgrath m9/d7 next week, evw>ryan, stewart>lloyd or hold stewart-lloyd until round 14. ryder becomes r2, steele f6
OUT Myers ($214,300) INBontempelli ($553,600)
OUT Sandilands ($464,700) INCousins ($102,400)
OUT Otten ($376,200) INHibberd ($472,800)
Your killing me crowls - before trades team already has Hibberd and Cousins in it ;D assuming it doesn't poleaxe your bye situation, option 2 for me. Wouldn't be bringing Ryan in early, and you clear out 3 round 13 bye players, can reassess if you wan to make the evw-ryan swap next week, you'll know how it affects your team on the park, and it won't cost you anything to hold andd see how ryan goes this week.
Otten - Scharenberg
Parson - Lynch
Myers - Cousins
Leaves me with 19 starters this round and 18 next round
Taranto. Myers. Otten. > Rocky. Cousins. Roberton.
Lloyd in a week or two when's he's bottomed out.
Sandi --> T Lynch
WHE --> Macrae
Myers --> Cousins
(320k in the bank to complete my team next week 8))
Shaw --> Roberton
Stewart --> Ryan
Sandi --> Yeo via Nank DPP
Then when Gawn is back Greenwood to Gawn and team is complete
Quote from: brudski on June 08, 2017, 10:23:45 AM
Shaw --> Roberton
Stewart --> Ryan
Sandi --> Yeo via Nank DPP
Then when Gawn is back Greenwood to Gawn and team is complete
Wouldn't be trading Heath Shaw?
I wouldn't be trading in Ryan before his bye?
Wouldn't be trading in Yeo when he has his bye?
:-\
SPP-Cousins
Otten-Doc
Sandi-GC Lynch
Quote from: essendon2 on June 08, 2017, 10:34:16 AM
Quote from: brudski on June 08, 2017, 10:23:45 AM
Shaw --> Roberton
Stewart --> Ryan
Sandi --> Yeo via Nank DPP
Then when Gawn is back Greenwood to Gawn and team is complete
Wouldn't be trading Heath Shaw?
I wouldn't be trading in Ryan before his bye?
Wouldn't be trading in Yeo when he has his bye?
:-\
Shaw is a luxary trade his cost me two rounds already and i have the cash to go to roberton
I didn't realise ryan's bye was next week thought it was this week have to reassess on that one
Doesn't matter if Yeo has his bye if sandi is out this week (which he most likely will be) and i trade him to Yeo i'll be a game better off because Yeo will play next week and sandi won't because of his bye
My overall is already shot so l'm just focusing on leagues now and trying to get my team in order for the run home after byes so i don't focus on byes to much. If i was in the running for overall then it is a completely different story
Boy the FF love for Rocky is crazy. I get it, but the same people who didn't pick him up at the start of the season for durability issues are the same ones that are advocating for him now! I remember 2015 when Daisy, Jobe and Beams all did their shoulders within a month of each other. All 3 came back, but the only one that made it to the final round was Beams who caused endless "will he, won't he" headaches.
Quote from: H1bb3i2d on June 08, 2017, 11:14:06 AM
Boy the FF love for Rocky is crazy. I get it, but the same people who didn't pick him up at the start of the season for durability issues are the same ones that are advocating for him now! I remember 2015 when Daisy, Jobe and Beams all did their shoulders within a month of each other. All 3 came back, but the only one that made it to the final round was Beams who caused endless "will he, won't he" headaches.
Rocky's a different specimen. I reckon he'd play with one arm if the doc would let him.
Quote from: GCSkiwi on June 08, 2017, 06:56:21 AM
Quote from: crowls on June 07, 2017, 09:49:11 PM
Not sure what to do with Team and Sandi will be 9 trades left, at round 14 7 trades and need Doc to finish premo team.
before trades team
Adams, Laird, Harbrow, Hibberd, Newman, Scharenberg (evw, stewart)
danger, pendles, murphy, steele, fyfe, beams, jpk, dusty (mcgrath, cousins, bolton)
stef, sandi,strndica
dahl, macrae, Tlynch (gcs), higgins, nank, ryder,( greenwood parsons)
option 1 keep sandi 40k balance newman/shaz/stewart/ryan d5-8, myers m10 , Steele f7/m9 ryder [/size]
OUT McGrath ($368,200)INBontempelli ($553,600)
OUT Vickers-Willis ($268,100)INRyan ($117,300)
OUT Otten ($376,200)INHibberd ($472,800)
option 2 trade sandli get 100k bank stewart/evw d7/8, mcgrath m9/d7 next week, evw>ryan, stewart>lloyd or hold stewart-lloyd until round 14. ryder becomes r2, steele f6
OUT Myers ($214,300) INBontempelli ($553,600)
OUT Sandilands ($464,700) INCousins ($102,400)
OUT Otten ($376,200) INHibberd ($472,800)
Your killing me crowls - before trades team already has Hibberd and Cousins in it ;D assuming it doesn't poleaxe your bye situation, option 2 for me. Wouldn't be bringing Ryan in early, and you clear out 3 round 13 bye players, can reassess if you wan to make the evw-ryan swap next week, you'll know how it affects your team on the park, and it won't cost you anything to hold andd see how ryan goes this week.
Kiwi, sorry mate. Explains why I am struggling this season. Making this sort of mistake almost everyweek. Mind is not on the job. (imagine how my boss must feel).
Thanks for the feedback. Getting rid of Sandi and bring in Cousins leave R13 with 21 players and 20 on the park 16 prems. Will hold off on Ryan until after his bye and then do stewart/evw to ryan/doc. 7 trades left and completed team. Weaknesses of Steele at F6, Stef/Ryder R1/R2. A bit closer to finals can look at upgrading them. Just focus on winning my cash league and see if I can get overall back to top 3K.
Think my team looks ok on paper, just not executing trades at the right times and made some dud moves costing points.
Quote from: H1bb3i2d on June 08, 2017, 11:14:06 AM
Boy the FF love for Rocky is crazy. I get it, but the same people who didn't pick him up at the start of the season for durability issues are the same ones that are advocating for him now! I remember 2015 when Daisy, Jobe and Beams all did their shoulders within a month of each other. All 3 came back, but the only one that made it to the final round was Beams who caused endless "will he, won't he" headaches.
Yep a lot jumping on him I am considering him for my last mid spot but am wary of his shoulder , if it were to pop again seeing there season is shot would they just send him off for surgery if it is needed ? and get him right for next year think I will hold off for a bit.
Supercoach is such a tough caper.
Weighing up between Heeney/Franklin/Wallis, as well as is Rocky too risky to bring in. On top of is 3 premos from one team too many.
Could Sandilands > Sam Jacobs be on the cards instead of Wallis/Franklin/Heeney? Allows me to get Yeo as a forward next week instead? Thoughts please.
Jacobs has only had 2 scores under 80 for the year.
Original trades I had planned
Powell Pepper > Rocky
Sandi > Franklin
Newman > Cousins
Current trades
T. Steward > Dylan Roberton
Sandi > Jacobs
Newman > Cousins
Original trades leaves Scott Selwood as M9 after the byes, gives me 3 Sydney premos. Current trades leaves me with max 2 premos from each team, and allows me to bring in Yeo next week.
Quote from: miamis_finest on June 08, 2017, 03:24:59 PM
Could Sandilands > Sam Jacobs be on the cards instead of Wallis/Franklin/Heeney? Allows me to get Yeo as a forward next week instead? Thoughts please.
Jacobs has only had 2 scores under 80 for the year.
Original trades I had planned
Powell Pepper > Rocky
Sandi > Franklin
Newman > Cousins
Current trades
T. Steward > Dylan Roberton
Sandi > Jacobs
Newman > Cousins
Original trades leaves Scott Selwood as M9 after the byes, gives me 3 Sydney premos. Current trades leaves me with max 2 premos from each team, and allows me to bring in Yeo next week.
With Jacobs bye next week, I wouldn't be bringing him in yet.
Myer to Cousins
Newman to Roberton.
Can afford Doc but cannot bring myself to spend 600k on a defender, especially compared to Bont being so cheap next week, don't like Hibberd (previous burn issues) and don't like any other round 11 bye defenders....
Quote from: jvalles69 on June 08, 2017, 04:42:56 PM
Quote from: miamis_finest on June 08, 2017, 03:24:59 PM
Could Sandilands > Sam Jacobs be on the cards instead of Wallis/Franklin/Heeney? Allows me to get Yeo as a forward next week instead? Thoughts please.
Jacobs has only had 2 scores under 80 for the year.
Original trades I had planned
Powell Pepper > Rocky
Sandi > Franklin
Newman > Cousins
Current trades
T. Steward > Dylan Roberton
Sandi > Jacobs
Newman > Cousins
Original trades leaves Scott Selwood as M9 after the byes, gives me 3 Sydney premos. Current trades leaves me with max 2 premos from each team, and allows me to bring in Yeo next week.
With Jacobs bye next week, I wouldn't be bringing him in yet.
Damn massive oversight by me. Back to the drawing board, was convinced he had already had the bye. Is Kreuzer scrapping the bottom of the barrel? Nice average but injury history is worrying.
Quote from: miamis_finest on June 08, 2017, 04:51:27 PM
Quote from: jvalles69 on June 08, 2017, 04:42:56 PM
Quote from: miamis_finest on June 08, 2017, 03:24:59 PM
Could Sandilands > Sam Jacobs be on the cards instead of Wallis/Franklin/Heeney? Allows me to get Yeo as a forward next week instead? Thoughts please.
Jacobs has only had 2 scores under 80 for the year.
Original trades I had planned
Powell Pepper > Rocky
Sandi > Franklin
Newman > Cousins
Current trades
T. Steward > Dylan Roberton
Sandi > Jacobs
Newman > Cousins
Original trades leaves Scott Selwood as M9 after the byes, gives me 3 Sydney premos. Current trades leaves me with max 2 premos from each team, and allows me to bring in Yeo next week.
With Jacobs bye next week, I wouldn't be bringing him in yet.
Damn massive oversight by me. Back to the drawing board, was convinced he had already had the bye. Is Kreuzer scrapping the bottom of the barrel? Nice average but injury history is worrying.
Haha, I've burned into my mind which weeks each team has their bye round...don't even need bye planner, lol!
Shaw - Doch
or
Fyfe - Rocky?
Quote from: TomK on June 08, 2017, 05:05:42 PM
Shaw - Doch
or
Fyfe - Rocky?
No to both. But if it's a necessity, probably the 2nd one.
Quote from: TomK on June 08, 2017, 05:05:42 PM
Shaw - Doch
or
Fyfe - Rocky?
Depends on the rest of your team, but I'd refrain from both, if I had to choose Fyfe to Rocky.
Quote from: miamis_finest on June 08, 2017, 05:09:19 PM
Quote from: TomK on June 08, 2017, 05:05:42 PM
Shaw - Doch
or
Fyfe - Rocky?
No to both. But if it's a necessity, probably the 2nd one.
Quote from: jvalles69 on June 08, 2017, 05:09:45 PM
Depends on the rest of your team, but I'd refrain from both, if I had to choose Fyfe to Rocky.
It's not a necessity, it helps my side out a lot next week (19 atm, would like 20) and I can probably afford to make a luxury trade. Without doing the trade, after RD14 I should have 9 trades left with Witts R2, SSelwood M8, Shaw D6/Fyfe M7 and still around 200k in the bank.
Making me second guess now though haha :P
Need to bring in Cousins.
Do I get rid of Taranto, Barett, Myers or Parsons?
Myers - Cousins
Stewart - Robertson
Happy i held onto Newman and will trade Sandi - Yeo next week completing my team with 11 trades left! :)
Quote from: oh_lol on June 08, 2017, 07:38:19 PM
Need to bring in Cousins.
Do I get rid of Taranto, Barett, Myers or Parsons?
Myers
-Taranto still scoring well
-Barrett just had his bye (however ive already got rid of him)
-and id rather keep parsons due to bye structure
Thinking:
Sandi to Rocky (via Nank to ruck and Greenwood fwd)
Fisher to Cousins
Next week Fyfe to Docherty (Hibberd to mids)
Uneasy about sideways trade of Fyfe however...
Wingard, lynch or Greene?
Quote from: backpocket on June 09, 2017, 01:37:02 PM
Wingard, lynch or Greene?
Personally I like Lynch out of those options
I want to bring in Rockliff and Hibberd this week but to do so I need to move on Berry (who i think is going to struggle with Rocky and Beams back), Powell-Pepper (not sure i should), and Myers (too early to move on him?) plus bring in Cousins the week before his bye (risky for a rookie?).
So it would be Berry, SPP, Myers out. Hibberd, Rocky, Cousins in. Leaves me one defender short of a full team (aside from my weak rucks of Witts, Sandi, Nank) with 12 trades left and Newman at d6.
Also leaves me with only 18 next week assuming Harbrow is back and I'd rather be in a safer position than that. I need midfield rookies that are going to be playing next week...
Now Ainsworth is in I'm thinking of getting rid of Eddy for him. Already got Cousins. Or is there a fwrd debuting like Beech who would be a better option? Thoughts?
Quote from: Hogan17 on June 09, 2017, 03:18:51 PM
Now Ainsworth is in I'm thinking of getting rid of Eddy for him. Already got Cousins. Or is there a fwrd debuting like Beech who would be a better option? Thoughts?
I'm thinking Ainsworth too.
Sandi > Ainsworth
SPP > Rocky
Otten > Docherty
Ainsworth and Greenwood to chill out at F6 until Gawn is ready to come in.
Quote from: LaHug on June 09, 2017, 03:12:48 PM
I want to bring in Rockliff and Hibberd this week but to do so I need to move on Berry (who i think is going to struggle with Rocky and Beams back), Powell-Pepper (not sure i should), and Myers (too early to move on him?) plus bring in Cousins the week before his bye (risky for a rookie?).
So it would be Berry, SPP, Myers out. Hibberd, Rocky, Cousins in. Leaves me one defender short of a full team (aside from my weak rucks of Witts, Sandi, Nank) with 12 trades left and Newman at d6.
Also leaves me with only 18 next week assuming Harbrow is back and I'd rather be in a safer position than that. I need midfield rookies that are going to be playing next week...
I bit the bullet and went Harbrow to Hibberd did not cost a lot.
Quote from: Ringo on June 09, 2017, 03:45:47 PM
Quote from: LaHug on June 09, 2017, 03:12:48 PM
I want to bring in Rockliff and Hibberd this week but to do so I need to move on Berry (who i think is going to struggle with Rocky and Beams back), Powell-Pepper (not sure i should), and Myers (too early to move on him?) plus bring in Cousins the week before his bye (risky for a rookie?).
So it would be Berry, SPP, Myers out. Hibberd, Rocky, Cousins in. Leaves me one defender short of a full team (aside from my weak rucks of Witts, Sandi, Nank) with 12 trades left and Newman at d6.
Also leaves me with only 18 next week assuming Harbrow is back and I'd rather be in a safer position than that. I need midfield rookies that are going to be playing next week...
I bit the bullet and went Harbrow to Hibberd did not cost a lot.
I brought Harbrow in two weeks ago to help me with round 11 and 13...
$360k in the bank. Thinking:
Barret, Myers, Otten out for Rocky, Hibberd, Cousins.
Leaves me $65k in the bank, 14 trades left.
Mids: Danger, JPK, Bont, Treloar, Cripps, Fyfe and Scooter to upgrade in a cple of weeks, most likely to Jelwood or Kelly.
Backs: Adams, Laird, Doch, Roberton, with Otten culled this week and Marchbank next week for Lloyd. Newman to keep making $ and decent cover if keeps playing
Thoughts?
Now that Llyod has been dropped, does he go for Cousins?
Or not worth it?
I'm holding Sandi since my trades are a mess. I can't afford to start making sideways trades. I'm thinking the following
Otten>Schaz
SPP>Lockliff
Barrett>Tom Lynch (either of them).
Quote from: LaHug on June 09, 2017, 03:51:57 PM
Quote from: Ringo on June 09, 2017, 03:45:47 PM
Quote from: LaHug on June 09, 2017, 03:12:48 PM
I want to bring in Rockliff and Hibberd this week but to do so I need to move on Berry (who i think is going to struggle with Rocky and Beams back), Powell-Pepper (not sure i should), and Myers (too early to move on him?) plus bring in Cousins the week before his bye (risky for a rookie?).
So it would be Berry, SPP, Myers out. Hibberd, Rocky, Cousins in. Leaves me one defender short of a full team (aside from my weak rucks of Witts, Sandi, Nank) with 12 trades left and Newman at d6.
Also leaves me with only 18 next week assuming Harbrow is back and I'd rather be in a safer position than that. I need midfield rookies that are going to be playing next week...
I bit the bullet and went Harbrow to Hibberd did not cost a lot.
I brought Harbrow in two weeks ago to help me with round 11 and 13...
did the same, harbrow didnt get the memo...
Quote from: Hazza09 on June 09, 2017, 07:31:49 PM
Now that Llyod has been dropped, does he go for Cousins?
Or not worth it?
Thinking the same. He has only made 55 k tho. But if hes not playing what's the use of keeping him?
Trade Fisher or Myers for cousins? Feel like I should trade Fisher because of the bye next week but Myers has better JS in my eyes. Thoughts?
Quote from: GoSaints3 on June 10, 2017, 10:41:41 AM
Trade Fisher or Myers for cousins? Feel like I should trade Fisher because of the bye next week but Myers has better JS in my eyes. Thoughts?
If you're ok for the rd 13 bye I'd trade Fisher. IMO Myers will start knocking out some good scores
Quote from: King_Robbo on June 10, 2017, 11:02:10 AM
Quote from: GoSaints3 on June 10, 2017, 10:41:41 AM
Trade Fisher or Myers for cousins? Feel like I should trade Fisher because of the bye next week but Myers has better JS in my eyes. Thoughts?
If you're ok for the rd 13 bye I'd trade Fisher. IMO Myers will start knocking out some good scores
Thanks mate
Quote from: King_Robbo on June 10, 2017, 11:02:10 AM
Quote from: GoSaints3 on June 10, 2017, 10:41:41 AM
Trade Fisher or Myers for cousins? Feel like I should trade Fisher because of the bye next week but Myers has better JS in my eyes. Thoughts?
If you're ok for the rd 13 bye I'd trade Fisher. IMO Myers will start knocking out some good scores
Was going to get rid of Myers for Cousins but Lloyd had to go as I only had 18 this week. Was still able to pick up Hibberd to give me one more premo to upgrade in def.
Ended up doing:
Myers to Cousins
Otten to Docherty
D SWallow to Rockliff (I have had Swallow sine I traded O'Meara to him in Rd 3 and he has done his job)
Quote from: Ringo on June 10, 2017, 12:24:42 PM
Ended up doing:
Myers to Cousins
Otten to Docherty
D SWallow to Rockliff (I have had Swallow sine I traded O'Meara to him in Rd 3 and he has done his job)
Wow you have patience holding onto Swallow. Personal I don't think raising $80k at an average of 77 is 'doing his job'
Myers to Cousins
Caddy to Lynch (GC)
for me this week.
10 trades remaining for the season :O
(I still have Swallow ;) )
Quote from: King_Robbo on June 10, 2017, 01:01:20 PM
Quote from: Ringo on June 10, 2017, 12:24:42 PM
Ended up doing:
Myers to Cousins
Otten to Docherty
D SWallow to Rockliff (I have had Swallow sine I traded O'Meara to him in Rd 3 and he has done his job)
Wow you have patience holding onto Swallow. Personal I don't think raising $80k at an average of 77 is 'doing his job'
Was always my plan to upgrade to a prem during the byes and Rocky will not get any cheaper. Offsetting the 80k cash gain.
:-\
After wearing out the Trades Reverse button Finally settled on OUT T Stewart, J Berry, SPP
IN Cousins, Hibberd, Docherty.
Still have more problems than trades but it wouldn't be SC if that wasn't the case. Cheers all.
:)
Devastated I reversed my Ablett trade and went with JPK, devastated... :'( :'( :'( :'( :'(
Whoever went Ablett. Well done.
My brother in law pulled the trigger and he's sitting 750th overall. I'm around 450th. I think he might pip me at the line now with that move.