Shaw laird TMac Mcgrath keefe berry (Ryan Stewart)
Danger Pendles Ablett Kennedy rocky Fyfe pepper Myers (freeman drew graham)
Gawn sandi ( 102k)
Dahl macrae Ryder mcgluggage Ainsworth Pickett (Rioli eddy)
$400
Think this is pretty solid
Opinions ????
Looks good to me, Ablett & Rocky will be genuine POD's in the midfield. In my second version I've gone with a similar structure but with fallen premos in the midfield and no high priced rookies. That would effectively mean your SPP & Myers would be up against my Murphy & Swallow.
Yeah solid.
Ryder nice insurance for Sandi. Lots of top end rookies allow wriggle room.
looks pretty good. The only thing I'd say to consider is do you think having 6 premium mids is 1 too many - having 3 rooks in defence is a definite gamble and one I've been toying over myself. Personally I think 5 premiums in the mids would afford a better and more complete team by allowing a settled fwd or back line or both... just advice only! :)
Quote from: Bluesman on January 29, 2017, 06:58:23 PM
looks pretty good. The only thing I'd say to consider is do you think having 6 premium mids is 1 too many - having 3 rooks in defence is a definite gamble and one I've been toying over myself. Personally I think 5 premiums in the mids would afford a better and more complete team by allowing a settled fwd or back line or both... just advice only! :)
i see your point but there seems to be a quite a few rookie options down back although it is still early days and we dont know how many will actually play. will just have to wait and see how they go in JLT and more importantly how many start round 1
I like your team only thing I would do is downgrade 1 prem mid into a mid pricers and upgrade one of your back rooks to a defenders mid pricers.
McGrath, Louge, Hampton, Scharenberg, Keefe, Berry, Ryan, Stewart
No need to be worried about 5 spots to fill in. I personally have McGrath at D3 as I'm confident that there will be plenty of sub 200k players to choose from.
Very nice side. No need to worry about your "weak" defence.
Fair few changes to this. I haven't updated my team on here recently but it did have docherty for a while now and I am really bummed to leave him out. Here it is
Montagna rance laird Hampton Stewart Ryan (vickers Newman)
Dangerfield Kennedy rocky Fyfe Mitchell omeara Ellisyolmen swallow (pepper Myers parfitt)
Gawn goldy(102k)
Dahl Heeney roughy mcgluggage bowes black (Cameron eddy)
2.1k
Quote from: Money Shot on January 30, 2017, 06:48:36 PM
McGrath, Louge, Hampton, Scharenberg, Keefe, Berry, Ryan, Stewart
No need to be worried about 5 spots to fill in. I personally have McGrath at D3 as I'm confident that there will be plenty of sub 200k players to choose from.
Very nice side. No need to worry about your "weak" defence.
^ this exactly. downgrade a defender and get in Goldstien. I have just Shaw and Adams myself.
I have goldy ?
haha oops so you do! My bad. Another premo mid as an upgrade instead then. Montagna>Keefe then Ellis-Yolmen>any top mid, as an idea.
Laird mills Hampton hibberd viziers Newman (Ryan Stewart)
Danger rocky Fyfe Mitchell viney beams omeara swallow (foote pepper wigg)
Gawn sandi (Str)
Riewoldt dahl Lycett Heeney Roughead glugg (black eddy)
Backed $$$ on Riewoldt and viney for the Brownlow so I wanna support the lads in my sc team as well. They aren't bad picks in any case and just have a gut feel.
Light defense but I actually had Jackson thurlow/marchbank at d2 just before posting this and still might go down that path or pick both. Mills won't go backwards and he has the upside chance of possible midfield time. Not convinced hibberd will play so that could cause a restructure. Although there still is otten.
Pretty much a locked midfield. Other than foote and wigg who just placeholding.
Rucks
Heavier forwards. Lycett is plays jlt3 will be the best ruck cover n will be fine for f5-f7.
Thoughts ????
Lycett over Ryder & Nank? Be interested to hear your reasoning.
Quote from: Bully on March 02, 2017, 12:54:29 PM
Lycett over Ryder & Nank? Be interested to hear your reasoning.
Id take lycett over nank for sure, dont know about ryder. had quite a few good games once nic nat went down last year. should be able to average 85-95. if put ryder in that scoring range too and nank more 75-85
Quote from: uncleswagy on March 02, 2017, 08:10:08 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 02, 2017, 12:54:29 PM
Lycett over Ryder & Nank? Be interested to hear your reasoning.
Id take lycett over nank for sure, dont know about ryder. had quite a few good games once nic nat went down last year. should be able to average 85-95. if put ryder in that scoring range too and nank more 75-85
I think Nank will score higher if he stays R.1 for Richmond and has more upside than Lycett and Ryder. But that is just my opinion and time will tell.
Quote from: Sabretooth Tigers on March 05, 2017, 01:28:51 PM
Quote from: uncleswagy on March 02, 2017, 08:10:08 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 02, 2017, 12:54:29 PM
Lycett over Ryder & Nank? Be interested to hear your reasoning.
Id take lycett over nank for sure, dont know about ryder. had quite a few good games once nic nat went down last year. should be able to average 85-95. if put ryder in that scoring range too and nank more 75-85
I think Nank will score higher if he stays R.1 for Richmond and has more upside than Lycett and Ryder. But that is just my opinion and time will tell.
Lycett will definitely score higher than nank. 1 has experience and coordination and one doesn't . That being sad I won't picking if doesn't play next week
Note my previous comment has been obliterated by what I have seen today from nankervis.
That was impressive and given his price and the fact he will wil sole ruck it's a no brainer for me.
I'm over worrying about the forward rookies. So I'm not starting any in this team and if one pops up then we will see.
Super light defense!
Laird thurlow marchbank Hampton vickers Stewart (hibberd often)
Danger rocky fyfe Mitchell Steven beams omeara swallow(pepper wigg Barrett)
nankervis sandi(Cameron)
Riewoldt Dahl macrae lycett heeney roughy (black eddy)
Big changes to my side.
Had thurlow a week ago at d2 and I saw enough today to risk it. Is best 22 will make cash and will score 80ish I think.
Marchbank playing SuperCoach friendly role.
Jack Steven - reckon he can extend himself in a better st Kilda side that looks daring. He runs so hard (have had him shuey viney wines and even Kelly through this position)
Nankervis sandi. Cheap spend that I see combining for 180+ a week. Potentially losing 40+points a week of Gawn goldy but that cost is $600k more. I think I can make up for it else where.
Lycett though my concerns for this him playing round 1 grow is up front for cover. Whichever looks the better keep out of lycett and nankervis I will keep with the other planned to get to a declining Gawn hopefully asap.
It's a yolo team.
Re: Thoughts on C.Mills at D3?
Quote from: eaglesman on Yesterday at 03:15:45 PM
Well mills is my d2 and take it this to the bank he is 100% starting in my side this season.
You should always be 110% sure with these things =)
Quote from: Kenny27 on March 06, 2017, 12:49:23 AM
Re: Thoughts on C.Mills at D3?
Quote from: eaglesman on Yesterday at 03:15:45 PM
Well mills is my d2 and take it this to the bank he is 100% starting in my side this season.
You should always be 110% sure with these things =)
I'm trying my best to get him back haha
Quote from: eaglesman on March 06, 2017, 12:58:31 AM
Quote from: Kenny27 on March 06, 2017, 12:49:23 AM
Re: Thoughts on C.Mills at D3?
Quote from: eaglesman on Yesterday at 03:15:45 PM
Well mills is my d2 and take it this to the bank he is 100% starting in my side this season.
You should always be 110% sure with these things =)
I'm trying my best to get him back haha
Know how you feel I keep rotating him in and out with Adams but don't have the guts to pull the trigger. Do you really think Roo is worth his starting price? what do you see him averaging this year
That's actually not a bad team hahaha, I don't mind it at all.
Could argue you already have 6 forward keepers, and the 3 highest scoring ones most likely too.
If I'm comparing teams
Thurlow (80) v Adams (100)
Mitchell (105) v Treloar (110)
Steven (105) v Sloane (110)
NRoo (95) v Gunston (95)
Macrae (95) v Higgins (90)
Lycett (90) v Goldy (110)
Heeney (90) v Schoey (60)
Still think I come out on top but I don't mind the idea mate.
Quote from: Kenny27 on March 06, 2017, 01:06:43 AM
Quote from: eaglesman on March 06, 2017, 12:58:31 AM
Quote from: Kenny27 on March 06, 2017, 12:49:23 AM
Re: Thoughts on C.Mills at D3?
Quote from: eaglesman on Yesterday at 03:15:45 PM
Well mills is my d2 and take it this to the bank he is 100% starting in my side this season.
You should always be 110% sure with these things =)
I'm trying my best to get him back haha
Know how you feel I keep rotating him in and out with Adams but don't have the guts to pull the trigger. Do you really think Roo is worth his starting price? what do you see him averaging this year
I think roo will be the highest scoring forward this season. Expecting a monster year to be honest.
Which Mitchell is that, Sam or Tom ?
Quote from: eaglesman on March 06, 2017, 01:53:27 AM
Quote from: Kenny27 on March 06, 2017, 01:06:43 AM
Quote from: eaglesman on March 06, 2017, 12:58:31 AM
Quote from: Kenny27 on March 06, 2017, 12:49:23 AM
Re: Thoughts on C.Mills at D3?
Quote from: eaglesman on Yesterday at 03:15:45 PM
Well mills is my d2 and take it this to the bank he is 100% starting in my side this season.
You should always be 110% sure with these things =)
I'm trying my best to get him back haha
Know how you feel I keep rotating him in and out with Adams but don't have the guts to pull the trigger. Do you really think Roo is worth his starting price? what do you see him averaging this year
I think roo will be the highest scoring forward this season. Expecting a monster year to be honest.
Ssh!!!!! :-)
Quote from: Grufflez on March 06, 2017, 09:58:54 AM
Which Mitchell is that, Sam or Tom ?
Titch-who will comfortably go 110 this season
Quote from: eaglesman on March 06, 2017, 12:02:45 PM
Quote from: Grufflez on March 06, 2017, 09:58:54 AM
Which Mitchell is that, Sam or Tom ?
Titch-who will comfortably go 110 this season
Yeah i didn't want to start him but i can't have others getting that value over me as i agree 110 is more likely than not.
Just out of curiosity what are your thoughts on Sam this year, Is the move going to benefit his own scores more or mainly Shuey & Gaffs?
Quote from: Grufflez on March 06, 2017, 08:43:38 PM
Quote from: eaglesman on March 06, 2017, 12:02:45 PM
Quote from: Grufflez on March 06, 2017, 09:58:54 AM
Which Mitchell is that, Sam or Tom ?
Titch-who will comfortably go 110 this season
Yeah i didn't want to start him but i can't have others getting that value over me as i agree 110 is more likely than not.
Just out of curiosity what are your thoughts on Sam this year, Is the move going to benefit his own scores more or mainly Shuey & Gaffs?
Sam is going to make shuey into a superstar of the comp I think. We regard him highly over here but I don't think he gets the national recognition. Won't surprise me to see him push for all Australian this year.
Def: No tom Stewart will he play? had hamstring tightness on weekend Going to be prepared thatvhebwont at this stage
I think Lloyd and his mid/def link could prove handy.
Mids: pretty standard. Barrett is placeholder or teia miles Hibberd hopefully plays opens up the def/mid link with Adams and Lloyd. Likewise with Pickett and his mid/fwd link.
Rucks. Obviously risky but witts will rookie priced will play. Early upgrade required
Forwards pretty standard no real surprises. If miles plays I will pick him
Innplace of Taranto and go back
To Taranto if the witts experiment fails
I really think This is well rounded team and prepared for carnage.
Shaw laird Adams Lloyd marchbank hampton (otten vickers)
Danger rocky Fyfe Mitchell beams omeara spp Barrett (hibberd Pickett parfitt)
Sandi witts (Str)
Nroo Dahl buddy roughy nank Taranto (eddy black)
31k
Would love the communities thoughts?
one move you could do is Llyod down to Thurlow and then do a black up to swallow.
Thurlow pretty much locked in 22 so doesnt make your backline any riskier (just hurts scoring) but then you make your mid alot more solid and hopefully make the points back up playing Swallow in the mid
This is my team now.
Shaw laird jones marchbank Hampton otten (Stewart hibberd)
Danger jpk Treloar fyfe Mitchell beams omeara taranto (pepper parfitt Barrett)
Gawn Sandilands 102
Riewoldt Dahl nank Steele Bowes Simpkin (eddy Pickett)
11k
I have to have 2 trades next week so corrective trades need to be done now. I really have no idea what I should do with my team so I'm hoping you guys can lend me some
Assistance please. Cheers guys
Do you want to hold Riewoldt?
Quote from: Bully on March 28, 2017, 07:16:01 PM
Do you want to hold Riewoldt?
I'm going for overall. But I am not sure whether to hold or not. still
Need further injury updates I feel
Quote from: eaglesman on March 28, 2017, 08:29:30 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 28, 2017, 07:16:01 PM
Do you want to hold Riewoldt?
I'm going for overall. But I am not sure whether to hold or not. still
Need further injury updates I feel
Hyper extending a knee requires daily assessments, 2 weeks minimum one would think, could be more but that's the risk you take. With an older player St Kilda may want to err on the side of caution so perhaps it's better to trade. You could always use this as an opportunity to restructure. Riewoldt to Higgins and leave some $$ up the sleeve for next week.
Quote from: Bully on March 28, 2017, 08:43:59 PM
Quote from: eaglesman on March 28, 2017, 08:29:30 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 28, 2017, 07:16:01 PM
Do you want to hold Riewoldt?
I'm going for overall. But I am not sure whether to hold or not. still
Need further injury updates I feel
Hyper extending a knee requires daily assessments, 2 weeks minimum one would think, could be more but that's the risk you take. With an older player St Kilda may want to err on the side of caution so perhaps it's better to trade. You could always use this as an opportunity to restructure. Riewoldt to Higgins and leave some $$ up the sleeve for next week.
What do you think of reading Riewoldt to Adams via dpp ... I got that suggestion from a loyal user and I think it is a great idea.
The other trade however I'm considering is Simpkin to Hannan/butler. Just feel like I need to use both trades this week so I have the 2 free next week- then get sit tight.
Quote from: eaglesman on March 28, 2017, 11:34:44 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 28, 2017, 08:43:59 PM
Quote from: eaglesman on March 28, 2017, 08:29:30 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 28, 2017, 07:16:01 PM
Do you want to hold Riewoldt?
I'm going for overall. But I am not sure whether to hold or not. still
Need further injury updates I feel
Hyper extending a knee requires daily assessments, 2 weeks minimum one would think, could be more but that's the risk you take. With an older player St Kilda may want to err on the side of caution so perhaps it's better to trade. You could always use this as an opportunity to restructure. Riewoldt to Higgins and leave some $$ up the sleeve for next week.
What do you think of reading Riewoldt to Adams via dpp ... I got that suggestion from a loyal user and I think it is a great idea.
The other trade however I'm considering is Simpkin to Hannan/butler. Just feel like I need to use both trades this week so I have the 2 free next week- then get sit tight.
So you're going to rely on 3 rookies in the forward line?
Quote from: Bully on March 28, 2017, 11:59:27 PM
Quote from: eaglesman on March 28, 2017, 11:34:44 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 28, 2017, 08:43:59 PM
Quote from: eaglesman on March 28, 2017, 08:29:30 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 28, 2017, 07:16:01 PM
Do you want to hold Riewoldt?
I'm going for overall. But I am not sure whether to hold or not. still
Need further injury updates I feel
Hyper extending a knee requires daily assessments, 2 weeks minimum one would think, could be more but that's the risk you take. With an older player St Kilda may want to err on the side of caution so perhaps it's better to trade. You could always use this as an opportunity to restructure. Riewoldt to Higgins and leave some $$ up the sleeve for next week.
What do you think of reading Riewoldt to Adams via dpp ... I got that suggestion from a loyal user and I think it is a great idea.
The other trade however I'm considering is Simpkin to Hannan/butler. Just feel like I need to use both trades this week so I have the 2 free next week- then get sit tight.
So you're going to rely on 3 rookies in the forward line?
If I rely on 3 rookies in the forward line it's one less rookie to worry about in def. don't think it makes much difference to be honest. And we have more flexibility for forward cover via dpp.
I was thinking a Nick to a Macrae or Caddy and then you can etiher keep the money or use it to upgrade another position.
Quote from: eaglesman on March 29, 2017, 09:41:41 AM
Quote from: Bully on March 28, 2017, 11:59:27 PM
Quote from: eaglesman on March 28, 2017, 11:34:44 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 28, 2017, 08:43:59 PM
Quote from: eaglesman on March 28, 2017, 08:29:30 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 28, 2017, 07:16:01 PM
Do you want to hold Riewoldt?
I'm going for overall. But I am not sure whether to hold or not. still
Need further injury updates I feel
Hyper extending a knee requires daily assessments, 2 weeks minimum one would think, could be more but that's the risk you take. With an older player St Kilda may want to err on the side of caution so perhaps it's better to trade. You could always use this as an opportunity to restructure. Riewoldt to Higgins and leave some $$ up the sleeve for next week.
What do you think of reading Riewoldt to Adams via dpp ... I got that suggestion from a loyal user and I think it is a great idea.
The other trade however I'm considering is Simpkin to Hannan/butler. Just feel like I need to use both trades this week so I have the 2 free next week- then get sit tight.
So you're going to rely on 3 rookies in the forward line?
If I rely on 3 rookies in the forward line it's one less rookie to worry about in def. don't think it makes much difference to be honest. And we have more flexibility for forward cover via dpp.
Powell Pepper should be on the field. So really its down to Buddy + Stewart/Otten/Hibberd or Adams + Taranto.
as bad as Taranto was id back him in over those 3 defensive rookies every day of the week. Adams v Buddy is much of a muchness.