Best and Fairest!

[ossie85]

Don't insult Dawes, related ;)

But yeah really I think Mick would be disappointed that Didak is his leading goal scorer  :-\

I really doubt he would be. Malthouse has his own set of indicators, individual goal tallies wouldn't be one of them. Look at his 27 years of coaching, he's never had a hugely dominant forward (cept maybe Sumich)

[Alex7089]

Wouldn't you think he would want his power forward (or at least main target) to have more goals than a goalsneak who rotates through mids. Especially at this stage of the season.

[ossie85]

Wouldn't you think he would want his power forward (or at least main target) to have more goals than a goalsneak who rotates through mids. Especially at this stage of the season.

Sure, I regret not going after Barry Hall or Daniel Bradshaw, having said that Dawes has been very good.

Just think Malthouse wouldn't be disappointed with any individual's efforts when looking at goal kicking tallies.

[Alex7089]

I suppose. But if that is what the player is there for you would want him to do it. Cloke has been important for other reasons though, I do get what you're saying.

[Master Q]

Cloke hasn't made a huge impact, not a bad player though.

[Alex7089]

He is good for Collingwoods structure I think he is very important at times.

[ossie85]

Cloke hasn't made a huge impact, not a bad player though.

Cloke's no Setanta, that's for sure

[Alex7089]

Cloke hasn't made a huge impact, not a bad player though.

Cloke's no Setanta, that's for sure

Setanta improved a lot earlier this year. Did he get injured or dropped what happened there?

[ossie85]

Dropped like a sack of spuds

[Alex7089]

Ah disappointing, I think he was improving and could've been a handy.... Y'know what forget it they did the right thing dropping him. :)

[ossie85]

Defenders have traditionally polled well at Collingwood.

Maybe Toov's will get a few votes, top 10 chance perhaps

[Alex7089]

Top 10 in my eyes- (not in order)
Swan
Pendles
Jolly
Wellingham
Beams
Didak
Thomas
Maxwell
Cloke
Presti (:P)

[Master Q]

Cloke hasn't made a huge impact, not a bad player though.

Cloke's no Setanta, that's for sure

True, never said he was.

[ossie85]

Top 10 in my eyes- (not in order)
Swan
Pendles
Jolly
Wellingham
Beams
Didak
Thomas
Maxwell
Cloke
Presti (:P)

Luke Ball over Maxy and Presti, missed too many games. Reckon he'll be top-5.

Decent list! No Harry O?

[bunyip]

Wouldn't the Brownlow Medalist have to be one of your two "A" grade players oss ;D