rnd 12 rookies

[sidvicious]

Which rookie is the best option for Rnd 12 trade

[North Melbournes Finest]

Might be taking both but if I had to get just one it'd be Bytel. Should be playing on the ball most of the game which is where you want your SC guys to be.

[crowls]

Favoring bytel over wicks.   JL always iffy with rooks so who knows how wicks will get used.

[Thewizz71]

Why not have both?

[shaker]

Agree you would think Bytel will play especially with Gresham going down but Wicks is named so will get him first and unless there is other carnage will grab Bytel when named.

[Wanderer]

Wicks is named and has no bye.

[sidvicious]

Why not have both?

Only have one mid rook to trade out

[Samm79]

Wicks is named and has no bye.

This is a factor, but so is Bytel having 18 possies v 9, Wicks 6 tackles v 2 and Wicks had a goal. Bytel in losing team, Wicks winning one. Would be Bytel for me if not for the bye, not so sure now.

[Rusty00]

Wicks is named and has no bye.

This is a factor, but so is Bytel having 18 possies v 9, Wicks 6 tackles v 2 and Wicks had a goal. Bytel in losing team, Wicks winning one. Would be Bytel for me if not for the bye, not so sure now.

I've settled on Wicks purely because of bye reasons.

[Goosey]

What about Xavier O'Halloran?

[kilbluff1985]

What about Xavier O'Halloran?

scored shower and to likely to get dropped next week.....

[Goosey]

What about Xavier O'Halloran?

scored shower and to likely to get dropped next week.....

68 not that shower though?
GWS lack of JS huh?

[bkimm32]

Still a half to go but ohallaran looking better than wicks