Pies All The Way- Team 2016

[AyoubLovesCollingwood]

This is my 1st Time Ever playing AFL Supercoach so I need a bit of help.

DEF: J.Gibson, K.Koldjashniji E,Yeo, N.Malceksi, P.Seedsman, J,Aish, (A,Francis, B,Whitecoss)

MID: P.Dangerfield, G.Abblet, L.Montagna, P.Cripps, D.Rich, D.Thomas, J.Anderson, D.Parish (D.Gore, C.Petracca, R.Mathieson)

RUC: M.Gawn, N.Vardy, (D.Wyatt)

FWD: C.Wingard, M.Barlow, J.Hogan, D.Menzel, D.Wells, M.Cox (T.Phillips, M.Brown *Ess)

Cash: $20,800

[Bully]

Defence - way too much money being spent here and only one player who I would nominate as a guaranteed keeper, you need to start again and spend the money on proven performers.

Mids - way too weak, no Libba? no Rocky? no Crouch? Rich is better in defence, Thomas is better as a forward, Anderson isn't a guy I would pick.

Rucks look very risky, Vardy isn't even a first ruckman.

Forwards seem ok but Hogan I'm not sure about, Cox won't cut it at F6 either.

[AyoubLovesCollingwood]

DEF: E,Yeo, D.Rich, P.Seedsman,J,Aish, J.Weitering, B.Whitecross (A,Francis, M.Dea)

MID: P.Dangerfield, G.Abblet, L.Montagna, T.Rockliff,O,Cripps,T.Liberatore,B.Crouch D.Parish (D.Gore, C.Petracca, R.Mathieson)

RUC: T.Goldstein, M.Lobbe (S.Grimly)

FWD: C.Wingard, M.Barlow,D.Thomas, D.Menzel, D.Wells,J.Simpkim(T.Phillips, M.Brown *Ess)

Cash: $36,200

[Ringo]

Much Better Team here although defence is still a little week.  Would like to see you with one of Shaw, Simpson Laiird as D1 though.
Mids: Not sure I would have Cripps at that price in mids. Wines may be better art a slightly higher price.
Rucks and Forwards sound although just keep an eye on the rookies who play Rd1.

[AyoubLovesCollingwood]

DEF: K.Simpsin,E.Yeo,D.Rich,J,Aish,A,Francis, M.Dea (M.Hartley,R.Bonner)

MID: P.Dangerfield, G.Abblet, L.Montagna, T.Rockliff,O.Wines T.Liberatore,B.Crouch D.Parish (D.Gore, C.Petracca, R.Mathieson)

RUC: T.Goldstein, M.Lobbe (S.Grimly)

FWD: C.Wingard, M.Barlow,D.Thomas, D.Menzel, D.Wells,J.Simpkim(T.Phillips, M.Brown *Ess)

Cash: $39,700

PLAYERS IN BOLD ARE NEW TO THE TEAM!!!

[Discomaniac]

Forwards are weak. Too many midpricers. If you're going to have Montagna why not have him in the forward line. Swap him for JPK, Sloane etc and downgrade Thomas, Menzel, Wells or simpkin to rookie to and upgrade one of them to premo.

[AyoubLovesCollingwood]

DEF: K.Simpsin,E.Yeo,D.Rich,J,Aish,A,Francis, M.Dea (M.Hartley,R.Bonner)

MID: P.Dangerfield, G.Abblet, JP.Kennedy, T.Rockliff,O.Wines T.Liberatore,B.Crouch D.Parish (D.Gore, C.Petracca, R.Mathieson)

RUC: T.Goldstein, M.Lobbe (S.Grimly)

FWD: C.Wingard, M.Barlow,L.Montagna, D.Wells, N.Kommer,M.Brown(T.Phillips,A.Macdonald-Tip)

Cash: $11,300

PLAYERS IN BOLD ARE NEW TO THE TEAM!!!