RATE MY TEAM PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Started by jack33, February 11, 2009, 10:51:13 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

jack33

Chad Cornes
Heath Shaw
Tarkyn Lockyer
Andrew McLeod
Dustin Fletcher
Ryan Houlihan
Jesse Smith

(Stephen Hill)
(Jackson Trengrove)

Kane Cornes
Chris Judd
Chris Masten
Paul Haselby
Hamish Hartlett
Daniel Rich

(Jack Ziebell)
(Tom Swift)

Dean Brogan
Jamie Charman

(Tyrone Vickery)
(John Messen)

Lance Franklin
Johnathon Brown
Brendan Fevola
Jason Porplyzia
Dale Thomas
Scott Lucas
Shaun Higgins

(Chris Yarran)
(Mitch Brown)

What upgrades or trades are needed???

I have 175k in the bank if that helps??

Maybe Brogan to Cox?
or Hartlett to a 260k midfielder?
or Fletcher to Malcheski?
or Thomas for Pavlich/Riewoldt?

Please help!

dylan84

fev un predictable
dont like rucks other than maybe vickery...

and houlihan???? no way

MiGZ

houlihan is ok in my books.

fletcher and mcleod are injury timebombs waiting to happen.

hamish wont play enough.

horrible ruck division. need cox.

and fevola isnt a keeper.


jack33

Updated

Brendan Goddard
Chad Cornes
Heath Shaw
Tarkyn Lockyer
Dustin Fletcher
Ryan Houlihan
Jesse Smith

(Stephen Hill)
(Jackson Trengrove)

Kane Cornes
Chris Judd
Chris Masten
Paul Haselby
Hamish Hartlett
Daniel Rich

(Jack Ziebell)
(Tom Swift)

Dean Cox
Jamie Charman

(Tyrone Vickery)
(John Messen)

Lance Franklin
Johnathon Brown
Jason Porplyzia
Dale Thomas
Patrick Vespremi
Scott Lucas
Shaun Higgins

(Chris Yarran)
(Mitch Brown)


And i have 50k left.
any other moves?

jack33

with my 50k left i upgraded h.hartlett to m.coughlan

dylan84

charman for mcintosh,dont rate meesen at all. no hartlett(hard to crack mids at port) or couglan(hurt knee again) maybe dangerfield.

jack33

i got andrew foster for coughlan??
and then mcintosh for charman

jack33

i got rusling for porplyzia and then upgraded foster to n.foley.

carl giles

jason blake in there!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! JACK DEAN IS A MESS