Why is everyone freaking out? It is only almost the start of round 2. Go to the bathroom and pull yourselves together lol. NA JK. I am in the same boat.
You can never tell what a player is going to do unless their team gives them the ball. If their team has faith in that player this helps make him consistent.
Jump on the AFL site and watch vids of what other team mates say about your player in question. This is where your DT and SC scores will be. Because you know the team has faith and will opt to kick, pass etc to them.
Plain and simple