WXV Trade Confabulation 2018

[GoLions]

I'll argue that Esava Ratugolea has shown more than McKay

I've had a few teams ask about big Sav

Well now, the asking price is a 100+ mid, no older than 30



Not even 12 months ago Joel Selwood was traded for Luke Dunstan + Hugh Greenwood

Selwood and Higgins are basically the same value now, but McKay isn't worth Dunstan + Greenwood

Yea, McKay > Dunstan + Greenwood

Unless SC counts VFL stats? Then Dunstan value will skyrocket.

[RaisyDaisy]

Unless SC counts VFL stats? Then Dunstan value will skyrocket.

16 AFL games this year and 5 VFL games

McKay played more VFL then him!

[elephants]

In what world does Jelwood = Higgins in terms of value

[Holz]

In what world does Jelwood = Higgins in terms of value

I think it is a typo and its Scott or Troy.

Cant be jelly that makes no sense.

[RaisyDaisy]

In what world does Jelwood = Higgins in terms of value

I think it is a typo and its Scott or Troy.

Cant be jelly that makes no sense.

Jelwood averaged 105 and Higgins 103, and they're the same age (few months difference)

Jelwood averaged 102 last year, so for the past 2 years 103.5avg or there abouts

I don't think valuing them the same or similarly is a problem

[Ricochet]

In what world does Jelwood = Higgins in terms of value

I think it is a typo and its Scott or Troy.

Cant be jelly that makes no sense.

Scooter > Higgins

[elephants]

In what world does Jelwood = Higgins in terms of value

I think it is a typo and its Scott or Troy.

Cant be jelly that makes no sense.

Even Troy is probably worth more. Cult hero

[meow meow]

Get your offers in for Toby Greene. Dublin leading the race, Buenos Aires second and Seoul third at the moment.

The winning offer will most likely involve a pick, and another player or pick.

[Purple 77]

Teams left to vote:

Christchurch Saints
Moscow Spetsnaz
Pacific Islanders

[Purple 77]

2 teams left to vote, but all trades have been decided:

Trade 14
Cairo trade: Mitch Honeychurch
Christchurch trade: Pick 49
Votes: 0
Coaches Comments: None
Admin comments: Sweet, JESUS!
Verdict: PASS

Trade 15
London trade: Pick 6
Mexico City trade: Jared Polec + Lewis Jetta
Votes: 0
Coaches Comments: None.
Admin comments: Cool!
Verdict: PASS

Trade 16
PNL trade: Pick 4
Christchurch trade: Gary Ablett Jnr, Bryce Gibbs + Heath Shaw
Votes: 6
Coaches Comments: Felt GAJ or Shaw was unnecessary, expressed concerns about the vacuum created by the departure of three starters for just one pick.
Admin comments: The trade has failed, with me having the power to overturn it. I don't disagree with the coaches enough to overturn it.
Verdict: REJECTED

Trade 17
Christchurch trade: Shaun Higgins
Berlin trade: Harry McKay + Pick 41
Votes: 8
Coaches Comments: Felt the unproven McKay did not warrant a 100+ averaging midfielder, regardless of his age.
Admin comments: Noted!
Verdict: REJECTED

Trade 18
Berlin trade: Charlie Dixon + Jordan Ridley
Tokyo trade: Trent Cotchin + Connor Menadue
Votes: 1
Coaches Comments: *redacted for anonymity*
Admin comments: I, WANNA SWWWIIIIINNNNGGGG, FROM THE MENNNAA-NA-DOOOO, FROM THE MENA-NA-DOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO-OOOOOOO!
Verdict: PASS

[Purple 77]

A reminder that your negs will be forward onto the coaches of the failed trades, anonymously.

[meow meow]

Teams left to vote:

Christchurch Saints
Moscow Spetsnaz
Pacific Islanders

Lies. I would have been one of the first to reply.

[Purple 77]

Teams left to vote:

Christchurch Saints
Moscow Spetsnaz
Pacific Islanders

Lies. I would have been one of the first to reply.

Ah, yes you were :-X

[meow meow]

Legitimate question here folks.

Sinclair is able to be traded for pick 6. Polec able to be traded for pick 6. Higgins isn't able to be traded for McKay because he's unproven.

What's the difference?

[Holz]

Legitimate question here folks.

Sinclair is able to be traded for pick 6. Polec able to be traded for pick 6. Higgins isn't able to be traded for McKay because he's unproven.

What's the difference?

Mckay is the 2nd best KPF i dont think unproven is the correct word. Likely limited upside is a better reason.