Brisbane Discussion

[Ringo]

I believe neither Collingwood or Brisbane would take advantage of this

Yet they want someone like Hanley along with pick 4 ::)

Something like that would be a major advantage to the Pies, no way that would happen. I get Beams is an amazing player, but we're not giving Collingwood an elite player AND pick 4 in exchange for an elite player. Someone like Golby or Crisp along with pick 4 I think is a fair deal, especially with Lumumba going.

Lions want pick 4, which is too cheap

Pies want 4 and Hanley, which is too expensive

This is how negotiations work. The result will be somewhere in the middle

bound to be a lion that doesn't need too much convincing to go to melbourne, just annoyed it wasn't last year and could've nabbed Tyson

Think the end result may either be our first 2 picks or Pick 4 plus Golby/Lester.  As you say Oss both teams will negotiate outcome with Beams welfare main concern.

[kilbluff1985]

it's funny Pies are allowed to ask for overs but if Essendon do it we get laughed at ::)

cos Collingwood haven't breached contract, or at least risked a legal battle

Also Essendon ask overs for every single player that ever comes or goes to the club

i'd rather that then get ripped off every time  ::)

[Mailman the 2nd]

it's funny Pies are allowed to ask for overs but if Essendon do it we get laughed at ::)

cos Collingwood haven't breached contract, or at least risked a legal battle

Also Essendon ask overs for every single player that ever comes or goes to the club

i'd rather that then get ripped off every time  ::)

Well the result is every club that tries to deal w/ Essendon feels like they're trying to get ripped off, hence why people laugh at them

[Ringo]

Come on guys Do not hijack Brisbane Thread with Essendon crap.

[Mailman the 2nd]

Don't think that Crisp or Golby will interest Collingwood as much as Brisbane's 2nd rounder

[ossie85]

Don't think that Crisp or Golby will interest Collingwood as much as Brisbane's 2nd rounder

if we took Karnezis we'd take anyone

[Mailman the 2nd]

Don't think that Crisp or Golby will interest Collingwood as much as Brisbane's 2nd rounder

if we took Karnezis we'd take anyone

That was a swap for Jackson Paine though, two fringe medium forwards, not really the same situation

[Ricochet]

Don't think that Crisp or Golby will interest Collingwood as much as Brisbane's 2nd rounder

Yeh Golby is an iteresting one. Pies already have quite a few defenders who can push into the mids

[strikes91]

Beams isn't contracted next season so if they keep him against his will, he can walk for nothing next season can't he?

Still will get compo which will be the pick after their first pick

He wont be a free agent, so no compensation I think

[Ringo]

Strikes is correct as he is not an unrestricted agent till 2016 so trade will need to be arranged if he plays next year.  he can walk to the preseason draft where he can put conditions on that only Brisbane can match and pies get nothing. Hence why Pies will be interested in a trade this year,

[T Dog]

Hey Ringo....any thoughts on Weardon or Crisps' chances for games?

[Ringo]

Wearden may get games. Had an interrupted season with injuries and when he had games in the NEAFL had some good performances and with a DPP may be worth a shot.  Crisp is a mid and got half a dozen games at the end of the season and performed solidly.  Return of Rich, Redden and possible arrival of Beams will prevent him from getting games unless injury strikes.

[kilbluff1985]

isn't Crisp a good chance for DPP?

[Ringo]

Do not think so KB - Played the majority of his 6 games in the midfield. Only the game against Adelaide he spent a fair bit down forward. Anyway can not see CD moving on 6 games.

[Nige]

Wearden may get games. Had an interrupted season with injuries and when he had games in the NEAFL had some good performances and with a DPP may be worth a shot.  Crisp is a mid and got half a dozen games at the end of the season and performed solidly.  Return of Rich, Redden and possible arrival of Beams will prevent him from getting games unless injury strikes.

Didn't Wearden get delisted?