FanFooty Forum

FanFooty => Supercoach Archive => Archives => 2013 Rate My SC Archive => Topic started by: Donnie Brasco on March 23, 2013, 09:24:14 AM

Title: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on March 23, 2013, 09:24:14 AM
What do you guys think?


Goddard Gibbs Duffield Vlastuin Goodes Pittard (Stevenson Terlich)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Dangerfield Cotchin Wines K.Mitchell O'Meara (Kommer Viney)

Maric Blicavs (Currie Rowe)

Franklin Cox Rockliff S.Johnson Karnezis Macaffer (Neade Lee)

$45,000
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: sammy123 on March 23, 2013, 09:30:54 AM
nice team. 9/10. Cannot fault it

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74834.0.html
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on March 23, 2013, 09:45:51 AM
Thanks Sammy. I'm still a bit worried about the rucks and if Jelwood should be in my midfield or not...
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on April 09, 2013, 09:15:13 AM
27,000 overall, $39,000 and 30 trades...


Goddard Gibbs Duffield Vlastuin Goodes Pittard (Stevenson Terlich)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Dangerfield Cotchin Wines K.Mitchell O'Meara (Kommer Viney)

Maric Blicavs (Daw Rowe)

Franklin Cox Rockliff S.Johnson Karnezis Macaffer (Neade Lee)


Thinking... Karnezis > Kennedy
                Mitchell > Dwyer
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: felsty on April 09, 2013, 10:29:24 AM
I'm doing the exact same trades mate. I would say a lot of blokes are! Very nice team, risky going in with Stevie J but I like it as I can see him pushin out some mammoth scores when he gets in
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Carltonblues5 on April 09, 2013, 11:32:20 AM
Nice team mate not sure about the rucks
I suppose you could put cox for Rowe
Otherwise this is a great team
9/10
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on April 10, 2013, 08:37:32 PM
Not sure guys, should I trade Mitchell or Kommer?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: johnnytheboy1 on April 11, 2013, 11:59:53 AM
Maybe Kommer as he may not hold his spot in the 22 i think Stevens has more of a chance as Port are a weaker team but stevens kicking efficiency would need to pick up. Just look at the teams tonight before deciding. Isee you have kept the faith with Stevie J i hope it pays off
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: geoffmack on April 11, 2013, 04:20:16 PM
All good there johnnytheboy. Am I the only one with Trav Cloke????
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on April 11, 2013, 06:55:04 PM
Thanks guys.

Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on April 15, 2013, 10:19:59 PM
2243, not bad. A few disappointments and moves to think about...


Goddard Gibbs Duffield Goodes Pittard Stevenson (Vlastuin Terlich)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Dangerfield Cotchin Wines O'Meara Viney (Kommer Neade)

Maric Blicavs (Daw Rowe)

Franklin Cox Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Dwyer (Macaffer Lee)


28 trades, only $31,000.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on April 16, 2013, 09:54:14 AM
Should I get rid of Kommer for Crouch, or sit tight...

Any other suggestions?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on April 18, 2013, 06:07:20 PM
Anybody?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on April 18, 2013, 09:34:00 PM
Kommer will waltz straight back into Essendons 22 and continue to make cash so hold.

I would trade McAffer to Crouch using the trading Room moving Neade Forward.

You also have Vlastin not playing so may need to look at that situation.

Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on April 19, 2013, 03:35:17 PM
Cheers Ringo, much appreciated.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on April 24, 2013, 07:46:07 AM
26,000 overall, $87,000 and 26 trades...


Goddard Gibbs Duffield Goodes Pittard Stevenson (Hutchins Terlich)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Dangerfield Cotchin Wines Crouch O'Meara (Kommer Viney)

Maric Rowe (Daw Blicavs)

Franklin Cox Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Dwyer (Neade Lee)
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on April 25, 2013, 10:52:56 AM
Thinking... Viney > Kerridge
                Stevenson > Docherty

Leaving me 24 trades & $270,000.

Thoughts guys?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on April 26, 2013, 10:20:31 AM
Both sound trades Donnie

Stevenson imo has possibly only 2 more price rises anyway so not being named this week trade,

Viney may come back and score big again but is that a risk worth taking.  Interesting choice though in Kerridge what is his JS like in Crows midfield.  Will he be the sub? Would possibly prefer Mayes or Evans.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on April 28, 2013, 07:01:26 PM
You're a wise man Ringo. I screwed up big time, two trades wasted!
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on April 30, 2013, 07:27:19 AM
33,875 overall, $271,500 and 24 trades...


Goddard Gibbs Duffield Goodes Pittard Terlich (Hutchins Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Dangerfield Cotchin Wines O'Meara Kerridge (Kommer Crouch)

Maric Rowe (Daw Blicavs)

Franklin Cox Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Dwyer (Neade Lee)


Stupidly went early on Kerridge and Docherty, last week, so it seems I have wasted a couple of trades. In a pickle, but glad I picked Stevie J from Round 1.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: felsty on April 30, 2013, 02:56:32 PM
Personally I would look at a blicavs downgrade to Gawn and then upgrade Dwyer to a premium ruck or fwd.. The remaining spot in that area should be saved for nicnat
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on April 30, 2013, 05:22:20 PM
Thanks Felsty, I was looking at Gawn, but I'm not sure what you mean by suggesting Dwyer to a premium ruck, how is that possible? Apologies in advance for my amateurish Supercoach knowledge, I'm sure it's obvious.

:-[
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: felsty on May 01, 2013, 09:02:05 AM
Hahah na no problem mate! That's what a forum is for..

In the trade window, after you trade Blicavs > Gawn you can choose to make another trade. Click on Dwyer to trade out and an S should appear next to Rowes name on the side so you can sub him into the forward line, effectively trading Dwyer out for a ruck. It means you lose DPP with Cox and Rowe, however that can be easily replaced later on if you downgrade Blicavs or Gawn..
Does that make sense?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 01, 2013, 09:34:14 AM
Thanks again mate, makes sense. What would you do? Should I worry about my backline or not, I guess everybody has the same issue with all the outs, etc...
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: felsty on May 01, 2013, 12:32:12 PM
i think if you have the cover then go for it.. docherty and hutchins have shown to score well enough when given a full game. all comes down to pittard and what happens.. personally im going to cop the donut and back my players in to get a good enough score to keep me up in the rankings. i really want to get stevie j and gawn into my side and the time is right with blicavs and dwyer hitting the wall. i tried to do the mathematics before and unless i trade out gibbs or goodes now for a premium and save the donut i wont realistically be able to get stevie in next week, and after that it might cost me an extra 100k to get him in. it just matters whats right for you.

personally i would downgrade blicavs to gawn and then look at upgrading your backline. rowe still has a little bit of money to make and could be upgraded to a premium ruck in a week or two. pittard > hartlett, shaw or birchall could be a good idea. only problem with trading out rowe soon for a premium means you lose your r/f link but downgrading gawn or daw when they max out for a mcbean or someone of the sort with r/f dpp and a low price will open that up again
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 01, 2013, 09:28:56 PM
Cheers Felsty, much appreciated. Think I'm going to go...

Blicavs > Gawn
Pittard > Birchall/ Heppell/ Shaw/ Enright

Worried about Hatlett's consistency, body and Port's run, etc.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: felsty on May 02, 2013, 04:57:27 PM
yeah same move here.. ill just pay more for stevie j later.

except im going to jump on hartlett. reckon birchall is a bit too pricey and for me shaw hasnt shown enough just yet to prove he'll be a top six defender.. hartlett spending too much time on the ball to have a poor score i think, and the way port is playing, especially the comebacks against good teams, makes me think that they should be quite a handful for a lot of teams this year..
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 07, 2013, 09:41:07 AM
Like most, had a shocker this week, not even 2000... 35,175 overall, $50,000 and 22 trades.


Goddard Gibbs Duffield Goodes Hartlett Terlich (Hutchins Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Dangerfield Cotchin Wines O'Meara Kerridge (Kommer Crouch)

Maric Rowe (Daw Gawn)

Franklin Cox Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Dwyer (Neade Lee)


A lot to think about this week!
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on May 07, 2013, 09:58:33 AM
Think it is about time you addressed rucks Donnie as this is costing you. I would swap Cox and Rowe as an interim measure playing Cox in the ruck. (You can restore link later if need be).

I would look at trading Hutchins to a rookie who is playing and then Dwyer to a forward you can afford.  Dwyer has reached his ceiling imo.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 07, 2013, 10:41:19 AM
Cheers Ringo, yeah the rucks have been playing on my mind all year. Anybody I should be looking at down back for Hutchins... Staker? Laird? etc.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on May 07, 2013, 05:10:26 PM
Just watch for whoever is named this week and make the cash.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 09, 2013, 08:53:40 PM
What do you think, Ringo & Co, now that Hutchins has been named...


Goddard Gibbs Duffield Goodes Hartlett Terlich (Hutchins Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Dangerfield Cotchin Wines O'Meara Kerridge (Kommer Crouch)

Maric Rowe (Daw Gawn)

Franklin Cox Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Dwyer (Neade Lee)
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on May 10, 2013, 02:26:20 PM
Continue watching who is named when final teams named tonight, Hutchins named on an extended bench - Has a B/e of 50 which he has not achieved in his last 2 games so would still look at downgrading him to possibly Laird if named.

Dwyer to Gray may also be a sound option as I think Dwyer has peaked whereas Gary will make some more coin for you.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 10, 2013, 06:34:17 PM
Thanks again Ringo, what are your thoughts on...

Terlich > Colquhuon
Neade > Thomas

Silly?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on May 10, 2013, 09:15:22 PM
Terlich to Colquhon is a waste at this time.  Terlich has a B/e of only 22 and Colquhon playing first game so can afford to wait on that one.

Neade also has a low B/e which he will achieve this week.

Also need to consider will Thomas be in top 10 forwards and be a keeper in your team.  You need to decide if you answer yes is it worth forgoing cash to get him this week.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 11, 2013, 08:30:00 AM
That's why you're a 'Veteran Coach' Ringo!
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 14, 2013, 10:20:53 AM
Much happier this week 2350, without Cotchin, Hartlett and a donut down back. 19,348 overall, $43,400 and 20 trades.


Goddard Duffield Vlastuin Hartlett Terlich Docherty (Goodes Gibbs)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Dangerfield Cotchin Wines O'Meara Gray (Kommer Crouch)

Maric Daw (Rowe Gawn)

Franklin Cox Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Kerridge (Neade Lee)


Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: felsty on May 14, 2013, 03:28:49 PM
I would make some cash downgrading need to lonergan in the mids, and then upgrading wines to any premium mid or premium defender? your rucks/fwds need attention but there is no point doing that til gawn or majak have hit the wall
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 14, 2013, 06:51:56 PM
Thanks Felsty, all things considered later this week, I'm thinking...

Neade > Staker
Wines > Priddis

Not sure about Lonergan, what do ya' reckon mate?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on May 14, 2013, 07:56:31 PM
What is your intention with Hartlett - He is bleeding cash and plays Carlton this week.

From left field you could downgrade Hartlett to Ibotson or Ellis or a mid priced defender in the 300/400k range and then Wines to Priddis.

Staker may or may not be named so you do not want him straight away.  Neade has a B/e of 71 which he may get close to if he plays or will be stable if he gets rested.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: felsty on May 15, 2013, 10:53:00 AM
I'm not a huge fan of Lonergan.. Personally I'm jumping on Vlastuin instead. I still think he will rise to $350k and will be helpful as a round 11 player during bye rounds.. Staker will be needed later in my opinion to downgrade others who have hit the wall..

Ringo, I also have Hartlett but you have to back him in I feel. Has averaged 90s past two years and should do this again. If he isn't a top 6 defender by the end then ill try and use a trade to upgrade
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 21, 2013, 09:28:37 AM
22,760 overall $100,700 and 18 trades.


Goddard Duffield Goodes Hartlett Terlich Vlastuin (Docherty Gibbs)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Dangerfield Cotchin Priddis O'Meara Kommer (Lonergan Crouch)

Maric Cox (Daw Gawn)

Franklin Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Gray Kerridge (Rowe Lee)
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 22, 2013, 09:13:05 PM
I think I'm going to bring in Staker and NicNat this week... thoughts chaps?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on May 23, 2013, 09:53:09 AM
Unless absolutely necessary I would wait a week for Staker until on boil

I would possibly do Kommer to Thurlow this week bringing Goodes to mids  (Komm3r is getting close to ceiling in my opinion)

Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 23, 2013, 05:42:39 PM
Thanks again Ringo, I hadn't thought about Kommer at all. I like it.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 23, 2013, 09:29:51 PM
You've got me thinking Ringo, how about...

Kommer > Thurlow
Goodes > Watson

Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on May 24, 2013, 08:11:29 AM
Dependent on what your final mids to look like Bringing in Watson now will give you Ablett, Pendles, Danger and Watto with Round 13 bye.  If you think that is fine then go for it but if you think Jelwood may be in your best 8 then I would do Goodes to Selwood.

There are a number of threads on Watto now and the byes for you to digest
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 27, 2013, 07:47:08 PM
2415, very happy this week. 12,075 overall, 17 trades and $227,700.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Hartlett Terlich Vlastuin (Docherty Thurlow)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Dangerfield Cotchin Priddis O'Meara Goodes (Lonergan Crouch)

Maric Cox (Daw Gawn)

Franklin Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Gray Kerridge (Rowe Lee)


I guess Terlich has to go?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on May 27, 2013, 08:09:17 PM
I see you have 2 Goodes so obviously you have a different defender or midfielder please advise which as it may make decisions a little easier.
One option though is Terlich to Gibbs back in form after injury, Possibly at lowest price as well.  Will probably average 30 points per game more than Terlich as well.

Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 27, 2013, 08:39:53 PM
Ha ha, fixed. Sorry mate!

:-[
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on May 27, 2013, 08:46:35 PM
As a suggestion you could go Terlich to Hutchings returning Goodes to defence.
Then Rowe to Natanui.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 27, 2013, 09:38:10 PM
Cheers Ringo, you wouldn't use Gawn instead to keep DPP?

Also, no Staker consideration?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on May 28, 2013, 08:03:50 AM
Staker should be considered but would depend on Team Balance

You could go Terlich to Staker.

With regards DPP Nat will give you that as well as he also has DPP so a nice position to be in and you get rid of a non scoring player.  You can use Gawn though if you wish.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on May 30, 2013, 07:26:08 PM
Thanks again Ringo, I like the look of Hrovat too.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on June 04, 2013, 12:43:28 PM
2075, bit of a shocker. 15 trades and $84,900.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Hartlett Goodes Vlastuin (Docherty Thurlow)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Dangerfield Cotchin Priddis O'Meara Hrovat (Lonergan Crouch)

Maric Cox (Daw Gawn)

Franklin Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Gray Natanui (Kerridge Lee)


Not looking too good this week ha ha!
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on June 06, 2013, 08:17:36 PM
Any suggestions guys? I'm thinking I'll downgrade Lonergan and Gawn...
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on June 09, 2013, 01:52:41 PM
Pretty happy at the moment, went:

Lonergan > Mitchell
Gawn > Nicholls
O'Meara > Watson
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on June 13, 2013, 07:39:46 PM
12 trades, $113,800.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Hartlett Goodes Vlastuin (Docherty Thurlow)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Watson Dangerfield Cotchin Priddis Mitchell (Hrovat Crouch)

Maric Cox (Nicholls Daw)

Franklin Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Gray Natanui (Kerridge Lee)


What do you reckon guys...

Kerridge > Staker/ Sumner/ B.Kennedy

Crouch > K.Martin
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on June 18, 2013, 09:20:18 AM
I'm struggling guys, I'd love your thoughts and advice experts...


10 trades, $133,000.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Hartlett Goodes Vlastuin (Docherty Thurlow)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Watson Dangerfield Cotchin Priddis Mitchell (Hrovat K.Martin)

Maric Cox (Nicholls Daw)

Franklin Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Gray Natanui (Kerridge Staker)


Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on June 18, 2013, 10:04:01 AM
I would look at Daw to Grimley Daw has a high B/e and Grimley will rise in value if named. Highly unlikely you will need this position anyway could even go McBean if desired.
If one of Docherty or Thurlow not named then I would trade to Birchill.  If Birchill is to be in you final team then would do this regardless as Birchill will never be cheaper.

Kerridge to Daniher after Byes,

To finalise team and for added flexibility when upgrading Martin or Hrovat I would upgrade via Gray to the final prem forward of you choosing, Would allow you to sit Gray at M9 with DPP allowing flexibility.
Other Upgrade to a Defender via Goodes or Vlastuin possibly also downgrading Thurlow to Oxley for DPP as well.
Leaves you with this team and 4 trades going into finals.

Goddard, Duffield, Gibbs, Hartlett, Birchill, Prem (Goodes, Oxley)
Ablett, Pendleberry, Kennedy, Watson, Dangerfield, Cotchin, Priddis, Mitchell (Vlastuin, Gray)
Maric, Cox (Nicholls, Grimley/McBean)
Franklin, Rockliff, Johnson, Kennedy, Natanui, Prem (Staker, Daniher)

Your team though
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: tor01doc on June 18, 2013, 10:52:31 AM
Gray -> Dusty?

Birchall is the other guy pressing for SC selection this week I think.

Vlastuin to Birchall but only if you want Birchall for sure.

All your guys look like they're still making money for you so no rush at all.

Obviously Kerridge is the other one to go.

I wonder whether you can find a cheap forward to save Kerridge's predicted drop. Ideally he doesn't get selected and then you can grab Walker and Daniher after their bye for Kerridge and Gray.

You could get Walker this week as you have cover anyway.

Probably don't need to trade anyone this week.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on June 18, 2013, 12:54:19 PM
Cheers Ringo and Tor, much appreciated. You both have good ideas and make sense. I like it!
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on June 19, 2013, 09:30:22 AM
Sorry boys, I forgot to make it clear that I have Tom Mitchell, and not Sammy, in my mids... does that drastically change things, what are your thoughts? Thanks guys.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Hartlett Goodes Vlastuin (Docherty Thurlow)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Watson Dangerfield Cotchin Priddis T.Mitchell (Hrovat K.Martin)

Maric Cox (Nicholls Daw)

Franklin Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Gray Natanui (Kerridge Staker)
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on June 19, 2013, 10:36:05 AM
Realised it was T Mitchell

As per my post Upgrade Gray to a mid prem in due course. Mitchell if he maintains form is good enough to either play as M8 or sit at M9 with the option of paying Vlas over him if going with my suggestions. With Vlas there and he is stinking it up could bring Gibbs or Goddard in and play Vlas in defence as well. Plenty of options if you utilise the DPP.

Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on June 19, 2013, 11:31:07 AM
Ha ha, all good. Thanks again mate.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on June 28, 2013, 03:33:47 PM
8 trades, $77,500.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Hartlett Birchall Vlastuin (Docherty Goodes)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Watson Dangerfield Cotchin Priddis T.Mitchell (Hrovat K.Martin)

Maric Cox (Nicholls Grimley)

Franklin Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Gray Natanui (Kerridge Staker)


Would I be silly to bring in Oxley for Docherty?



Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on June 28, 2013, 04:15:37 PM
Not necessary this week unless you need cash for upgrades, Probably if named as sub would consider but not really necessary.  Another option to consider is Birchall to Lamb or Sphanger via Staker. And your choice of  Vlas, Goodes or Docherty to a prem you can afford, 
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on June 29, 2013, 09:51:48 AM
Cheers Ringo, I ended up going:

Birchall > Lamb
Goodes > Shaw

Leaving me with 6 trades and $243,000. I stuffed up, trading Goodes and forgot that you couldn't reverse because of Thursday night's game.

:-[
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on June 29, 2013, 10:35:47 AM
Shaw will not let you down and 78 from Lamb is reasonable if he was emergency only. Got caught earlier in the year with no reverse trades so each week now just play around early in the week and reverse trades but then only do any trades involving the first teams prior to lockout.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on July 02, 2013, 08:52:32 AM
6 trades, $243,500.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Shaw Hartlett Vlastuin (Staker Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Watson Dangerfield Cotchin Priddis T.Mitchell (Hrovat K.Martin)

Maric Cox (Nicholls Grimley)

Franklin Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Gray Natanui (Lamb Kerridge)


What do you think guys...

Kerridge > Oxley/ Daniher
K.Martin > Bartel/ Walker (via Gray)
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: _wato on July 02, 2013, 10:25:24 AM
Quote from: Donnie Brasco on July 02, 2013, 08:52:32 AM
6 trades, $243,500.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Shaw Hartlett Vlastuin (Staker Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Watson Dangerfield Cotchin Priddis T.Mitchell (Hrovat K.Martin)

Maric Cox (Nicholls Grimley)

Franklin Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Gray Natanui (Lamb Kerridge)


What do you think guys...

Kerridge > Oxley/ Daniher
K.Martin > Bartel/ Walker (via Gray)


Very sound trades mate, I'd do it straightaway, then leave that team as you'll need 4 trades for LTI's between now and finals.
I'd do Kerridge to Oxley, giving you the DPP between defence and forward, then get Bartel giving you that DPP between Mids and Fwds which will become extremely important come the end of the season. Gray can be M9 and F6 depending on the situation, and I like that. You'll also have $160,000 in the bank for luxury trades if you go well with injuries! Mitchell to Griffen or Vlas to Heppell/Ibbo, your choice. Well done mate, hope that makes sense :)
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on July 03, 2013, 09:16:09 AM
Cheers Wato, I can't think of any better options, but of course now Docherty is a worry...

Any other suggestions would be greatly appreciated (calling my old mate Ringo ha ha)
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on July 04, 2013, 11:24:17 AM
You really do not have to trade at all unless something unforseen happens with team announcements. Lamb should cover Johnson and  Staker could cover Vlas if required.

Martin has a B/e of 11 so will rise in value for next week.

If Lamb not named or named as sub I would consider Kerridge to Bartel. Walker or even Tippett.Would complete your forward line leaving bench as Gray and Lamb when Johnson finishes suspension.

Would then look at Martin to a prem defender via Vlas and downgrading Nichols to McBean to give DPP to rucks as well.


Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on July 09, 2013, 11:50:05 AM
5 trades, $22,000.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Shaw Hartlett Vlastuin (Staker Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Watson Dangerfield Cotchin Priddis T.Mitchell (Hrovat K.Martin)

Maric Cox (Nicholls Grimley)

Franklin Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Bartel Natanui (Gray Lamb)


Thanks again Ringo, ended up completing my forward line. Shame about Watson, can't keep a player for 6 weeks!
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Mat0369 on July 09, 2013, 03:15:55 PM
You don't have a lot of cash or trades which is a slight problem. You either need to trade Watson to a cheaper premium or downgrade Vlas, run with Staker as D6 and upgrade Watson to Griffen. It is risky doing the second option as you will need to use 2 trades. The other option I can see is to shifty Stevie J into the middle, play Gray and downgrade Watson for cash so that way you upgrade Vlas closer to finals
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on July 11, 2013, 06:56:29 PM
Cheers Matty, I've got a lot to think about... I've had a throbbing headache all week ha ha!
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on July 12, 2013, 06:24:12 AM
What to do with Watson...


5 trades, $22,000.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Shaw Hartlett Vlastuin (Staker Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Watson Dangerfield Cotchin Priddis T.Mitchell (Hrovat K.Martin)

Maric Cox (Nicholls Grimley)

Franklin Rockliff S.Johnson J.Kennedy Bartel Natanui (Gray Lamb)
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Vinny on July 13, 2013, 12:47:16 AM
Andrew Walker !

Avg of 108 - So not far off Selwood Cotchin JPK Jack.

DPP will be gold come finals - You can swap around with SJ Rocky and Jimmy.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on July 13, 2013, 09:28:56 AM
Cheers Vinny, I like it! Would you even consider good, old, reliable Boomer? He looks pretty fresh and determined...
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on July 16, 2013, 08:06:05 AM
4 trades, $39,000.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Shaw Hartlett Vlastuin (Staker Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Dangerfield Cotchin Priddis S.Johnson T.Mitchell (Hrovat K.Martin)

Maric Cox (Nicholls Grimley)

Franklin Rockliff J.Kennedy Bartel Natanui A.Walker (Gray Lamb)


To trade or not to trade, that is the question fellas'...


Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on July 16, 2013, 08:34:42 AM
I would wait and see what shakes down this week injury wise.  Dangerfield will definitely be out, Johnson will be missing for a week and Nat under an injury cloud.

You can field a team to cover but would leave little coverage on bench for late outs by using your DPP's.  Unless you have to win to stay in the 8 I would not trade unless needed to for a LTI eg Danger more than 4 or Nat sent to surgery early.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on July 22, 2013, 09:51:44 AM
4 trades, $39,000.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Shaw Hartlett Staker (Vlastuin Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Cotchin Priddis S.Johnson T.Mitchell Hrovat (Dangerfield K.Martin)

Maric Nicholls (Natanui Grimley)

Rockliff J.Kennedy Bartel Cox A.Walker Gray (Franklin Lamb)


Quite a few worries... Dangerfield, Natanui, Franklin, etc.

Downgrade Natanui to McBean?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on July 22, 2013, 10:09:14 AM
Do you have to win the next 2 weeks if not I would sit.

If you have to win I would go one of these 2 options:
Franklin to rookie (Maybe Oxley to create DPP) and Hrovat or Martin to mid you can afford
Naitanui to McBean and Hrovat or Martin to a mid you can afford

Will leave 2 trades for finals.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on July 22, 2013, 11:28:16 AM
Thanks again Ringo, as always, words of wisdom. Unfortunately, I do have to win the next two. If you were in my shoes, what would you do? I'm more in favour of the Oxley move, but of course I'll change my mind daily ha ha...
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on July 22, 2013, 04:59:55 PM
If you like Risks rather than Oxley How about Henderson from crows has the DPP for Staker and makes 52k as a direct swap with Franklin. Also Henderson will be playing whereas Oxley may not. Discovered this today in my own research as a trade for Goodes.  I am keeping Danger for finals as a POD.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on July 30, 2013, 08:37:30 PM
2 trades, $55,900 left... I have to win this week to make finals in two of my leagues...

What should I do? What would you guys do? Thanks in advance chaps, much appreciated!


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Shaw Hartlett Staker (Vlastuin Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Griffen Cotchin Priddis S.Johnson T.Mitchell (Dangerfield K.Martin)

Maric Cox (Nicholls Grimley)

Rockliff J.Kennedy Bartel A.Walker Franklin Gray (Lamb McBean)
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on July 31, 2013, 07:00:18 AM
Rucks are looking grim, but everywhere seems ok, doesn't it?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on July 31, 2013, 09:35:38 AM
Is it a must win to get into the 8.

If it is and Dangerfield is named I would go Martin to a rookie priced mid Boston, Carter or similar

Nicholls to Goldy or Minson.

Mitchell will be your M9

Bring Cox back to Forwards giving you the option of who to bench with McBean giving the Ruck DPP.

If it is not necessary to win to get into 8 not top 4 then I would sit.
Look at your oponnents teams and see whether you can win without trading as well.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on August 01, 2013, 08:43:41 PM
Cheers Ringo, and thanks again for all your great help throughout the year, very much appreciated!

Once again, I've taken your 'old wise owl' advice and have decided to sit tight, the only move I've made is to restore Stevie J to my forward line and Robbie Gray as M9. Leaves me with 2 trades and $55,900

Not too bad a team, even if I do say so myself, ha ha...


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Shaw Hartlett Staker (Vlastuin Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Griffen Cotchin Priddis Dangerfield T.Mitchell (Gray K.Martin)

Maric Cox (Nicholls Grimley)

Rockliff J.Kennedy Bartel A.Walker Franklin Stevie J (Lamb McBean)

 
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on August 05, 2013, 11:46:35 AM
Pretty happy, I've made the finals in all of my leagues.

2 trades, $55,900 left, where to now...


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Shaw Hartlett Staker (Vlastuin Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Griffen Cotchin Priddis Dangerfield T.Mitchell (Gray K.Martin)

Maric Cox (Nicholls Grimley)

Rockliff J.Kennedy Bartel A.Walker Franklin S.Johnson (Lamb McBean)


As per your advice Ringo, do I downgrade Martin then upgrade Nicholls, swing Cox forward and possibly Stevie, Jimmy, Rocky or Walker into the middle?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on August 05, 2013, 12:43:53 PM
Where did you finish in leagues if top 4 I would sit but if you finished bottom 4 and in must win situation check out your opponents team try to anticipate his trades and the trade to win even if only one trade.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on August 13, 2013, 07:58:07 AM
This is it! I lost all of my first finals. Calling all experts... (I'm playing Crawf in one of my matches.)

2 trades, $55,900 left.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Shaw Hartlett Staker (Vlastuin Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Griffen Cotchin Priddis Dangerfield T.Mitchell (Gray K.Martin)

Maric Cox (Nicholls Grimley)

Rockliff J.Kennedy Bartel A.Walker Franklin S.Johnson (Lamb McBean)


Cheers guys!
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on August 13, 2013, 09:32:48 AM
Will give you a couple of Options. Like most of us wish we had a trade or 2 left.

Nicholls to Grundy - Martin to Hanley via Vlastuin gives you the Def/Mid DPP/
Nicholls to Grundy - Mitchell to Swan
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on August 13, 2013, 10:43:03 AM
Cheers Ringo, I like both, slightly leaning more towards the midfield move. What are your thoughts on Selwood?

Saw Hanley firsthand, against us on the weekend, kicked a very good goal. Becoming a great player!
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on August 13, 2013, 02:48:46 PM
Just think Swan may outscore him but either way can not go wrong. Look at opponents team and select accordingly Swan owned by 40% of Teams and Selwood 30%.

Swans draw - Hawthorn, Eagles and North (scored 136 against North and 91 against Hawks in early rounds)
Jelwoods draw - Eagles, Swans, and Lions. (scored 163 against Swans and 135 against Lions in early rounds this year. May be a handy choice for GF as game is at skilled)
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on August 27, 2013, 09:55:34 AM
Very happy 2411 this week, in 2/3 Grand Finals. Selwood loophole helped, as did Gray as a late-in for Walker. A few disappointments, though.


Goddard Duffield Gibbs Shaw Vlastuin Staker (Hartlett Docherty)

Ablett Pendlebury Selwood Kennedy Griffen Cotchin Priddis Dangerfield (Gray K.Martin)

Maric Cox (Grundy Grimley)

Rockliff J.Kennedy Bartel A.Walker Franklin S.Johnson (Lamb McBean)


Loophole is going to be challenging this week, as is my backline... Love to hear your thoughts guys?

Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on August 27, 2013, 04:10:15 PM
Do you have any trades left Donnie or did use both.

Watch your opponents move in the main league that you want to win and make your moves to counter.

Personally think Grundy will out score JJ Kennedy so will move Cox back to forward and moving JJK to bench.
If Docherty is named in centre again would play him over both Staker and Vlaustin.

With Sydney playing first I am looking at maybe JPK as VC to start and then weigh up Captain options. Hanneberry not playing and we seen that when a mid does not play taking points of JPK he increases scoring. (remember when Mitchell did not play last week JPK went 136)
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on August 27, 2013, 06:25:34 PM
Thanks again Ringo.

Unfortunately, I have no trades left. As Hartlett is still suspended, who would you play out of Staker and Vlaustin, providing Docherty is named in the middle?

JPK makes a lot of sense, who are you thinking as backup... Selwood (Raines, but at SS), dare I say it, Ablett, Pendles or Griffen (injured?), Stevie J or Rocky?
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Ringo on August 27, 2013, 06:49:38 PM
Toss the coin between Staker and Vlas as both are about equal.

Will either go Pendles or Stevie J for Captain if JPK does not work.
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Donnie Brasco on September 02, 2013, 10:39:37 AM
Very happy 2460 this week, won my main Grand Final, lost the other two convincingly. 13,015 overall, not too bad.

Thanks again for all your help this year guys, especially Ringo! Most importantly, carn the Tiges this week!
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Sabretooth Tigers on September 23, 2013, 12:46:14 AM
 :)
Congratulations on the 100 replies DB.    ;)
Title: Re: A wise guy's always right even when he's wrong, he's right...
Post by: Vinny on September 23, 2013, 12:47:30 AM
Haha ^ ;D