2020 Player X v Player y

[tommy10]

who out of Georgiades, Davis and King? this will be for F7

Davis

[Wanderer]

Z.Guthrie vs Roberton?

Guthrie gives me the cash to get a higher priced rookie that is playing vs having a non-playing rookie like Williams.
I don't know anything about Guthrie JS but his Marsh scores weren't bad.

[Wanderer]

who out of Georgiades, Davis and King? this will be for F7

Davis

It's a toss up between Davis and Georgiadis. Davis slightly cheaper but I went with Georgiadis because they are playing GC.

[Slick5]

Sicily or Houston?

[tkringle]

who out of Georgiades, Davis and King? this will be for F7

Davis

It's a toss up between Davis and Georgiadis. Davis slightly cheaper but I went with Georgiadis because they are playing GC.

Yeah i've decided to go with Georgiades as well..

[Wanderer]

Sicily or Houston?

I went with Sicily because Hawks have more key position defenders this year, so you would think Sicily plays that sweeper role, the way Howe did last night, and it looks like a higher scoring role under the new format. If Houston didn't have a good finish last year I wouldn't even be considering him.
FWIW, Sicily first three games vs GCS/ADEL/NTH, Houston BRIS/FREO/COLL. I can see lots of intercept marks and link up plays out of the backline for Sicily to start the year.

[Samsturmfels]

Z.Guthrie vs Roberton?

Guthrie gives me the cash to get a higher priced rookie that is playing vs having a non-playing rookie like Williams.
I don't know anything about Guthrie JS but his Marsh scores weren't bad.

I have both and very unconvinced that either be worth it in the long-term. I'd probably get roberton as is way more likely to be a more reliable sc player. If possible i'd try and get cash from somewhere else.

[Wanderer]

Z.Guthrie vs Roberton?

Guthrie gives me the cash to get a higher priced rookie that is playing vs having a non-playing rookie like Williams.
I don't know anything about Guthrie JS but his Marsh scores weren't bad.

I have both and very unconvinced that either be worth it in the long-term. I'd probably get roberton as is way more likely to be a more reliable sc player. If possible i'd try and get cash from somewhere else.

The way I see it is Guthrie saves me 75K. If Guthrie can stay within 15 points average of Roberton, then it would be worth it. Lets say Roberton scores 80 average, you would think Guthrie could manage a 65. The only problem is I have no idea what Guthrie's JS is like.

[backpocket]

Sicily v Laird
Houston v Brodie Smith

Got a sneaky feeling Smith is going close to 100 this year.

[North Melbournes Finest]

Sicily v Laird
Houston v Brodie Smith

Got a sneaky feeling Smith is going close to 100 this year.

I would love Laird over Sicily, but I'm about $400 short and can't work out how to manage that. Laird and Houston.

[North Melbournes Finest]

Sicily or Houston?

[SilverLion]

Doedee + Roberton (1 trade needed) vs Rivers + Howe (2 trades needed)

[whynot102]

Option 2 I traded out Roberton for Howe this week

Doedee + Roberton (1 trade needed) vs Rivers + Howe (2 trades needed)

[frenzy]

Sicily or Houston?

both were ave rnd 1, but probably Sic just.

[SilverLion]

Townsend + Rivers (can loop with Starcevich) vs. Doedee + Cameron (can loop with Brander)