Player X v Player Y

[tkringle]

Sloane or Menegola?

Very tough one.

I'd go Sloane as have Essendon and they shouldn't or can't tag.

With Geelong missing Selwood/Duncan a lot more attention could be given to there second tier mids

Thanks. Yeah I've been undecided between these two all week. Was originally going to get in Neale but wouldn't leave me enough $$ to upgrade Lynch to anyone decent..

One more - play Lloyd or Shaz?

[SilverLion]

Sloane or Menegola?

Very tough one.

I'd go Sloane as have Essendon and they shouldn't or can't tag.

With Geelong missing Selwood/Duncan a lot more attention could be given to there second tier mids

Thanks. Yeah I've been undecided between these two all week. Was originally going to get in Neale but wouldn't leave me enough $$ to upgrade Lynch to anyone decent..

One more - play Lloyd or Shaz?

Unfortunately, gotta play Lloyd IMO.

[Mark]

Dusty..

What order ?

Nank-Greenwood-WHE ??

Greenwood-WHE-Nank

Agreed UNLESS Soldo gets dropped. Nank top of the pile in that case for mine.

Yep if Nank becomes sole ruck then he would go from 3rd to 1st.

I would have Nank over WHE regardless

So with Soldo playing would the order stay the same...

Greenwood-WHE-Nank still guys ??

[petefisker]

Who to bring in?
Billings v Melb
Vs
Sicily vs north
Vs
Kennedy vs Blues @home

[GCSkiwi]

Who to bring in?
Billings v Melb
Vs
Sicily vs north
Vs
Kennedy vs Blues @home

Considering the draw beyond this round I went for Billings

[SilverLion]

Dusty..

What order ?

Nank-Greenwood-WHE ??

Greenwood-WHE-Nank

Agreed UNLESS Soldo gets dropped. Nank top of the pile in that case for mine.

Yep if Nank becomes sole ruck then he would go from 3rd to 1st.

I would have Nank over WHE regardless

So with Soldo playing would the order stay the same...

Greenwood-WHE-Nank still guys ??

Yup. IMO anyways :)

[B.]

Field 2 in defence

Ryan, Roberton, Lloyd, Scharenberg

[Jesty]

Field 2 in defence

Ryan, Roberton, Lloyd, Scharenberg

Ryan and Roberton.

[Jesty]

Jelwood > Gibbs, Hanners or Menegola?
That my price range.

[Ringo]

I've gone Menegola based on the fact Jelwood is out and Danger will get the attention. But with my curse of death you may want to consider Hanners with Swans wanting to continue winning games.

[Jesty]

Think I'll join you.
Now lets sit back and watch Hanners knock out 160. Lol

[mzunguman]

Zerrett or Beams???

[GCSkiwi]

Zerrett or Beams???

Beams is the one in form, just keep your fingers crossed!

Can't believe I'm asking this at this stage, but:

Dylan Mountford vs Luke Ryan? Got Witherden as a swingman, Hurley and Neale both out. So will play Witherden plus one of the others, surely Ryan?

[Ringo]

Surely Ryan will not have 2 bad games in a row.

Jack Martin v Michael Hibberd v Brodie Smith

[GCSkiwi]

Surely Ryan will not have 2 bad games in a row.

Jack Martin v Michael Hibberd v Brodie Smith

For Hurley? I'd go with Hibberd, but I'd have a serious think about whether you can afford to hold, reckon Witherden could be ok cover...